THE RELATION OF THE BACTERIOSTATIC ACTION OF CERTAIN DYES TO OXIDATION-REDUCTION PROCESSES.

Dubos R. · 1929

Read THE RELATION OF THE BACTERIOSTATIC ACTION OF CERTAIN DYES TO OXIDATION-REDUCTION PROCESSES. by Dubos R. (1929) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2131571.txt.

Introduction

René Dubos, at the Hospital of The Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research, linked dye action to oxidation-reduction chemistry in a 1929 paper. Some dyes stop bacteria from growing, a bacteriostatic effect, while others do not. He compared indicator dyes of known electric level against pneumococcus and hemolytic streptococci from man, cattle, and cheese.

Oxidized indophenols and methylene blue held back pneumococcus and the human and bovine streptococci. Indigoes, malachite green, and litmus were not toxic. One strong dye alone checked the cheese strains. Kept in a reduced form by the medium, the active dyes lost their power. Dubos reads the pattern as the dyes holding the medium at an electric level outside the range where those germs can grow.

Catalog record

CREATORDubos R.
YEAR1929
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2131571

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

THE RELATION OF THE BACTERIOSTATIC ACTION OF CERTAIN DYES TO OXIDATION-REDUCTION PROCESSES By René Dubos Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.49.4.575 ABSTRACT Oxidized indophenols and methylene blue are bacteriostatic for Pneumococcus and hemolytic streptococci of human and bovine origin, while the indigoes, malachite green and litmus are not toxic. 2-Chloroindophenol, the most positive of the indicators of oxidation-reduction potentials used, is also the only one to have a bacteriostatic action on cheese strains of Streptococcus hæmolyticus. Methylene blue and the indophenols are no longer bacteriostatic when present in a reduced form in a medium capable of maintaining them in such a condition. A comparison of these results with the growth in plain broth of the organisms studied suggests that the "inhibiting" dyes "poise" the medium at an oxidation potential outside the range in which the inhibited organisms can grow. THE RELATION OF THE BACTERIOSTATIC ACTION OF CERTARq DYES TO OXIDATION-REDUCTION PROCESSES. BY REN~ DUBOS~PH.D. (From the Hospital of The Rockefeller Instlt~ctefor Medical Researck.) (Received for publication, November 16, 1928.) In a preceding paper (1) it has been suggested that the growth of certain facultative anaerobes is inhibited by the existence in the me- dium of substances with a high oxidation potential. Accurate studies on the critical potentials for different species of bacteria will require the use of media "poised" at definite values. Even then, the results will be significant only if it is demonstrated that there exists a condi- tion of equilibrium between the different parts of the system under consideration. Unfortunately, we have at our disposal only very few oxidation- reduction systems, the characteristics of which are known. Among these may be mentioned the color indicators of Clark. It seems that these indicators together with a fewother systems, such as hemoglobin- methemoglobin, fumaric-succinic acid, hermidin, echinochrome and some bacterial pigments, might be used to "poise" the media at their own characteristic potentials. However, the use of this technique is complicated by the toxicity of some of the dyes for certain bacterial species. It appeared possible that, in some cases, this toxicity might be partly accounted for by the high oxidation potentials of the oxi- dized dyes. Were this hypothesis justified, it might give us a method of determining the critical potential of the bacterial species studied, by determining which of the dyes are toxic in the oxidized form, and not toxic in the reduced form. The bactericidal and bacteriostatic actions of certain dyes on differ- ent groups of microorganisms has been known for a long time, but the mechanism of this action is still obscure; it is likelythat the mechanism varies with each type of dyes and each group of organisms. An 575 576 BACTERIOSTATIC ACTION OF DYES AND OXIDATION" extensive review of the subject has been recently presented by Sartorius (2), but without any special discussion of the fundamental principles involved. Among the few facts which have been established in this respect may be men- tioned the more or less complete parallelism between the bacteriostatic of tri- phenylmethanes and the Gram reaction (3). On the other hand, azine and azonium dyes, such as phenosafranine and Janus green are known to precipitate proteolytic enzymes (4) and to penetrate the living cell (5). A striking example of the differential toxicity of a dye for two closely related bacterial species has been de- scribed by Sherman and Albus (6). They showed that, while the growth of hemolytic streptococci of human and bovine origin is inhibited by the presence in the medium of even low concentrations of methylene blue, the cheese strains thrive in presence of much higher concentrations of the same dye. Later, Avery (7) found that the sample of methylene blue used contained Zn as impurity, and that Zn salts alone, in corresponding concentrations, would also inhibit the human and bovine strains. However, purified methylene blue retained the sameproperty. Some time later, Brown (8) reported "that streptococci which were inhibited by methylene blue in the presence of oxygen grew well in media containing methylene blue which was reduced." Burner (9) studied the growth of certain organisms on acid fuchsin agar plates and found that the growth of "isolated" ceils of Staphylococcus aureus, diph- theroid bacillus and Friedliinder's bacillus was inhibited on such media. (Iso- lated cells were obtained by spreading a dilute suspension of the culture over the plate.) However, growth developed in the vicinity of colonies of Staphylococ- cus aureus obtained by local heavy inoculation. Burnet concluded from his experiments "that the fuchsin interferes directly with the production or utiliza- tion of peroxide by the organism. The presence of products of growth whose primary function is to destroy peroxide, protects isolated organisms against otherwise inhibiting concentrations of the dye..... Fuchsin must act by rendering the organism sensitive to traces of peroxide produced in its own metabolism." Although not dealing directly with the toxicity of dyes for bacterial cultures, the following three studies may be mentioned here. W. M. Clark and associates (10) have indicated that the halogens lose the greater part of their toxicity when added under conditions which prevent the attainment of oxidation potentials positive to the indophenols. Voegtlin and collaborators (11), working with normal and cancer tissues, found that the "toxic action of dyes depends to some extent on their oxidizing power for reduced glutathione, and also on other features of their molecular structure" and demon- strated by toxicity tests "the existence of a biological antagonism between reduced glutathione and methylene blue." In the course of their studies on the intra- cellular oxidation-reduction potentials of Amveba duma, Cohen, Chambers and I~N~ DUBOS 577 Reznikoff (12) observed that "the reductauts of toxic oxidants were usually non- toxic" and that "the diazines were decidedly toxic." The ultimate object of the following experiments was to fred out whether indicators of oxidation-reduction can be used to determine the critical oxidation potential of the medium above which the growth of Pneumococcus and Streptococcus cannot take place. The problem which has been most directly consideredhere is an analysis of the mech- anism by which such indicators exert a bacteriostatic action on these species. TABLE I. List of Dyes* Used. Nameofoxidant 2-Chloroindophenol(o-chlorophenolindophenol)........... Indophenol (phenol indophenol)......................... 2-Methyl indophenol (o-cresolindophenol)................ l-Naphthol-2-sulfonate indophenol...................... Methylene blue....................................... Janus green (green --*pink) ..................... (approx.) Ki indigo tetrasulfonate ............................... K, indigo trisulfonate .................................. Ks indigo disulfonate................................... K indigo monosulfonate............................... Janus green (pink ~ colorless)................. (approx.) Neutral red.................................. (approx.) Phenosafranine............................... (approx.) Litmus.............................................. Malachite green....................................... Eo'(pH= 7.4) (involts) +0.233 +0.228 +0.195 +0.123 +0.011 --0.02 --0.046 --0.081 --0.125 --0.182 --0.26 --0.31 -0.525 ? ? rH 21.8 21.6 20.5 18.1 14.4 13 12.5 11.3 9,9 7.5 5 3.7 --3.5 ? ? * The indophenols, the methylene blue, and 3 of the indigoes were obtained from La Motte Chemical Company. Indigo trisulfonate was obtained through the courtesy of Dr. B. Cohen of the Hygiene Laboratory, Washington, D. C. The other indicators were dyes used in the laboratory for staining and cytological work. EXPER~NTAL. Methods. 12 hour plain broth cultures of the following organisms were used in the test Pneumococcus: smooth virulent: Type I (I/200/4) Type II (D/39/43) Type Ill (A/66/69) 578 BACTERIOSTATIC ACTION OF DYES AND OXIDATION Rough avlrulent derived from Type I (1/193/R) Type II (D/39/R) Type III (M/3/R) Streptococcusl~emolyticus:human strains: L,

Read the complete text