EXPERIMENTAL ARTHRITIS IN THE RABBIT, PRODUCED WITH STREPTOCOCCUS MITIS.
Rothschild MA, Thalhimer W. · 1914
Read EXPERIMENTAL ARTHRITIS IN THE RABBIT, PRODUCED WITH STREPTOCOCCUS MITIS. by Rothschild MA, Thalhimer W. (1914) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2125185.txt.
Introduction
M. A. Rothschild and William Thalhimer of Mount Sinai Hospital in New York produced arthritis in rabbits with Streptococcus mitis in 1914, and weighed what that means for rheumatic fever. Half the injected rabbits developed joint inflammation. Its character, they report, is identical with the arthritis made by the microbe claimed as rheumatism's specific cause.
The joint fluid matches too. The germ itself could be recovered from only about a third of the sore joints. Other streptococci make a different arthritis: more tissue destruction, more permanence, and fluid crowded with pus cells. The authors' conclusion cuts against the specificity school. A few of their animals did go chronic, with eroded cartilage. Readers get an animal result used, carefully, to argue about what counts as a cause in human rheumatism.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rothschild MA, Thalhimer W. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1914 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
EXPERIMENTAL ARTHRITIS IN THE RABBIT, PRODUCED WITH STREPTOCOCCUS MITIS By M. A. Rothschild, William Thalhimer Published in: The Journal of Experimental Medicine DOI: 10.1084/jem.19.5.444 ABSTRACT 1. We have produced arthritis in 50 per cent. of the rabbits injected with Streptococcus mitis. 2. The character of the arthritis is identical with that produced by Micrococcus rheumaticus. 3. The exudate in and about the joints partakes of the same nature as that caused by Streptococcus rheumaticus. 4. Bacteriological studies show that Streptococcus mitis can be recovered from about one third of the affected joints. 5. Arthritis produced by other types of streptococci differs by reason of greater destruction of tissue, by being more permanent in character, and by the exudate containing large numbers of polymorphonuclear leucocytes. 6. The deduction of a distinct variety or species of streptococcus based upon the power to cause arthritis in rabbits is unwarranted. EXPERIMENTAL ARTHRITIS IN THE RABBIT, PRO- DUCED WITH STREPTOCOCCUS MITIS.* BY M. A. ROTHSCHILD, M.D., AND WILLIAM THALHIMER, M.D. (From the Pathological Laboratory of the Mount Sinai Hospital, New York.) Arthritis has been produced in animals by means of various micro- organisms. Those persons who advocate the specificity of Micro- coccus rheumaticus in acute rheumatic fever find much positive sup- port in the results obtained from the inoculation of animals in which arthritis, endocarditis, or pericarditis occur. In view of this con- sideration we have been led to inject rabbits with Streptococcus mitis isolated intra vitam from cases of subacute bacterial endocar- ditis, with the results to be described in this paper. This communication does not deal with the etiology of rheuma- tism. Clinicians and pathologists must first decide what shall be termed acute articular rheumatism. However, as weI have pointed out, one group of cases of rheumatism exists in which there is a characteristic myocardial lesion (Aschoff bodies) associated with a verrucous endocarditis and unattended by embolic phenomena. Bacteriological examination in these cases is negative. There is a large second group comprising the bacterial infections of the endo- cardium, and a third group of bacterial or toxic arthritides with or without endocarditis. It is possible to produce arthritis in rabbits by means of Bacillus pyogenes fetidus liquefaciens, staphylococci, hemolytic streptococci, the streptococcus of epidemic sore throat, Achalme's bacillus, Micro- coccus rheumaticus isolated from the throat, blood, and joints, Streptococcus salivarius and fecalis (Horder), the pneumococcus, and Streptococcus viridans. Rosenow has reported the production of arthritis with Streptococcus viridans in a small percentage, and of endocarditis in a large percentage of rabbits. Our figures have been quite the reverse; that is, 5 per cent. of our rabbits developed * This work was done under the tenure of a George Blumenthal, Jr., Fellow- ship. Received for publication, February 3, I914. 1 Thalhimer, W., and Rothschild, M. A., Jour. Exper. Med., I914, xix, 4:7. 444 M. A. Rothschild and William Thalhimer. 445 arthritis and 7 per cent. endocarditis. We have employed nine different strains of Streptococcus mitis (table I). By reference to the table it will be seen that there is a slight variation in the ability of the different strains to produce arthritis. TABLE I. Organism. No. of rabbits. Arthritis. Endocarditis. 4,I10 4,147 4,206 4,275 4,I7O 4,342 4,357 2,524 c io 9 7 6 3 3 2 I I 4 2 22 3 50% 7% CHARACTER OF THE ARTHRITIS. The rabbits described here are the same as those reported in our communication z in which the method of injection, the media used, Rabbit 53. TABLE II.S Organism 4,275. Injected Ma 26, I9x3. 5 Injections. Date. Left fore foot. Right fore foot. Left hind foot. Right hind foot. June 9 ......... June I4 ........ June I6 ........ June 24 ........ June 29 ........ July 3 ......... .-{-4 ++ ++ +++ +++ +++ (Elbow) + (Wrist) + + ++ ++ + Killed July 7.......... July 9 .......... July 2I ......... I July 28 ......... } Aug. 25 ......... I Sept. 3 ......... - + - ++ - + + - + - + - + + + + + ++ ++ + + + + + ++ ++ + + ~-Thalhimer, W., and Rothschild, M. A., Iour. Exper. Med., 1914, xix, 429. a Beattie (]our. Path. and Bacteriol., I9IO, xiv, 436, table VI) shows in a graphic manner the involvement of the joints of a rabbit that was injected with a streptococcus resembling Streptococcus rheumaticus. His table corresponds closely to tables II, III, IV, and V in our series. 4 In the tables, + = joint affected; --~ joint not affected. 446 Experimental Arthritis in the Rabbit. and the doses are given. The production of arthritis appears to be independent of the doses of the streptococci and the media employed. By reference to tables II, III, IV, and V the evanescent and mi- TABLE III. Rabbit IO. Organism 4,147. Injected December lO, I912. 6 Injections. Killed January 24, x913. Date, Left fore foot. Right fore foot. Left hind foot. Right hind foot, Dec. 26 ........ Dec. 27 ........ Dee. 28 ........ Dec. 29 ........ Dee. 31 ........ Jan. 6 ......... Jan. I3 ........ Jan. 17 ........ Jan. 22 ........ Jan. 24 ........ Limps; ankle swollen. No limp; ankle swollen. Ankle swollen. Ankle swollen. Ankle swollen. Swelling smaller. Swelling smaller. Swelling smaller. Swelling smaller. Rabbit xS. Organism 4,1Io. TABLE IV. Injected December 22, 1912. 4 Injections. Died February 2o, 1913. Date__ . Left fore foot. Dee. 25 ..... [ Dee. 27 ..... [ Dec. 3I ..... l Jan. I3 ...... [ Jan. i8 ...... l Limps; ankle swollen Jan. 25 ...... t Right fore foot. Stiff LeftLimpshind foot. ,. Right __hindfoot. Ankle swollen Stiff i = P - Rabbit 70. Organism 4,357. TABLE V. Injected June 24, I913. 13, I9z3. 2 Injections. Died July Date. June 27 ........ June 28 ........ June 29 ........ July 3 .......... July 7 ......... July 9 ......... July I3 ........ Left fore foot. Right fore foot. Left hind foot. Stiff + + Knee + + + Right hind foot. Stiff + + Knee + ++ + gratory character of the arthritis is seen. Authors have used these characters as an argument for the specificity of a special organism M. A. Rothschild and William Thalhimer. 447 in causing acute articular rheumatism. The fact that the joints after extensive involvement return to a normal condition has been emphasized by Poynton and Paine, Beattie, and others. The arthri- tis produced by Streptococcus miffs has the same general charac- teristics. In some of the animals a chronic type of arthritis arises, the joint cartilages being eroded, the articular surfaces proliferated, and a partial ankylosis of the joint resulting. Poynton and Paine have seen the same results follow from Micrococcus rheumaticus. For control experiments we injected a number of rabbits with streptococci obtained from the sore throat epidemic in Chicago. Our results agreed with those of Davis who produced arthritis in every animal inoculated with organisms from the Chicago and Boston epidemics of sore throat. We injected a series of rabbits with hemolytic streptococci, and our results agreed with those of Cole who states: "In most cases the pathological changes in the joints are mild, consisting mainly of edema about the joint, the fluid becoming turbid, sticky,