The hierarchy of stability and predictability in orthognathic surgery with rigid fixation: an update and extension.
Proffit WR, Turvey TA, Phillips C. · 2007
Read The hierarchy of stability and predictability in orthognathic surgery with rigid fixation: an update and extension. by Proffit WR, Turvey TA, Phillips C. (2007) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc1876453.txt.
Introduction
Proffit, Turvey and Phillips updated in 2007 the stability ranking for jaw surgery that repositions the face bones. Orthognathic surgery moves the jaws to fix bite and facial balance, and metal rigid fixation holds the bones while they heal. Not all movements stay put equally well, so surgeons plan around a known hierarchy.
Two additions join the list: fixing facial asymmetry holds well with rigid fixation, and chin repositioning is very stable. In the first year after surgery, corrections for Class II long-face patterns held better than those for Class III patterns. Between one and five years the picture flips, with Class III patients then more stable. Changes over two millimeters occurred in a surprisingly large share of patients even after healing. Teeth usually adapt, so bite changes lag behind bone changes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Proffit WR, Turvey TA, Phillips C. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2007 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The hierarchy of stability and predictability in orthognathic surgery with rigid fixation: an update and extension By William R Proffit, Timothy A Turvey, Ceib Phillips Published in: Head & Face Medicine DOI: 10.1186/1746-160X-3-21 ABSTRACT A hierarchy of stability exists among the types of surgical movements that are possible with orthognathic surgery. This report updates the hierarchy, focusing on comparison of the stability of procedures when rigid fixation is used. Two procedures not previously placed in the hierarchy now are included: correction of asymmetry is stable with rigid fixation and repositioning of the chin also is very stable. During the first post-surgical year, surgical movements in patients treated for Class II/long face problems tend to be more stable than those treated for Class III problems. Clinically relevant changes (more than 2 mm) occur in a surprisingly large percentage of orthognathic surgery patients from one to five years post-treatment, after surgical healing is complete. During the first post-surgical year, patients treated for Class II/long face problems are more stable than those treated for Class III problems; from one to five years post-treatment, some patients in both groups experience skeletal change, but the Class III patients then are more stable than the Class II/long face patients. Fewer patients exhibit long-term changes in the dental occlusion than skeletal changes, because the dentition usually adapts to the skeletal change. BACKGROUND The Dentofacial Program at the University of North Carolina was begun in 1975 as a way to coordinate the evaluation and treatment of patients who needed orthodontics and orthognathic surgery, and as a way to facilitate research in this area. A research grant focused on the outcomes of orthognathic surgery at UNC, funded by the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research, enters its 28th year in June 2007. This research project has resulted in more than 100 research papers in peer-reviewed journals, and about half that many invited contributions and book chapters. It became obvious by the 1990s that a major influence on the outcomes of orthognathic surgery was the amount and direction of surgical movement. A series of research papers that focused specifically on stability as related to the different surgical movements was summarized in 1996 in a paper outlining a hierarchy of stability related to surgical movements [1]. The purpose of this paper is to update the hierarchy by extending it to include treatment of asymmetries and provide further information with regard to long-term stability. METHODS The data base created through this project currently (February 2007) has records on 2264 patients who have had orthognathic surgery. Nearly twice that many have had initial records through the Dentofacial Program after they were referred for evaluation. Many of these were judged not to need surgery; the remainder did not accept it if it was recommended [2,3]. As of February 2007, at least one year follow-up is available for 1475 patients who did receive surgery, and five year or longer postsurgical follow-up is available for 507 patients. Stability has been evaluated primarily from lateral cephalometric radiographs, which for all our studies have been oriented with the SN line rotated down 6° anteriorly, a position that approximates natural head position and is more reproducible than the Frankfort plane. This horizontal line is used as the x axis, and a vertical plane perpendicular to it through sella as the y axis, so that changes in landmark locations can be registered as x, y coordinate changes. When stability is considered, it is important to keep in mind that there is not a normal distribution of post-surgical or post-treatment change. Instead, most of the changes occur in a few of the patients. Mean changes and standard deviations, therefore, can be misleading. The error in locating most cephalometric landmarks is less than 1 mm, and does not exceed 2 mm for any landmark. The hierarchy of procedures presented in this paper is primarily based on the number (percentage) of patients who experienced changes of at least 2 mm. We consider changes of <2 mm within the range of method error and clinically insignificant; 2–4 mm outside the range of method error and potentially clinically significant; and >4 mm as often beyond the range of orthodontic compensation and clinically highly significant. The results presented below represent a compilation of stability data from the UNC database that have been reported previously in separate publications. RESULTS For the purposes of this extension of the hierarchy, it is important to differentiate post-surgical stability (changes in the first post-surgical year, which relate directly to the surgical healing, post-treatment orthodontics and short-term physiologic adaptation) from post-treatment stability (changes beyond one year post-surgery, which relate to long-term adaptation and for some patients, to post-treatment growth). The First Post-Surgical Year A revised hierarchy for post-surgical stability (the first post-surgical year) is shown in Figure 1. Asymmetry and genioplasty have been added, and the surgical movements are grouped to emphasize the similarity of stability (percent of patients with >=2 mm changes) with different surgical procedures. The grouping simply reflects that differences between some procedures in the hierarchy are quite small, while other differences can be quite large. Considering the procedures as they are grouped: [Figure: The extended hierarchy of stability, showing relative stability during the first postsurgical year.] Highly stable It is interesting that the two single-jaw procedures used to correct skeletal Class II problems, superior repositioning of the maxilla and advancement of the mandible, fall into the highly stable category [4-11]. This was also true with wire fixation. It must be kept in mind, however, that mandibular advancement at UNC has been restricted to patients with short or normal face height. Early experience showed a lack of stability with ramus surgery to rotate the mandible at the osteotomy site so that the chin was moved up to close an anterior open bite, and we have used superior repositioning of the maxilla (with or without mandibular surgery) for these long face patients, so that the rotation occurred at the condyle instead. With rigid fixation, the maxilla is quite stable during the first postsurgical year when moved up (Figure 2), and there is almost no chance of clinically significant change. The composite tracing for the mandible (Figure 3) from immediate postsurgery to one year also shows almost no mean change in the horizontal position of the mandible, but the majority of the patients experience >2 mm upward movement of gonion due to remodeling in that area. Clinically, > 90% of the patients treated with either of these surgical procedures are judged to have excellent results. [Figure: A composite tracing for 42 patients in whom the maxilla was moved up >2 mm. With this surgical movement and rigid fixation, there is almost no relapse tendency. The tracing shows a small upward movement from immediate postsurgery to one year that is due to removal of the surgical splint.] [Figure: A composite tracing for 40 patients in whom the mandible was advanced >2 mm. The only significant change is a shortening of ramus height due to remodeling at the gonial angle, which is expected after a ramus osteotomy.] Lower border osteotomy to reposition the chin also falls into the highly stable category, [12] with better remodeling of the symphysis noted in younger patients