ON THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE SUBMILIARY MYOCARDIAL NODULES OF ASCHOFF IN RHEUMATIC FEVER.
Thalhimer W, Rothschild MA. · 1914
Read ON THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE SUBMILIARY MYOCARDIAL NODULES OF ASCHOFF IN RHEUMATIC FEVER. by Thalhimer W, Rothschild MA. (1914) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2125190.txt.
Introduction
William Thalhimer and M. A. Rothschild of Mount Sinai surveyed the Aschoff nodule in 1914, the tiny heart-muscle focus named for Aschoff, and asked what it proves in rheumatic fever. In rheumatic heart inflammation the nodules are present and characteristic. They favor the left ventricle's walls, while the auricles usually escape.
The diagnostic weight comes from the comparisons. Nodules appeared in three cases of chorea with no joint signs at all, tying that movement disorder firmly to rheumatism. They were absent in fourteen cases of subacute bacterial endocarditis caused by Streptococcus mitis, and in endocardial infections by four other named germs. Where an old rheumatic infection has burned out, the nodules may be gone, but their healed scars, dense sclerotic patches, remain. Readers get a microscope finding promoted to a court of appeal for diagnosis.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thalhimer W, Rothschild MA. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1914 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
ON THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE SUBMILIARY MYOCARDIAL NODULES OF ASCHOFF IN RHEUMATIC FEVER By William Thalhimer, M. A. Rothschild Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.19.5.417 ABSTRACT 1. In rheumatic myocarditis, foci, termed submiliary nodules of Aschoff, are present which are characteristic of the rheumatic infection. 2. They are most frequently found in the walls of the left ventricle, the auricles usually escaping. 3. The nodules were found in three cases of chorea without joint manifestations, proving the close relation of this condition to rheumatism. 4. They were absent in fourteen cases of subacute bacterial endocarditis due to Streptococcus mitis. 5. They were not found in infections of the endocardium with the gonococcus, staphylococcus, streptococcus, or pneumococcus. 6. Even in the absence of a rheumatic history we believe, in accordance with Fraenkel, that the presence of Aschoff bodies signifies a previous rheumatic infection. 7. Aschoff bodies are not always found in rheumatic carditis, where the infection antedates death by a long period, but the healed remains, represented by sclerotic patches ("Schwielen"), are present. 8. We suggest that the cases of arthritis characterized by the presence of the submiliary nodules of Aschoff in the myocardium be placed in one group and called for the time being "rheumatism"; and the cases with articular manifestations, yielding positive bacteriological findings and no Aschoff bodies, should be classified according to the infecting microörganisms concerned, and not as rheumatism. ON THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE SUBMILIARY MYO- CARDIAL NODULES OF ASCHOFF IN RHEUMATIC FEVER.* BY WILLIAM THALHIMER, M.D., AI~D M. A. ROTHSCHILD, M.D. (From the Pathological Laboratory of the Mount Sinai Hospital, New York.) PLATES 46 TO 48. Aschof, in 19o4, described what he considered a specific microscopic lesion in the myocardium of cases of acute rheumatic fever. Previously Romberg and his pupils had noted that interstitial changes and inflammatory loci occur in the myocardium of cases succumbing either to the acute fever or to chronic valvular disease of rheumatic origin. Aschoff called the focal lesions "submil- iary nodules of rheumatic fever," and stated that they occur near the small or medium sized vessels, to the adventitia of which they often have close relation. The lesions consist of large cells with one or more large polymorphous nuclei, the cells being arranged in the form of a fan or rosette. The central portion of the nodule is composed of faintly staining, apparently necrotic masses of pro- toplasm. The giant cells, so called, resemble the large cells of certain sar- comatous or pseudoleukemic growths. The nodules include also large and small lymphocytes and polymorphonuclear leucocytes. The small lymphocytes are numerous at the periphery. Aschoff believes that the giant cells arise as a result of swelling from the adventitial " I47anderaellen." These cells give the cell masses their characteristic appearance. Geipel studied seven cases of rheumatic myocarditis, of which one was com- plicated by staphylococcus abscesses in the myocardium, and another by gono- coccus endocarditis. The nodules occurred in the intermuscular connective tissue, especially about the blood vessels. He describes their origin as follows: "There is first an increase in the size of the connective tissue cells, both the nuclei and the cytoplasm taking part in the process. Later the nuclei subdivide and in some cases the cells become confluent. As a result, giant cells, 15 to 23 microns in size, develop, and these assume a peripheral arrangement about the connective tissue fibers, the latter staining faintly in the center of the nodules." Geipel's view of the origin of the nodules, namely from the interstitial con- nective tissue, is in contradistinction to Aschof's view of their origin from the adventitial " Wanderaellen." Geipel also made a study of the blood vessels in other organs and failed to find any lesions resembling ~he Aschoff bodies. He believes that the rheumatic virus exerts a characteristic effect upon the cardiac interstitial tissue, that the * This work was done under the tenure of a George Blumenthal, Jr., Fellow- ship. Received for publication, February 3, 1914. 417 418 Nodules of Asehoff in Rheumatic Fever. latter undergoes a certain degree of necrosis, followed by a form of productive inflammation which exhibits itself in the formation of the Aschoff bodies. He does not admit, however, that the Aschoff bodies are specific for rheumatic myo- carditis, for he claims to have observed similar nodules in the heart of a case of chronic interstitial nephritis. But as adherent pericardium coexisted, there is the possibility, as suggested by Aschoff, of a previous rheumatic infection. Coombs demonstrated the bodies in several series of cases, chiefly in the wall of the left ventricle. They were absent from non-rheumatic cases. W~ichter reported a case in which the bodies were abundant, and Bracht and W~ichter later found the nodules in three cases of acute articular rheumatism. However, in a fourth case, giving a rheumatic history, the bodies were absent. In two of the cases a Streptococcus mitis1 type of organism was cultivated from the heart's blood post mortem. They failed to reproduce the lesions in animals. Saigo observed the bodies in five hearts from persons giving a previous history of rheumatism. In one instance, a woman, dying of sarcoma of the uterus, who had suffered from acute articular rheumatism twenty-seven years previously, scars with an occasional giant cell were presen, a finding which he considered sufficient proof of a previous rheumatic infection. Takayasu and Lfw each found the nodules in one case. Fraenkel, in order to test the specificity of the Aschoff bodies, made post-mortem studies of twenty cases in which blood cul- tures had been made intra vitam. He demonstrated the value of the Unna- Pappenheim methyl-green pyronin stain for differentiating them from other loci. Eight of his twenty cases had given a rheumatic hisrtory. In seven cases no history was available and five subjects had not suffered from rheumatism. One instance was similar to one of ours, there being a superadded vegetative endo- carditis due to an infection by Streptococcus mitis. Of the eight cases in which a definite history of rheumatism was obtainable, five showed Aschoff bodies. In the remaining three cases the attack of rheumatism occurred three, seven, and twenty years respectively before death. However, fibrous scars oc- curred with a few characteristic cells in a case eighteen years after an attack of acute rheumatic fever. He calls attention to the occurrence in old cases of fibrous scars which infiltrate the myocardium. In the five cases in which there was no history of rheumatism, the nodules were absent in two, characteristic cells were found in two, and the cells and nodules in one. The fifth case was one of chorea without joint manifestations, and the characteristic nodules were present. In seven cases of verrucous endocarditis, without history, Aschoff bodies or their remains were present in six. Fraenkel believes that even in the absence of a history of rheumatism the finding o.f Aschoff bodies is strong presumptive evidence of a preceding rheumatic infection. In the hearts of patients dying from infection of the endocardium by the streptococcus, staphylo- coccus, pneumococcus, Bacillus aerogenes, or the diphtheria bacillus, Aschoff bodies could not be demonstrated. Douglas found the bodies in one case of acute rheumatic fever, and Huzella found them in