COMPARATIVE STUDIES OF HERPETOMONADS AND LEISHMANIAS : II. DIFFERENTIATION OF THE ORGANISMS BY SEROLOGICAL REACTIONS AND FERMENTATION TESTS.
Noguchi H. · 1926
Read COMPARATIVE STUDIES OF HERPETOMONADS AND LEISHMANIAS : II. DIFFERENTIATION OF THE ORGANISMS BY SEROLOGICAL REACTIONS AND FERMENTATION TESTS. by Noguchi H. (1926) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2131776.txt.
Introduction
Hideyo Noguchi wrote part two of his comparative studies of herpetomonads and leishmanias in 1926. Both are small flagellate parasites, the leishmanias in man and animals, the herpetomonads mostly in insects and plants. Telling them apart matters for naming what infects a patient. Noguchi applied serum reactions and sugar fermentation tests to a set of strains.
Twelve herpetomonad strains from insects and plants proved unrelated by serum tests to any leishmania, and their sugar behavior also set them apart. Seven strains from milkweeds and the bugs that feed on them fell into just two kinds, named for the bugs they first came from. The two kinds showed some group reaction in serum, but split cleanly on carbohydrates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Noguchi H. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1926 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
COMPARATIVE STUDIES OF HERPETOMONADS AND LEISHMANIAS By Hideyo Noguchi Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.44.3.327 ABSTRACT Serological reactions and fermentation tests have been employed in the present investigation as a means of differentiating various strains of herpetomonads from one another as well as from leishmanias. The twelve strains of herpetomonads isolated from insects and plants all proved to be serologically unrelated to any of the leishmanias, and were distinguishable from them by the manner in which they affected various carbohydrates. Three of the strains of herpetomonads tested had been isolated from milkweeds (Asclepias syriaca and A. nivea) and four from bugs which feed on the latices of these plants (Oncopeltus fasciatus, Oncopeltus sp.? from Peru, and Lygæus kalmii). When tested for their serological and carbohydrate-fermenting properties, however, the seven strains proved to be of two kinds only, one represented by the strain first isolated from Oncopeltus fasciatus) and hence named H. oncofelti, the other by H. lygæorum, so named because it was first isolated from Lygæus kalmii. Serologically there was a certain degree of group reaction among the flagellates of these two types, but in their action upon carbohydrates they were entirely different, H. oncopelti splitting thirteen carbohydrates, H. lygæorum only three. Three strains of herpetomonads isolated from flies proved to be distinct both in serological properties and in their action upon carbohydrates. One, derived from the house fly, and called H. muscidarum, was able to ferment most of the carbohydrates tested, including lactose which was not affected by any of the other strains. The other two, isolated from bluebottle flies, behaved much the same as the leishmanias with regard to carbohydrate fermentation, attacking five of the same sugars. One of them fermented galactose in addition, the other both galactose and inulin. Two strains from mosquitoes (Anopheles and Culex) behaved identically in serological reactions and also in fermentation tests. They are regarded as one species and have been named H. culicidarum. This organism ferments thirteen sugars, including amygdalin which no other organism of the series attacks. One of the most striking phenomena observed was the entire lack of fermentative faculty on the part of Herpetomonas ctenocephali and Trypanosoma rotatorium. Neither of these organisms was affected by any of the immune sera prepared with other flagellates. The serological specificity of Leishmania tropica, L. brasiliensis, and L. donovani, and the close relation between L. donovani and L. infantum were confirmed in the present study. These organisms could not, however, be differentiated by fermentation tests. The data presented suggest that the biological characteristics of flagellates of the Herpetomonas group may be utilized with advantage for identification of a species which occurs in different environments and for separation of different species when they are found in the same environment. If the leishmania parasites pass the flagellated or herpetomonad stage of their life history in some invertebrate host, it may be possible by tests of the sort described to distinguish them from the non-pathogenic herpetomonads which are so widely distributed among insects and plants. COMPARATIVE STUDIES OF HERPETOMONADS AND LEISHMANIAS. II. DIFFERENTIATION OF THE 9RGANISMS BY SEROLOGICAL REACTIONS AND FERMENTATION TESTS. BY HIDEYO NOGUCHI, M.D. (From the Laboratories of The RockefellerInstitute for Medical Research.) (Received for publication, March 16, 1926.) Rogers, who first cultivated the parasite of kala-azarI and found that under cultural conditions it acquired a flagellum and became morpho- logically indistinguishable from the herpetomonads so widely dis- tributed in nature as parasites of insects and plants, suggested that the organism might pass the flagellated stage of its life history in some blood-sucking insect.~ The theory proved an extremely difficult one to substantiate, however. The extremely slow development of kala- azar and of other infections due to leishmanias, and the lack of suscep- tible animals, both contribute to the difficulty of carrying out trans- mission experiments. The fact that blood-sucking insects which have been allowed to feed upon patients with kala-azar or oriental sore are found on subsequent dissection to contain flagellates does not jus- tify the conclusion that the flagellates are leishmanias, because the latter cannot be distinguished on morphological grounds from the flagellates occurring in many insects. Even when the insects used have been bred in the laboratory, and one may reasonably assume that they are free from flagellate infection, it is essential to be able to demonstrate in some way that the strain isolated from the insect after feeding is the same as that obtained from the patient. The injection into animals of herpetomonads derived from insects and plants ~has not given results which are sufficiently striking or constant to be considered convincing evidence of the pathogenicity of the inocu- 1Rogers, L., Lancet, 1904, Ixxxii, 215. 2Rogers, L., Proc. Roy. Soc.London, Series B, 1906, lxxvli, 284. Discussed in Part I of this reportfl 327 328 H]ERPETOMONADS AND LEISHMANIAS. II lated organisms; and the interpretation of the findings in such instances is complicated by the presence of natural flagellate infections in the animals employed (e.g., mice, rats, amphibians, and birds). The immunological properties of the leishmanias and herpetomonads have been very little studied. The writer,4 in 1924, showed that at least three species of leishmanias could be distinguished by serological tests. KligleP has also found that L. brasiliensis and L. infantu m are immunologically distinct from one another and from L. tropica, while different strains of L. tropica are serologically identical. Wage- her and Kochs recently carried out comparative serological tests with cultures of four strains of Leishmania and one strain of Herpetomonas ctenocephali, the latter a flageilate of the dog flea, which has been regarded as a possible vector of canine leishmaniasis. The anti-. leishmania sera of these authors, which were prepared with killed cultures, had no effect upon H. ctenocephali but affected equally the different species of leishmanias. Investigation of the cheinical changes which may take place in various carbohydrate-containing culture media has not so far been utilized for the differentiation of species of Herpetomonas. KligleP attempted to distinguish leishmanias by this means but was unable to draw any definite conclusion from his study with a small series of strains. As a first step in the application of immunological and biochemical methods to the differentiation of flagellate species, a number of strains of herpetomonads have been isolated from various sources and com- pared in serological and fermenting properties with one another and with the leishmanias. Twelve strains in all have been cultivated as described in Part I of this reportJ Two additional flagellate strains, Herpetomonas ctenocephali and Trypanosoma rotatorium, furnished by courtesy of Dr. E. E. Tyzzer, were included in the study. The leishmania strains were the same as those I have employed previ- 4Noguchi, H., Proc. Internat. Conf. Health Prob. Trop. America, Kingston, Jamaica, British West Indies, July 22 to August 1, 1924, published in Boston, 1924,p. 455. 5Kligler,I. J., Tr. Roy. Soc.Med., 1925,xix,330. 6Wagener,E. H., and Koch,D. A., Univ.Calif.Pub.Zool., 1926,xxviii,365. Noguchi,H., and Tilden, E. B., J. Exp. Med., 1926,xllv,307. mDEYO NOGVCaI 329 ously for immunological investigation. * Comparison of the biologi- cal characteristics of these eighteen strains of flagellates brought to light a number of interesting facts. Serological Differentiation of Herpetomonads and Leishmanias. Rabbits were immunized against Herpetomonas oncopelti, H. lyMeorum, H. culicidarum, H. muscidarum,