Environmental factors and cancer of the colon and breast.

Drasar BS, Irving D. · 1973

Read Environmental factors and cancer of the colon and breast. by Drasar BS, Irving D. (1973) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2008837.txt.

Introduction

Drasar and Irving compared cancer rates across countries in 1973 to test environmental links. Breast and colon cancers were common in rich countries and rare in poorer ones. The team correlated rates for breast, colon and stomach cancer with diet measures. They also used indicators of standard of living. Their question was which shared factors tracked the disease patterns.

Breast and colon cancer were both highly correlated with fat intake. They were also highly correlated with animal protein intake. Stomach cancer behaved differently in the comparisons. The pattern supported a dietary and environmental influence, rather than geography alone. Earlier work from the same laboratory had pointed to gut bacteria as one possible link between diet and colon cancer.

Catalog record

CREATORDrasar BS, Irving D.
YEAR1973
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2008837

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Environmental Factors and Cancer of the Colon and Breast By B. S. Drasar, Doreen Irving Published in: British Journal of Cancer DOI: 10.1038/bjc.1973.20 ABSTRACT The correlation between cancer of the breast, colon and stomach dietary factors, and various indicators of standard of living was examined. Cancer of the breast and colon was highly correlated with fat and animal protein. Br. J. Cancer (1973) 27, 167. ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS AND CANCER OF THE COLON AND BREAST B. S. DRASAR AND DOREEN IRVING* From the Department of Bacteriology, WZrright-Fleming Institute of M11icrobiology, St Mary's Hospital Hedical School, London W2 IPG and the *Department of MHedical Statistics and Epidemiology, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Keppel Street, Gower Street, London JVClE 7HT Received 6 September 1972. Accepted 19 October 1972 Summary.-The correlation between cancer of the breast, colon and stomach dietary factors, and various indicators of standard of living was examined. Cancer of the breast and colon was highly correlated with fat and animal protein. CANCERS of the breast and colon occur most commonly in the developed coun- tries. The incidence of these cancers is high in North America and North West Europe and low in South America, Africa and Asia (e.g. Doll, 1969). Previous papers from this laboratory have discussed the role of bacteria in the aetiology of cancer of the colon and breast (Aries et al., 1-969; Hill et al., 1971a; Hill, Goddard and Williams, 197 lb; Drasar and Hill, 1972). Implicit in these dis- cussions is the assumption that these cases are associated with some dietary factors. Protein (Gregor, Toman and Prasova, 1969), fat (Wynder and Shigematsu, 1967), refined carbohydrate and fibre (Bur- kitt, 1971; Walker, 1971) have been suggested as determinants. This paper considers the world-wide variations in nutrition and socio-economic development and their relation to cancers of the colon, breast and stomach. Cancer of the stomach was included for consideration since the studies of Wynder and Shigematsu (1967) suggest that it has a negative correlation with cancer of the colon and further the work of Gregor et al. (1969) showed a relationship with protein intake. SOURCE OF THE DATA Nutritional surveys are available for only a few countries, but the Food and Agriculture Organisation (F.A.O.) pub- lishes annually an estimate of the food TABLE I. Populations Included in the Analyses in this Paper Populations also Other populations considered earlier bv considered in the Wynder and Shigematsu analyses in this (1967) paper EUROPE EUROPE Austria Greece Belgium Hungary Denmark Poland Finland Romania France Yugoslavia German F.R. AMERICA Ireland Colombia Italy Jamaica Netherlands Uruguay Norway Venezuela Portugal ASIA Sweden China (Taiwan) Switzerlan(l Indlia U.K. Singapore AMERICA AFRICA Canada Alozambique Chile Nigeria U.S. White South Africa ASIA (Johannesburg Israel Africans) Japan Uganda OCEANIA Australia New Zealand B. S. DRASAR AND DOREEN IRVING TABLE II.-Factors Considered for 37 Countries in the Calculation of the Correlation Matrix Incidence cancer of the stomach cancer of the breast cancer of the colon Available animal protein total protein sugars and sweets eggs Available total fat combined fat animal fat fibre Cash income per person per year radio receivers television receivers motor vehicles available each day per person in many countries (F.A.O., 1969). In view of this relatively comprehensive coverage, and despite the fact that they refer to the food available assuming equal distribution within a country, these F.A.O. data were used as the basis of the nutritional data since it is only by using these figures that data from sufficient countries can be examined to enable useful correlations to be obtained. The cancer incidence figures are from the records of cancer registries and other sources and were taken from Doll's (1969) review. Other non-dietary indices of the standard of living were also taken into account; these were based upon the data presented in the United Nations Year Book for 1970. Data on cancer incidence, diet and other factors were obtained for 37 coun- tries (Table I); of these countries 21 had been considered previously by Wynder and Shigematsu (1967). FACTORS EXAMINED The factors examined are listed in Table II. Animal and total protein data are as presented by the F.A.O., Annex Tables series G: Estimated calorie and protein content of national average food Notes and sources Annual rates per 100,000 persons aged 35-64 years standardized for age (male rates except breast) (Doll, 1969) Grams per person per day F.A.O. data Grams per person per day Calculated from F.A.O. data Dollars. United Nations Statistical Year Book Availability per 1000 persons. Calculated from data in United Nations Statistical Year Book. supply per caput. Animal fat, total fat and combined fat were calculated, on the basis of standard analyses (Davidson and Passmore, 1963), from the data presented by the F.A.O. Annex Tables series F: per caput food supplies available for human consumption in selected countries. Combined fat differs from total fat in that fat consumed as oils and fats, e.g. butter and cooking oil, is excluded from the former. Estimates of fibre content were also based on the series F tables. Cereals, potatoes and other starchy foods (e.g. plantains), pulses, nuts and seeds, veget- ables and fruit were all assumed to contain fibre. The consumption of 70% extrac- tion flour containing less the 0.1 mg of fibre per 100 g was assumed to be limited to the developed countries, North America, North West Europe and Australasia. Other regions were assumed to use 100% extraction flour containing 2-2 mg of fibre per 100 g. The fibre content in all cereals was related to that in wheat. Vegetables, pulses etc. were assumed to contain 3% fibre (Cruickshank, 1946). RESULTS Inter-relations of cancers In the 37 countries considered in the main analysis cancer of the colon was 168 ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS AND CANCER OF THE COLON AND BREAST 169 TABLE III.-The Inter-relation of Some Cancers Type of data Mortality rates Incidence rates Incidence rates Incidence rates Incidence rates Incidence rates Note Wynder and Shigematsu (1967) Countries considered by Wynder and Shigematsu (1967) Countries considered in dietary analysis Countries listed by Doll (1969) Countries considered in dietary analysis Countries listed by Doll (1969) Correlation coefficient r = 8104 0 0 0 0 .0 * . 0 .00 a*-0 : w e_ ^ of 0 0 0 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Age adjusted annual rates of breast cancer / 100,000 Fic. 1.-Correlation between colon and breast cancer rates. highly correlated with cancer of the breast (Fig. 1). This relationship was also seen when all the incidence data available were considered (Table III) but neither cancer was significantly correlated with cancer of the stomach (Fig. 2, Table III). However, if the data for countries con- sidered previously were extracted a nega- tive correlation between cancer of the colon and stomach was seen. The present analysis includes data for underdeveloped countries not considered previously (Table I). Relation of cancers to dietary and socio-economic factors No significant correlation between the incidence of stomach cancer and any of the nutritional or economic factors con- sidered was detected and these results are not presented in detail. Correlation coeffi- cients for breast and colon cancer incidence with the various factors considered are shown in Fig. 3. Both cancers were highly correlated with indicators of affluence such as

Read the complete text