LOCAL SPECIFIC THERAPY OF EXPERIMENTAL PNEUMOCOCCAL MENINGITIS : II. THE PRODUCTION, PATHOLOGY, AND TREATMENT OF TYPE I PNEUMOCOCCAL MENINGITIS IN DOGS.
Stewart FW. · 1927
Read LOCAL SPECIFIC THERAPY OF EXPERIMENTAL PNEUMOCOCCAL MENINGITIS : II. THE PRODUCTION, PATHOLOGY, AND TREATMENT OF TYPE I PNEUMOCOCCAL MENINGITIS IN DOGS. by Stewart FW. (1927) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2131246.txt.
Introduction
Fred Stewart, at The Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research, wrote part two of his 1927 series on local treatment of pneumococcal meningitis. Part one had used rabbits; this part produces the disease in dogs and treats it there. Injected into the cisternal space, virulent Type I pneumococci gave the dogs a severe, pus-forming meningitis much like the human disease.
Stewart washed the meninges in a set way and applied mixtures of optochin and serum through a four-puncture method. Cures followed when the drug reached every region of the membranes often enough. Where contact failed, germs survived and infection returned. He stresses repeated clear spinal fluids, on smear and on culture, before a cure can be trusted, and notes that recovered dogs resisted a second attack in part.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Stewart FW. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1927 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
LOCAL SPECIFIC THERAPY OF EXPERIMENTAL PNEUMOCOCCAL MENINGITIS By Fred W. Stewart Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.46.3.409 ABSTRACT 1. Extensive acute, fibrinopurulent meningitis may be produced in dogs by the intracisternal injection of virulent Type I pneumococci. 2. Given an equal number of virulent infecting organisms, the rate of establishment of infection depends upon the phase of growth and the quantitative growth per cc. of culture plus an uncontrollable individual factor in the animal. 3. The pathology of pneumococcal meningitis is discussed. It resembles very closely the similar disease in man. 4. Systematic lavage and treatment with optochin-serum mixtures by the method of quadruple puncture, as described above, have resulted in cures of Type I pneumococcal meningitis in dogs. 5. The important factor in obtaining cures is to bring all regions of the meninges into frequent contact with the therapeutic agent. 6. In the absence of such contact, incomplete sterilization results and "reinfection" is almost inevitable. 7. Protocols show the necessity of repeated negative cisternal fluids, both on smear and on culture, before sterilization can be assured. 8. Recovered dogs subjected to meningeal reinfection show some degree of resistance. LOCAL SPECIFIC THERAPY OF EXPERIMENTAL PNEUMOCOCCAL MENINGITIS. II. TIrE PRODUCTION, PATHOLOGY, AND TREATMENT OF TYPE I PNEIYMOCOCCAL MENINGITIS IN DOGS. BY FRED W. STEWART, M.D. (Fromthe Laboratories of The Rockefeller Institute far Medical Research.) PLATES 16 TO 21. (Receivedfor publication,June 12, 1927.) In the previous paper (1) the production, pathology, and attempted treatment of Type I pneumococcal meningitis of rabbits were dis- cussed. Reasons were presented explaining why the rabbit is a very unfavorable animal for the study of this disease, which may be briefly summarized as follows: In a normal rabbit, septicemia, following in- tracisternal infection with Type I pneumococci, is invariable, rapid, and massive, and septicemic death occurs before there is any reactiona] localization in the meninges; consequently, to produce meningeal localization, complete or partial, a previous immunizing treatment is necessary. Following this treatment, however, there is a considerable variation in the intensity of the meningeal infection, making it im- possible to gauge properly the dosage of organisms which will produce fatal disease, but which will not immediately overwhelm the animal's resistance. Even if the disease intensity is properly regulated, treat- ment is unsuccessful on account of both the limited working space and the widespread localization of organisms in regions impossible to reach either by immune serum or lavage. In view of these facts, the rabbit was abandoned as an experimental animal and recourse was had to young dogs. The dog is, as we know, relatively resistant to systemic pneumococcal infection, although marked variations even here are encountered. In the meninges, how- ever, a type of disease may be produced which progresses toward fatal termination, if cultures of suitable virulence are used, and one which quite closely approximates pathologically the human pneumococcal 409 410 PNEUMOCOCCAL MENINGITIS. II meningitis. To produce rapid progressive meningitis with any degree of assurance that the disease will assume a fairly characteristic course from day to day, the infecting dose must be reasonably standardized. In the present study the dosage of organisms has been accurately counted by means of a Petroff-Hausser bacterial counter. Not only should the numbers of infecting pneumococci be known, but the culture should be standardized both as to hours of growth and as to quantity of growth. A culture should be chosen which is well along on the up- ward limb of the growth curve. We have employed 6 hour cultures. It must be a culture which has given a good growth. There is a marked difference between the degree of 18-24 hour infection pro- duced by a given number of pneumococci from a 6 hour plain broth culture which has produced a low total growth, i. e., a growth ranging from 150-225 million per cc., and that produced by the same number of organisms from a 6 hour 0.2 per cent dextrose broth culture which is producing a growth of upwards of 700 million per cc. Unless these differences are recognized, conclusions are of little value. Use of late (24 hour) cultures may lead to very deceptive results. Even with these cultural conditions standardized, there is an uncontrollable indi- vidual factor which influences the rate of establishment of progressive disease; every animal is an individual and must be so handled. Whereas we hesitate to interpret the anatomic and therapeutic results of others, we are inclined to believe that the findings of Idzumi (2) were the result of the use of a culture of low virulence. Idzumi studied pneumococcal meningitis in dogs. This investigator used enormous doses of organisms, from 1-2 cc. of a suspension secured by centrifuging 10 cc. of a 24 hour culture of low mouse virulence. Al- though the dogs died, the pathologic changes were scarcely more than those of hyperemia. In our own study the disease has been regularly produced with approximately 1 cc. of a 1:100 dilution of 6 hour culture. It would seem that Kolmer's (3) successful therapy, i.e., lavage from one or both lateral ventricles to the cisterna magna with physiological saline or Ringer's solution, cannot be interpreted as the result of other than feeble infection with cultures well beyond the growth peak and full of non-viable organisms. The lavage was most incomplete, since the entire cord, base, and convexity were untouched by the saline. Kolmer reports, however, that at the time of lavage FRED W. STEWART 411 the spinal fluids were always purulent and contained myriads of pneumococci, making it more difficult for one to und.erstand how lavage from one lateral ventricle to the cisterna magna could have appreciably influenced the process, since in our own experience the other ventricle would always have been an untouched focus in a disease of the intensity he describes. Bull (4) observed meningitis developing in the course of pneumococcal septicemia in dogs. His organism was not typed. Bull noted some spontaneous recoveries. EXPERIMENTAL. Apparently in control dogs, infected intracisternally, death may occur in one or more of three ways. A dog may develop a fairly rapid proliferation of pneumococci in the meninges with a constant large feeding of organisms into the blood stream, and die of bacteremia. If a culture is of low potency due to poor growth conditions, a meningeal process of such intensity may result that a very marked cellular re- actional process occurs, with pneumococci present in relatively small numbers. In such cases death appears to be "reactional." Thirdly, the proliferation of organisms within the meninges may attain enor- mous proportions, and brain and cord may be covered with a thick, gelatinous layer, consisting mainly of heavily encapsulated pneumo- cocci, but with relatively moderate cellular reaction. In the second and third instances, death may be due, in part at least, to the mechan- ical obstruction of the meningeal spaces. The actual mechanism of death from pneumococcus infection is always rather obscure. Three protocols may be introduced to illustrate these points. Dog 12.--Female hound; weight 5.5 kilos. March 23, 1927,4.10 p.m., mor- phine gr. 1/5; ether; cistern puncture; clear fluid. Injected 6,500,000 Type I pneumococci(6 hour dextrosebroth culture, growth 1,100,000,000per cc.). Good recovery. 19hours later, lethargic, weak, irritable, sicker than usual at