BOTULISM. STUDIES ON THE MANNER IN WHICH THE TOXIN OF CLOSTRIDIUM BOTULINUM ACTS UPON THE BODY : I. THE EFFECT UPON THE AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM.
Dickson EC, Shevky R. · 1923
Read BOTULISM. STUDIES ON THE MANNER IN WHICH THE TOXIN OF CLOSTRIDIUM BOTULINUM ACTS UPON THE BODY : I. THE EFFECT UPON THE AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM. by Dickson EC, Shevky R. (1923) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2128354.txt.
Introduction
Ernest C. Dickson and Richard Shevky opened a botulism series by asking where the toxin of Clostridium botulinum strikes the nervous system. Their paper appeared in the Journal of Experimental Medicine in 1923. They poisoned cats, dogs, and rabbits and tested the autonomic nerves, the involuntary control system, branch by branch.
Botulinus poisoning, they conclude, acts specifically on two outflows of connector fibers in Gaskell's scheme, the bulbosacral and the prosomatic. It blocks the impulses of those nerves. The thoracicolumbar outflow, by contrast, shows no damage in either the experiments or the clinical evidence. The exact site of the block was not found, and neither was its inner mechanism. But the lesion is peripheral, not central, and it cannot be a physical break in the conducting path. A break could never answer to massive stimulation, or answer again afterward, as these nerves do.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dickson EC, Shevky R. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1923 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
BOTULISM. STUDIES ON THE MANNER IN WHICH THE TOXIN OF CLOSTRIDIUM BOTULINUM ACTS UPON THE BODY By Ernest C. Dickson, Richard Shevky Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.37.5.711 ABSTRACT A survey of the results of these experiments shows, we believe conclusively, that in botulinus intoxication in cats, dogs, and rabbits there is a specific effect upon the portions of the autonomic nervous system which Gaskell (14) described as the bulbosacral and prosomatic outflows of connector fibers respectively, which results in a blocking of the nerve impulses of these nerves. The experimental as well as the clinical evidence indicates that there is no damage to the nerves of the thoracicolumbar outflow. The exact location of the damage has not been ascertained nor has the mechanism by which the nerve impulse is blocked been determined. The experiments show, however, that the lesions in these portions of the nervous system are not of central distribution but are peripheral, and that the block cannot be due to an organic break in the conduction apparatus but must be due to some derangement which is relatively unstable. If it were otherwise it would not be possible to induce a physiological response even by massive stimulation, nor could the response be subsequently repeated by stimuli which lie within the limits of normal intensity. The application of the results of these experiments to the clinical manifestations of botulism will be discussed in a later report after the effect of the toxin upon the skeletal motor nerves has been described. BOTULISM. STUDIES ON THE MANNER IN WHICH THE TOXIN OF CLOSTRIDIUM BOTULINUM ACTS UPON THE BODY. I. THE EFFECT UPON THE AUTONOMIC NERVOUS SYSTEM.* t BY ERNEST C. DICKSON, M.D., AND RICHARD SHEVKY, PH.D. (From the Laboratory of Experimental Medicine of Stanford University Medical School, San Francisco.) (Received for publication, December 19, 1922.) The generally accepted conception of the symptom-complex of botulinus intoxication in human beings is best summarized by Van Ermengem (1) who wrote: The botulism syndrome consists essentially in a group of neuroparalytic phenomena: disturbances of secretion of the gastrointestinal tract and symmetrical motor paralysis, complete or partial, probably caused by lesions of the medulla oblongata, of the pons, especially of the nuclei of the various cerebral nerves, and of the anterior horns of the spinal cord. It is characterized by an inhibition of, or increase in the secretion of saliva and of the buccopharyngeal mucus, by more or less complete external and internal ophthalmoplegia (blepharoptosis, mydriasis, paralysis of accommodation, diplopia, and internal strabismus); by dysphagia, aphonia, obstinate constipation, and retention of urine; by general weakness of contraction in all the voluntary muscles; by an absence of fever and of disturbance of the general sensation or of intelligence. In 1894-96 Van Ermengem proved that the immediate cause of botulism in human beings or in animals isa toxin which is elaborated by the growth of Clostrid- ium botulinum in preserved foods, and since that time there have been many attempts to ascertain the manner in which the toxin acts upon the body to pro- duce these various signs and symptoms. The majority of investigators have *These experiments are a part of an investigation of botulism which was made in California by the United States Public Health Service, Stanford University, and the University of California under a grant from the National Canners' Asso- ciation, the Canners' League of California, and the California Olive Association. t The experiments were performed in the Laboratory of Experimental Medicine at Stanford University Medical School and in the Department of Physiology at Stanford University. We desire to express our indebtedness to Professor E. G. Martin for the facilities of his department and for his interest and advice through- out the course of the investigation. 711 BOTULISM. I followed the lead suggested by Van Ermengem by attempting to demonstrate organic changes in the cells of the nuclei of the cranial motor nerves which would afford anatomical cause for the characteristic disturbances of function. Marinesco (2) was the first to study the tissues of the nervous system in this way, his observations being made upon the brains and cords of animals in which Van Ermengem had induced experimental botulism. He described changes in the finer structure of the ganglion cells of the brain and cord. They were most marked in the cord in the enlargements which correspond to the extremities, less marked in the medulla oblongata, pons, and peduncles, and almost absent in the ganglion cells of the cerebral hemispheres. He observed the changes in the nuclei of the nervus hypoglossus, the nucleus ambiguus, the dorsal nuclei of the vagi, the Purkinje cells of the cerebellum, and the middle nucleus of the nervus oculomotorius, and described them as follows: In the first stage one finds only a diminution of the chromatophilic elements extending from the periphery of the cells, but later the Nissl granules are reduced to fine powder- like granules. Stilllater there is absorption of the achromatophilic substance and vacuoles appear, and in the vicinity of these lesions there is proliferation of the glia cells to produce neuronophages which take up the destroyed material. He did not find any destruction of the nerve fibers. Kempner and Pollack (3) reported similar destructive lesions in the nerve cells of the brain and cord but also found an earlier stage in the protoplasmic degeneration which they described as a "klumpige Schwellung" of the cell granules. They did not observe any proliferation of the glia cells. These authors noted that when an animal was protected from the toxin by the administration of botulinus antitoxin, the lesions in the nerve cells persisted for at least 2 weeks after the clinical manifestations had cleared up, and they were unable to demon- strate any correlation between the nerve cell damage and the severity of symptoms. Ossipoff (4) agreed with Marinesco that the lesions in the cells were most marked in the cord, especially in the portions which supplied the nerves to the extremities, and that they were less marked in the bulb, but he also found similar lesions in the Purkinje cells of the whole brain. He stated, however, that he had not found sufficient reason to assume that the changes in the nerve cells are specific of botulism and different from changes which occur after the adminis- tration of other toxins such as diphtheria and tetanus toxins. RSmer and Stein (5) made careful studies of the nuclei of the oculomotor nerves in monkeys which they had injected with botulinus toxin and they found tigrolysis, pycnosis, clumping of Nissl granules, and, in more advanced cases, complete disintegration of cellular structure in the impaired median nucleus. They concluded that there was sufficient histologic change in the nerve cells to account for the disturbance of function in the muscles of the eyes of these animals. All these observers based their conclusions upon a study of the tissues of animals in which the intoxication had been experimentally produced, and there are few reports in which analogous studies have been made of the brains of 712 ERNEST C. DICKSON AND RICHARD SHEVKY human victims of botulism. Brger (6) recorded that the cells of the cerebrum were normal in the brain of a woman