STUDIES ON ENDOTHELIAL REACTIONS : VI. THE ENDOTHELIAL RESPONSE IN EXPERIMENTAL TUBERCULOUS MENINGOENCEPHALITIS.
Foot NC. · 1922
Read STUDIES ON ENDOTHELIAL REACTIONS : VI. THE ENDOTHELIAL RESPONSE IN EXPERIMENTAL TUBERCULOUS MENINGOENCEPHALITIS. by Foot NC. (1922) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2128390.txt.
Introduction
Nathan Chandler Foot traced which cells build the tubercles of tuberculous meningitis in the rabbit's brain. His paper is the sixth in an endothelial reactions series, in the Journal of Experimental Medicine in 1922, from Harvard's comparative pathology department. The tubercles were produced experimentally in the brain and its membranes.
The tubercles form from cells of endothelial origin, the lining cells of vessels and organs. Those cells do not come only from the capillaries nearby. The blood's own wandering macrophages, large eating cells, are drawn into the building work, and in this case they can even divide while still free in the blood. Removing the spleen did not materially cut the supply of these cells. Liver and bone marrow lining may contribute, but the lung, Foot reports, plays a much larger role as a source than anyone had suspected.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Foot NC. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1922 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
STUDIES ON ENDOTHELIAL REACTIONS By Nathan Chandler Foot Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.36.6.607 ABSTRACT 1. Experimental cerebral and meningeal tubercles in the rabbit are formed from cells of endothelial origin. 2. These cells are derived apparently from other sources than the neighboring capillary endothelium alone. 3. The circulating macrophages, which, in this case, are capable of multiplying by mitosis while still free in the blood, are drawn upon in the formation of the cerebral tubercle. 4. Splenectomy has not materially decreased the available supply of circulating macrophages in this experiment. 5. While these cells may originate in the endothelium of the liver and bone marrow, the lung appears to play a much more important rôle in this respect than has been hitherto suspected. STUDIES ON ENDOTHELIAL REACTIONS. Vl. THE ENDOTHELIAL RESPONSE II~ EX.eEI~IX~EN:CAL TUBERCULOUS MENINGOE N CEPIf_ALITIS. BYNATHANCHANDLERFOOT,M.D. (FromtheDepartmentof ComparativePathology,GeorgeFabyanFoundation,Harvard Medical School,Boston.) :PLATES54 To 56. (Receivedfor publication,July 3, 1922.) INTR ODUCTION. As stated in the fourth paper of this series, it has been the writer's purpose to call attention to the importance of the vascular endothe- lium as a source of the mononuclear phagocytes, or macrophages, in conditions resulting from inflammation or injury. Three of the five preceding papers dealt with these phenomena in the case of tuberculous inflammation in rabbits--one with subcutaneous tubercles, one with pulmonary tuberculosis, and one with general miliary tuber- culosis (Foot, 1920, a, b, 1921). In the present paper the reaction of the cerebral tissues to an infection with tubercle bacilli will be discussed. This subject has been reserved for special treatment because of that radical difference between cerebral and other tissues of the body, which might perhaps alter the type of reaction. There is little doubt that tuberculous meningoencephalitis is a process practically limited to the meninges and their vascular exten- sions into the substance of the brain. This view appears to be ac- cepted by those few who have written on the subject, upon which little work has been done during the past decade. It is difficult to find a detailed description of the histology of the cerebral lesions in this disease in most text-books on pathology, for the reason that they are to be considered usually a part of a general miliary tuberculosis. Cerebral tuberculosis has, however, some characteristics that differ 6O7 608 ENDOTHELIAL REACTIONS. VI rather strikingly from the tuberculosis of other organs. It shows a well marked tendency to limit itself to the mesodermal elements of the brain, a far greater lymphocytic reaction, many large mononu- clear ceils circulating in the vessels of the affected area, and some- times fewer giant ceils are found here than in tubercles of other organs. Perhaps the most detailed treatment of the process is to be found in Ranke's (1908) article, in which he gives an excellent historical sketch of the development of knowledge on this subject, tracing it from 1829 when it was first described by Abercrombie. Experimental work was not begun until Kure, working in Nissl's laboratory in 1898, produced tuberculous meningoencephalitis by drawing cotton threads impregnated with tubercle bacilli through the brains of dogs. This method elicited a mixed reaction in which there was, at first, a foreign body to be dealt with and later the infection resulting from the multiplication of the bacilli which had to be overcome. Delille improved on these experiments by injecting extracts of tubercle bacilli in ether, chloroform, and xylol. The tubercles produced in this way were found to be independent of the brain tissue, except where they encroached directly upon its substance. Ranke's article concludes with a description of three cases of tuberculous meningitis with necropsy and a very careful report on the histopathological exami- nation of the lesions, replete with morphological details based upon the study of preparations stained in a great variety of ways. In the course of this description he discusses large mononuclcar cells of varying morphology that are first noted free in the blood of the pial vessels. These cells were first discussed by Tigges in 1863 and interpreted as exfoliated endothelial cells by Sawada in 1901, Diamond taking a similar view as to their origin at about the same time. Ranke, after describing them exhaustively and with the greatest minuteness of detail, leaves the question of their origin open for further investigation and future decision. This is particularly interesting as Farrar (1908), in an article published in the same volume and issued from the same laboratory, describes similar cells in connection with experiments on the reaction to elder pith discs inserted into the cerebral cortex of rabbits, ascribing their origin to the pial endothelium and also tracing the grid cells from the vascular endothelium of the meninges. Gehry (1909), writing in the following year, takes up the question of the origin of these macrophages and, after discussing them at length, categorically states that they are derivatives of the fixed tissues. As this term is loosely employed in the German literature, it may mean the vascular endothelium, the adventitial connective tissue, or the mesothelinm. All these writers are agreed that the brain tissue proper does not respond to foreign bodies, nor to tuberculous inflammation, except secondarily--when it is invaded by the agent in question and by the mesodermal reaction to its presence. In such areas the nerve cells die off, to be replaced by the multiplication of their satellite glia cells, which act as mere stop- gaps. The glia cells form clusters, or nests, and multiply usually by amitotic NATHAN CHANDLERFOOT 609 division, although mitotic figuresare sometimes found. Rod cellsare found in the neighborhood of tuberculous lesions in man; the matter of their origin is fully discussed by Uyematsu (1920) in an article on diffuse cerebral sclerosis. He believes them to be modified glia cells, while Alzheimer and Nissl have considered them to be endothelial in origin. Farrar (1908) states that they do not occur in the rabbit's brain. Shorter discussions of tuberculous meningitis will be found in the section on vascular lesionsof the brain and cord by Nonne and Luce (1904) in the Handbuch der pathologischen Anatomic des Nervensystems. The fact that cerebral tuber- culosis is taken up under the heading of vascular diseases speaks for itself. Lugaro, in the same text-book, gives a good description of the glia cell and its manifold variations in type. According to him, it is the phagocyte of the ectoder- mal brain tissue, usually multiplying by direct division; it may form giant cells, spider cells or astrocytes, and may also phagocytose and replace ganglion cells, etc. In recent years an article by Friedenwald and Greenfeld (1915) brings the subject of cerebral tuberculosis more nearly to date---but their description of the pathological histology,of the lesions is rather meager. From this review it will be seen that the main question left for decision is the origin of the mononuclear macrophages that circulate in the meningeal vessels and through the lymph spaces of the pia- arachnoid in tuberculous meningitis. That the tubercles are formed in, or near vessels and that their epithelioid cells are probably of en- dothelial origin has been fairly well established. In order to decide this point, if possible, the following experiment was performed. EXPERI~KENTAL. Five adult rabbits were anesthetized