RECIPROCAL EFFECTS OF CONCOMITANT INFECTIONS : III. THE INFLUENCE OF VACCINIA AND OF VACCINAL IMMUNITY ON THE REACTION TO INFECTION WITH EXPERIMENTAL SYPHILIS (INTRACUTANEOUS INOCULATION).
Pearce L. · 1928
Read RECIPROCAL EFFECTS OF CONCOMITANT INFECTIONS : III. THE INFLUENCE OF VACCINIA AND OF VACCINAL IMMUNITY ON THE REACTION TO INFECTION WITH EXPERIMENTAL SYPHILIS (INTRACUTANEOUS INOCULATION). by Pearce L. (1928) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2131471.txt.
Introduction
Louise Pearce, at The Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research, wrote part three of her two-infection series in 1928. She asked how a second infection changes syphilis in rabbits. The syphilis was started by a shot into the skin. Beside it she placed either a fresh vaccinia infection, begun the same day, or a vaccine immunity already in place from before.
The two states pulled in opposed ways. A vaccinia infection begun at the same time weakened the defense, and the syphilis that followed ran more severe than in control rabbits. Vaccine immunity already present strengthened the defense, and the syphilis stayed very mild. The results match her earlier work that used a different route for the syphilis infection.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pearce L. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1928 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
RECIPROCAL EFFECTS OF CONCOMITANT INFECTIONS By Louise Pearce Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.48.3.363 ABSTRACT An experiment is reported in which was studied the effects of a concomitant vaccinal infection and of vaccinal immunity upon the reaction to syphilis in rabbits induced by intracutaneous inoculation. The results obtained showed that the reaction was modified by both conditions. A vaccinal infection initiated at the time of syphilitic inoculation was associated with a defensive reaction of lessened efficiency, the ensuing syphilis being more severe than in control animals. A state of vaccinal immunity present at the time of syphilitic inoculation was associated with a reaction of heightened efficiency, the ensuing syphilis being very mild. These results are in harmony with those obtained in other experiments in which the intratesticular route of syphilitic inoculation was employed. RECIPROCAL EFFECTS OF CONCOMITANT INFECTIONS. III. THE INFLUENCE OF VACCINIA AND OF VACCINAL I~ITY ON THE P~EACTION TO INFECTION WITH EXPERIMENTAL SYPHILIS (INTRACUTANEOUS INOCULATION). BY LOUISE PEARCE, M.D. (From the Laboratories of The Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research.) (Received for publication, May 29, 1928.) In a previous paper of this series (1), the results of experiments were reported in which it was shown that in rabbits the efficiency of the reaction to infection with syphilis was markedly decreased by the intracutaneous inoculation of vaccine virus at the time of the intra- tesficular inoculation of Treponema pallidum, the ensuing syphilis being much more severe than in control animaJs. In other experi- ments (2), a state of vaccinal immunity at the time of syphilitic inocu- lation was associated with an increased effectiveness of reaction, the disease being very mild. Results of a similar nature were obtained in which the intratesticular inocula consisted of a mixture of Trepo- nemapallidum and vaccine virus (2). In all the experiments already reported, the syphilitic inoculation was made in one testicle. Our experience, as well as that of others with experimental syphilis, has shown that the circumstances under which the syphilitic infection is initiated are essential factors in deter- mining the general character of the reaction and that, among these factors, the site and mode of inoculation are of particular importance. As an extension of the present study of concomitant infections, experi- ments were carried out in which another route of syphilitic inoculation was employed, namely, the intracutaneous. In one group of rabbits, vaccine virus was injected intracutaneouslyat the time of the pallidum inoculation but at a different site, while in a second, the animals were immune to vaccine virus when inoculated with syphilis. The results of the experiment comprising the study of the reaction to syphilis induced by intracutaneous inoculation under these two conditions are 363 364 CONCOMITANT INFECTIONS. III reported in detail in the present paper; a preliminary report has pre- viously been published (3). Materials and Method. As in the other experiments dealing with the effects of a concomitant vaccinal infection upon the syphilitic reaction, the Nichols strain of Treponemapallidum and the Noguehi strain of vaccine virus were employed. The experiment was begun on Feb. 14, 1927, and the materials used for inoculation were the same as in the other groups of rabbits inoculated intratesticularly on this date (1, 2). The syphilitic emulsion prepared from an actively developing tesficular lesion contained from 1 to 3 motile spirochetes per microscopic field. The vaccinal material was obtained from an early vaccinal orchitis, and its activity was controlled by the intracutaneous and the intratesticular inoculation of 4 normal rabbits. The experiment comprised 3 groups of 10 rabbits each. The first group was inoculated with 0.2 cc. of the syphilitic emulsion intracutaneously on the dorsal surface of the prepuce, and immediately thereafter, the vaccinal emulsion (0.2 cc.) was injected intracutaneously on the side of the body while a similar amount was applied to an adjacent scarified area. The skin areas had been shaved just before these procedures were carried out. The second group of rabbits was immunized to vaccine virus 30 days before inoculation with syphilis. Each animal reacted in a typical manner to the intra- cutaneous vaccinal injection and a second injection, 10 days after the first, was followed by no visible reaction. The syphilitic inoculation of these animals con- sisted in the injection of 0.2 cc. of the pallidumemulsion intracutaneously on the dorsum of the prepuce, as in the first group of animals. The third group of the experiment comprised the syphilitic controls, that is, normal rabbits inoculated in the same site and with a similar amount of the pallidumemulsion as in the first and second groups. The rabbits employed were young adult male animals approximately 8 months of age, and were carefullymatched as to breed and color. They were separately caged throughout the experiment and were fed the usual diet of hay, oats, and cabbage. The period of observation was 4 months during which time each rabbit was ex- amined at frequent intervals in order that the course of the disease might be care- fully followed. The syphilitic reaction was studied upon the same basis as in the former experiments already referred to (1, 2). Among the significant phenomena of the infection especially considered were the following: the incubation period, the character and duration of the primary lesion, the incidence, time of appear- ance, number, character, and persistence of generalized lesions, and finally, the resolution and healing of lesions or the initiation of the period of latency. Although lesions of the testicles, tunics, epididymis, and vas deferens are, strictly speaking, generalized manifestations under the conditions of intracuta- neous inoculation, they are of a somewhat different order than lesions of the perios- LOUISE PEARCE 365 teum, bone, skin and mucous membranes, and the eyes, and consequently have been separately considered. As has been found with the intratesticular route of inoculation, the testicles offer extremely favorable conditions for the growth of spirochetes, and in certain rabbits inoculated intracutaneously an orchitis may be the only generalized manifestation detected. Furthermore, no distinction has beenmadein the present discussionbetweenlesionsof the testiclesand thoseofthe tunics,epididymis,and vas sincethe latter structures are frequentlyinvolvedin an extensionofthe testicularprocess. In analyzingthe results, specialattention has been paid to the timerelations of the successivephenomena of reaction. The term "focal distribution" or "focal rate" as applied to generalizedlesions,refers to the number of such lesionsper rabbit as determinedby clinicalexamination. The actual rate includesonlythose animalswhichdevelopedgeneralizedlesions,whilethe relativerate refersto all the animals of a group. In estimating the distribution of lesionsfor group compari- sons, the relative rate gives a fairer impressionof the extent of the lesionsand furthermore.,avoids the impressionwhichwouldbe obtained by the chanceinclu- sionin anygroupofan individualanimalwithunusuallyseveresyphilis. RESULTS. The results of this experiment are summarized in Tables I to III and in Text-figs. 1 and 2. The figures given in Tables I and II represent group values. The incidence of the various phenomena of the syphi- litic infection chosen for comparison are given in Table I, together with the actual and relative focal distribution rates of generalized lesions. Table II contains the mean time of occurrence of these phenomena, while Table III lists the time of appearance of all generalized lesions in 2 day intervals as estimated from the date of inoculation. The course of the infection in the 3 groups of rabbits, that is, the animals inoculated with Treponemapallidumand