VALENCY RULE AND ALLEGED HOFMEISTER SERIES IN THE COLLOIDAL BEHAVIOR OF PROTEINS : II. THE INFLUENCE OF SALTS.

Loeb J, Kunitz M. · 1923

Read VALENCY RULE AND ALLEGED HOFMEISTER SERIES IN THE COLLOIDAL BEHAVIOR OF PROTEINS : II. THE INFLUENCE OF SALTS. by Loeb J, Kunitz M. (1923) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2140583.txt.

Introduction

Jacques Loeb and Kunitz attacked the Hofmeister series in a 1923 paper, part two of their valency rule study. Old colloid work ranked salts in a fixed series, the Hofmeister series, by their effects on proteins. Loeb held that ranking to be an artifact. The pair review old experiments and add new ones on gelatin chloride.

For membrane potentials, osmotic pressure, swelling, and particle-swelling viscosity, a salt's effect depends only on the valency of its anion. It does not depend on the anion's chemical nature. The cation has no effect, so long as acidity stays unchanged. The famous series arose, they argue, because earlier workers failed to measure and match the acidity of their protein solutions. Properties outside membrane equilibria, such as solubility, may behave differently.

Catalog record

CREATORLoeb J, Kunitz M.
YEAR1923
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2140583

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

VALENCY RULE AND ALLEGED HOFMEISTER SERIES IN THE COLLOIDAL BEHAVIOR OF PROTEINS By Jacques Loeb, M. Kunitz Published in: The Journal of General Physiology DOI: 10.1085/jgp.5.5.693 ABSTRACT It is shown by the older experiments by Loeb and by the experiments reported in this paper that the effect of salts on the membrane potentials, osmotic pressure, swelling of gelatin chloride, and that type of viscosity which is due to the swelling of protein particles, depends only on the valency but not on the chemical nature of the anion of the salt, and that the cation of the salt has no effect on these properties, if the pH of the protein solution or protein gel is not altered by the salt. The so called Hofmeister series of salt effects on these four properties are purely fictitious and due to the failure of the former authors to measure the hydrogen ion concentration of their protein solutions or gels and to compare the effects of salts at the same pH of the protein solution or the protein gel. These results confirm the older experiments of Loeb and together they furnish a further proof for the correctness of the idea that the influence of electrolytes on the four properties of proteins is determined by membrane equilibria. Such properties of proteins which do not depend on membrane equilibria, such as solubility or cohesion, may be affected not only by the valency but also by the chemical nature of the ions of a salt. VALENCY RULE AND ALLEGED HOFMEISTER SERIES IN THE COLLOIDAL BEHAVIOR OF PROTEINS. II. THE INFLUENCE OF SALTS. BY JACQUES LOEB Am) M. KUNITZ. (From the Laboratories of The Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research.) (Received for publication, March 20, 1923.) Difference between the Action of Acids and of Salts on Colloidal Behavior. In order to understand the action of salts on colloidal behavior, it is necessary to understand the difference between the action of acids and of salts. When acid is added to a solution of isoelectric protein, the membrane potentials, osmotic pressure, and, in the case of some proteins (e.g. gelatin), viscosity, are first increased until a maximum is reached; and when more acid is added, the values representing these properties drop again. The action of acid on the swelling of gelatin is the same, since the swelling due to acid is merely an osmotic phe- nomenon. This rise and fall of the curves for these four properties finds its explanation through the following facts. The addition of acid to isoelectric protein has two opposite effects; first, a salt forma- tion between protein and acid, which increases the concentration of ionized protein, and this causes a rise in the value of the four properties mentioned with the addition of acid; and second, the depressing influence of the anion of the acid on the value of the four properties. Both effects increase with the increase in the concentration of acid, but not at the same rate. When little acid is added to isoelectric protein, the salt formation and ionization of the protein increases at first more rapidly than the depressing effect of the anion of the acid until a point is reached where the further addition of acid increases the ionization little, and finally not at all, while the depressing effect of the anion of the acid continues to increase. This peculiar action of 693 The Journal of General Physiology 694 COLLOIDAL BEHAVIOR OF PROTEINS. II the acid finds its explanation in the theory of membrane equilibria, as shown in preceding papers and a book.1 If this theory of membrane equilibria is correct, we should expect that, when the protein salt is a salt of the type of gelatin chloride, where the gelatin ion is positively charged, only the anion of an acid (or a salt) should influence the four properties dependent on the mem- brane equilibrium, namely membrane potentials, osmotic pressure, swelling, and that type of viscosity which is due to the swelling of protein particles; and furthermore, that only the valency of the anion but not its chemical nature should have an effect (unless these properties are affected in an indirect way by a change in the chemical or physical constitution of the protein by a specific acid). The validity of the valency rule has already been discussed for acids and will be discussed more fully here for salts. The difference between the action of salts and acids on the four properties of protein is this, that while acids (and alkalies) cause ionization of isoelectric protein, salts have no such effect. When a salt is added to a solution of a protein salt, e.g. gelatin chloride, of a given pH, only the depressing action of the anion of the salt on these properties is noticed, but no augmenting effect of the cation of the salt. This was proved by Loeb by the following two sets of experi- ments. When all the protein is ionized, e.g. when gelatin chloride of pH 2.5 is chosen, HC1 and NaC1 act quantitatively alike, since now no further ionization can be produced by the acid. When, however, the pH of the gelatin chloride is higher (but below pH 4.7), the addition of little acid will cause an increase in the values of the four properties which will not be produced by the salt? The second proof consisted in the fact that if the pH of the protein solution is kept constant, salts of the type of NaCI, CaC12, and LaCla will have an equal depressing effect on the properties of protein-acid salts for the same concentration of the C1 ions of the three salts, at the same pH of the protein solution or protein gel. This was proven for membrane potentials and osmotic pressure.~ i Loeb,J., Proteins and the theoryofcolloidalbehavior,New York and London, 1922. Loeb,J., d. Gem Physiol., 1921-22,iv, 752. Hitchcock,D. I., J. Gen. Physiol., 1921-22, iv, 597. JACQUES LOEB AND ~. K-UIWITZ 695 If the explanation of these effects of salts on the basis of the norman equation is correct, it follows furthermore that only the anion of a salt should have a depressing effect on the four properties of protein- acid salts, and only the cation of a salt should have a depressing effect on the properties of metal proteinates. Loeb has already shown that this is correct~and it is intended to add in this paper some further experimental evidence. This was considered advisable on account of the fact that some authors continue to maintain that for the action of salts on proteins the Hofmeister series are valid. Those who be- lieve in the validity of the Hofmeister series for the action of salts on the four above mentioned properties of proteins arrange the effect of salts on the swelling of gelatin in the following way SO4, tartrate, citrate < acetate < C1 < Br, NO3 < I < CNS where the swelling is said to be a maximum in CNS and a minimum in SOs. "Above a certain concentration the sulfates, tartrates, and citrates cause a shrinkage of the gel of gelatin, and acetate acts in the same sense but less strongly, while the other anions cause an increasing swelling of the gel of

Read the complete text