RELATION OF VARICELLA TO HERPES ZOSTER : II. CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL OBSERVATIONS.

Rivers TM, Eldridge LA. · 1929

Read RELATION OF VARICELLA TO HERPES ZOSTER : II. CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL OBSERVATIONS. by Rivers TM, Eldridge LA. (1929) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2131591.txt.

Introduction

Rivers and Eldridge, at the Hospital of The Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research, wrote part two of their study of varicella and herpes zoster in 1929. Chicken-pox and shingles make similar skin blisters, and some held their viruses to be one and the same. Part one handled statistics. Part two brings clinical observations and animal experiments to the question.

The collected evidence points away from identity. In most instances the agents behind the two diseases are not the same. Cases of zoster tied to nerve injury, drug injury, or spine disease also suggest that some zoster is not an infection at all, but a skin change after nerve damage. Exposure cases alone, the authors warn, can mislead by coincidence.

Catalog record

CREATORRivers TM, Eldridge LA.
YEAR1929
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2131591

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

RELATION OF VARICELLA TO HERPES ZOSTER By T. M. Rivers, L. A. Eldridge Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.49.6.907 ABSTRACT Experiments and clinical observations dealing with the identity of the viruses of varicella and herpes zoster were presented. The results indicate that the etiological agents concerned with these two diseases are in the majority of instances not identical. RELATION OF VARICELLA TO HERPES ZOSTER. II. CLINICAL AND ]~XPEI~r~O~.NTAL OBSERVATIONS. By T. M. RIVERS, M.D., AND L.A. ELDRIDGE, JR.,M.D. (From the Hospital of The RockefellerInstitute for Medical Research.) (Received for publication, February 13, 1929.) In the preceding paper (1) the problem relating to the identity of the causal agents of varicella and herpes zoster was stated. The mere occurrence of varicella in an individual following exposure to herpes zoster might easily be explained upon coincidence. Certain other observations, however, dealing with complement fixation work, inoculation experiments, and protection tests conducted with conva- lescent sera deserve serious consideration. Netter (2) and Netter and Urbain (3), de Lange (4), and others, because of their results with complement fixation tests, contend that the etiological agents of zoster and varicella are quite frequently identical. Landa and Silbersteru (5), however, were unable to confirm these observations. Kundratitz (6) and Lip- schtttz and Kundratitz (7) inoculated 28 children under 5 years of age with material from herpes zoster patients in the hope of immunizing them against chicken-pox. In 17 of the children a local reaction, characterized by papules and vesicles, was observed at the point of inoculation. The children were subsequently found to be immune to varicella. These writers also claim that injections of convalescent herpes zoster serum will protect exposed children against varicella. Lauda and Stt~hr (8) inoculated 54 children with material from 17 cases of herpes zoster, and in none of them did they observe a local reaction at the site of the inoculation. Three of the inoculated children and 3 other uninoculated infants who came in contact with some of the zoster patients developed typical chicken-pox 2 or 3 weeks after exposure. These workers were unable to demonstrate that conva- lescent zoster serum protects against variceila and conclude from the results of their work that the majority of cases of zoster are not caused by the virus of chicken-pox. Chicken-pox is a highly contagious disease, but for a long time doubt existed in regard to its inoculability. A great deal of this doubt arose from the fact that most of the experimental inoculations were made during epidemics of varicella and exposures to the disease under natural conditions could not absolutely be elimi- nated. Nevertheless, in spite of these difficulties, it has been shown (9) that 9O7 908 RELATION O~ VARICELLA TO HERPES ZOSTER. II varicella is inoculable. Successful experiments, however, are not as constant as one might suppose when considering the extremely contagious nature of the disease. Evidence is accumulating in favor of the idea that zoster also is caused by a virus, but the question as to its inoculabilityin humans is still moot. If it were possible without difficulty to produce varicella and zoster in animals, the relation of the two diseases would be settled quickly. It is very doubtful if the virus that causes the majority of cases of zoster has been propagated in experimental animals. With one ex- ception this is also true in regard to varicella. Certain kinds of monkeys (Cercopithecussabaeusand Cercopithecuslalandi) are suscep- tible to the virus of chicken-pox. Even in these animals the results are irregular and the evidence of infection consists of the occurrence of acidophilic nuclear inclusions in affected cells of inoculated testicles. These inclusions, however, do not occur in controls and their appear- ance is regularly prevented by convalescent varicella serum (10, 11). In view of the regularity with which convalescent varicella serum prevents these inclusions in testicles inoculated with chicken-pox virus, it seemed likely that information regarding the identity of vari- cella and zoster might be obtained by conducting neutralization tests with varicella virus and convalescent zoster serum. It is with obser- vations concerning these experiments that the present paper deals. Methods and Materials. MonkeysEmployed.--oungmale green monkeys (Cercopilhecussabaeus)were used. Animals in which spermatogenesis had been established were discarded. NeutralizationTests.--Emulsifiedpapules and vesicles collected from varicetla patients, usually within the first 72 hours of the disease, were used as virus. Non- immune serum was secured from chicken-pox patients during the first 72 hours of disease. Immune variceUa serum was obtained from convalescent patients 14 to 22 days after the appearance of the rash. Immune zoster serum was collected from convalescentpatients 23 to 28 days after the appearance of the eruption. The papules and vesicles were excised under aseptic conditions and emulsified by grinding in a mortar moistened with Locke's solution. Sand was not used. The emulsified material was taken up in 0.5 to 2.0 cc. of Locke's solution and portions of it were mixed as desired with equal amounts of non-immune serum, immune varicella serum, or immune herpes zoster serum. Measured amounts (0.25 cc.) of the mixtures were then injected into the testicles of monkeys. More than 45 minutes never elapsed between the collection of the varicellavirus and its injection into the animals. T. M. RIVERS AND L. A. ELDRIDGE, JR. 909 Removal and Examination of Testides.--It was previously shown (10, 11) that nuclear inclusions are present in the testicles of green monkeys on the 5th and 6th days after inoculation with chicken-pox. Consequently, in the experiments reported at the present time, the monkeys were castratedI on the 5th or 6th day following inoculation. The testicles removed for histological studies were fixed in Zenker's fluid, sectioned, and stained with eosin and methylene blue. A careful search for eosin-staining nuclear inclusions was made in numerous sections of each testicle. Details concerning the tinctorial reactions of the inclusions are given by Tyzzer (12), Lipschiitz (13), and Goodpasture (14). Resu/ts.--Testicles in which nuclear inclusions were found were considered infected with varicella virus. If no inclusions were found, infection was considered not to have occurred. In this type of work, positive results are naturally much more significant than are negative ones. EXPERIMENTAL. In the study of the relation of varicella to herpes zoster 4 neu- tralization experiments were performed. ~ A detailed account of each follows. Experiment I. The first experiment was conducted in order to determine whether the serum of an adult, who had had chicken-pox in childhood, would neutralize varicella virus. Serum was collected from J., 35 years of age, who had chicken-pox when 5 years old. Non-immune serum was obtained from W. R. during the first 48 hours after the appearance of the varicella rash. Virus in the form of 4 vari- celia vesicles was secured from B. The serum to be tested, from J., was mixed with an equal amount of virus, and then 0.25 cc. of the mixture was injected into each testicle of Monkey 1. Non-immune serum, W. R., was also mixed with virus, and 0.25 cc. of the mixture was injected into each testicle of Mon- key 2. 5 days later the testicles were removed and examined in the usual manner for the presence of acidophilic nuclear inclusions. They were found in the testicles of both monkeys. 1All operative procedures

Read the complete text