STUDIES IN ULTRAFILTRATION.

Zinsser H, Tang FF. · 1927

Read STUDIES IN ULTRAFILTRATION. by Zinsser H, Tang FF. (1927) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2131172.txt.

Introduction

Hans Zinsser and Fei-Fang Tang published their ultrafiltration studies in The Journal of Experimental Medicine in 1927. They passed proteins, an enzyme, bacteriophage, and several viruses through very fine filters to judge particle size by what got through. The authors warn from the start that such indirect readings carry many chances of error.

Their results set pure proteins in an order that matched known molecular weights, though casein behaved as if far larger than its weight suggests. They stress that the active agents may not float free at all. Herpes virus, for one, seemed bound to protein bits from the cells it grew in. Size claims from filtration, they argue, must stay cautious.

Catalog record

CREATORZinsser H, Tang FF.
YEAR1927
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2131172

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

STUDIES IN ULTRAFILTRATION By Hans Zinsser, Fei-Fang Tang Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.46.2.357 ABSTRACT We are submitting this series of experiments as observed facts, realizing that there are so many uncertainties in this form of indirect observation that great caution must be exercised in drawing conclusions of any kind. The most serious of the possible errors involved is that the active substances which we have studied, the enzyme—the bacteriophage—and the several varieties of virus, may not be free in our suspensions, but are adsorbed to larger particles. The peculiar difficulties encountered in filtering herpes virus particularly suggest a source of error of this kind, and if we are right in assuming the intracellular position of this virus in the nervous tissue, it is more than likely that most of the virus obtained in suspension may be closely associated with protein particles derived from the cells. Keeping all this in mind, we may, nevertheless, derive a certain amount of information from our experiments as follows: 1. The order of magnitudes of the pure proteins with which we have worked,—namely, crystallized egg albumen, crystallized serum albumen and purified casein,—follows the order of molecular weights of these substances as determined by Cohn. As far as casein is concerned, the size indicated by filtration in comparison with collargol is far greater than it should be by calculations which take a molecular weight of 192,000 as the point of departure. While one cannot be sure of the reason for this, there are many possible explanations such as considerable swelling of the casein partides, aggregation of molecules and the fact that casein is not at its isoelectric point under the conditions of filtration and surely present as a salt. 2. Trypsin, even in the certainly very impure condition in which we employed it, is but very slightly larger than serum albumen and distinctly smaller than casein. In its pure form it may well be much smaller even than our filtrations indicate, but certainly not larger. This relatively small size of trypsin may have considerable bearing upon the question of whether or not the lytic agents spoken of as "bacteriophage" are substances of the nature of enzymes, or whether they are more comparable to the filtrable virus, as supposed by d'Hérelle. 3. Herpes virus, the Rous chicken sarcoma and a staphylococcus bacteriophage were all subjected to filtration at pH 7.2 and at hydrogen ion concentrations higher than 8, which is given by Olitsky and Boëz as the isoelectric point of foot-and-mouth disease, but failed to pass membranes which, at the same pressures, were permeable for casein and collargol. The bacteriophage and the Rous sarcoma with considerable regularity passed through membranes which held back colloidal arsenic trisulfide. We have cited only a few of the experiments which were actually done, every one of the tests tabulated being merely representative of a number of others that were omitted for economy of space. The herpes virus we have had greater difficulty in filtering. We cite one experiment with a 2 per cent acetic-collodion membrane and another with a 1.5 per cent membrane through which the herpes virus passed, the membrane being so controlled that gross leakage could be excluded. We believe that the difficulty here is very largely due to the fact that in preparing the herpes virus for filtration it cannot be separated from considerable amounts of brain material, from which, perhaps, it is not easily dissociated. This would be natural if the herpes virus were intracellularly located, as we believe it to be. This experiment and similar ones, however, incline us to believe that the herpes virus is not far different from the Rous sarcoma virus and the bacteriophage, as far as filtration through membranes is concerned. It certainly is not smaller than either of these substances and probably, as we judge from a few experiments carried out at higher pressures, is not much larger. It may be assumed, therefore, that in the form in which we were able to procure the bacteriophage and the two varieties of virus investigated by us, they were of a magnitude larger than casein and collargol and smaller than colloidal arsenic. The weak point in drawing our conclusions is the fact that we were not in a position to measure for ourselves with any accuracy the actual sizes of collargol and arsenic trisulfide particles. Accepting the general views of Bechhold and others, however, our experiments would define the sizes of the separticular substances as larger than 20 mµ and probably smaller than 100 mµ. The order of magnitudes of the substances measured by us would then be as follows: Crystallized egg albumen Crystallized serum albumen Trypsin Collargol Casein Bacteriophage, Rous sarcoma virus, herpes virus Arsenic trisulfide Our experiments show little agreement with the work of Levaditi and Nicolau and of Levaditi, Nicolau and Galloway. In their recent filtration tests of foot-and-mouth disease this virus is reported by them as passing through membranes that held back trypsin, indicating a size much smaller than any of the viruses measured by us. Our results, on the other hand, are in actual measurements comparable to those of Olitsky and Boëz, not only in the fact that the viruses with which we worked correspond approximately to the size determined by them for foot-and-mouth disease, but that the percentage of collodion in membranes permeable for virus and impermeable for colloidal arsenic corresponds almost exactly to our own. This gives us confidence that the technique developed may be more easily standardized than we at first believed and that the method of ultrafiltration, owing to the great ease with which membranes of relatively standard size may be made, may have valuable applications in the investigation of bacteriological and immunological problems. STUDIES IN ULTRAFILTRATION. BY HANS ZINSSER, M.D., A~D FEI-FANG TANG, M.D. (Fromtke Departmento/Bacteriologyand Immunology, Harvard UniversityMedical Sckool, Boston.) (Received for publication, May 6, 1927.) The limitations of the term "filtrable virus" have been well de- fined in a recent critical review on these agents by T. M. Rivers (1), who points out the chaos that has reigned in the loose classification of a variety of pathogenic agents on the uncertain basis of filtrability. His review renders it unnecessary for us to reiterate the difficulties that are involved in any work that deals with the nature of agents that--as he asserts--have never been cultivated in the absence of living cells and can be recognizedonly by their biological or pathogenic effects. Nevertheless, it would be a considerable step toward clearer understanding could we obtain information concerning the actual sizes of someof those active and pathogenic agents, whichpass through filters that hold back the smallest bacteria and which are either too small to be seen with the microscopeor, for reasons of chemical consti- tution, have defied methods of staining. We shall not refer to the complications that render the process of filtration an uncertain method. Stuart Mudd (2) and others have thoroughly discussed these matters in recent publications, and since our work deals entirely with filtration through collodion membranes, considerations which apply to the ordinary bacterial filters of the Berkefeld, Mandler, Chamberland types are omitted. Our present communicationdeals with an endeavour to approach the problem of the magnitude of

Read the complete text