Developmental neurotoxicity of pyrethroid insecticides: critical review and future research needs.

Shafer TJ, Meyer DA, Crofton KM. · 2005

Read Developmental neurotoxicity of pyrethroid insecticides: critical review and future research needs. by Shafer TJ, Meyer DA, Crofton KM. (2005) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc1277854.txt.

Introduction

Shafer, Meyer, and Crofton reviewed pyrethroid insecticides and the developing brain in 2005. Pyrethroids hold 25 percent of the world insecticide market. Adult nerve effects are well characterized. Effects on developing brains were far less charted.

Newborn rats proved at least ten times more sensitive than adults. That gap held for two tested pyrethroids. Most others lack age-specific toxicity data entirely. The review covers 22 developmental studies in depth. Motor activity and a brain receptor density changed most often. Shafer flags sodium channel development as the key backdrop. It appeared in Environmental Health Perspectives in 2005.

Catalog record

CREATORShafer TJ, Meyer DA, Crofton KM.
YEAR2005
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
LICENSECC0 1.0 Universal
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC1277854

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Developmental Neurotoxicity of Pyrethroid Insecticides: Critical Review and Future Research Needs By Timothy J Shafer, Douglas A Meyer, Kevin M Crofton Published in: Environmental Health Perspectives DOI: 10.1289/ehp.7254 ABSTRACT Abstract Pyrethroid insecticides have been used for more than 40 years and account for 25% of the worldwide insecticide market. Although their acute neurotoxicity to adults has been well characterized, information regarding the potential developmental neurotoxicity of this class of compounds is limited. There is a large age dependence to the acute toxicity of pyrethroids in which neonatal rats are at least an order of magnitude more sensitive than adults to two pyrethroids. There is no information on age-dependent toxicity for most pyrethroids. In the present review we examine the scientific data related to potential for age-dependent and developmental neurotoxicity of pyrethroids. As a basis for understanding this neurotoxicity, we discuss the heterogeneity and ontogeny of voltage-sensitive sodium channels, a primary neuronal target of pyrethroids. We also summarize 22 studies of the developmental neurotoxicity of pyrethroids and review the strengths and limitations of these studies. These studies examined numerous end points, with changes in motor activity and muscarinic acetylcholine receptor density the most common. Many of the developmental neurotoxicity studies suffer from inadequate study design, problematic statistical analyses, use of formulated products, and/or inadequate controls. These factors confound interpretation of results. To better understand the potential for developmental exposure to pyrethroids to cause neurotoxicity, additional, well-designed and well-executed developmental neurotoxicity studies are needed. These studies should employ state-of-the-science methods to promote a greater understanding of the mode of action of pyrethroids in the developing nervous system. Keywords: age-dependent toxicity, biologically based dose–response model, developmental neurotoxicity, mode of action, physiologically based pharmacokinetic model, pyrethroid, risk assessment, voltage-sensitive sodium channel Pyrethroid insecticides have been used in agricultural and home formulations for more than 30 years and account for approximately one-fourth of the worldwide insecticide market (Casida and Quistad 1998). Currently, 16 pyrethroids are registered for use in the United States in a large variety of agricultural or consumer products (Bryant and Bite 2003). Often, pyrethroids are sold and/or used as mixtures containing a combination of two or more compounds (Farm Chemicals Handbook 1997). Exposure to pyrethroids has been widely documented in humans, including exposure of pregnant women, infants, and children (Berkowitz et al. 2003; Huedorf et al. 2004; Schettgen et al. 2002; Whyatt et al. 2002). Although the acute toxicity of these compounds to adults has been well characterized, the potential for developmental toxicity of pyrethroids is not well understood. In the present review we focus on the potential for neurotoxicity after developmental exposure to pyrethroid insecticides. We also consider the current state and quality of scientific data that could be used to support risk decisions related to pyrethroid developmental and age-dependent neurotoxicity. Specifically, in this review we a) provide a brief overview of the toxicity of this class of compounds; b) review pyrethroid effects on voltage-sensitive sodium channels (VSSCs), a primary mode of action of pyrethroids; c) discuss the developmental profiles of VSSCs; d) provide examples of the results of perturbation of VSSCs during development by other insults; e) discuss the evidence for age-related sensitivity to this class of compounds; f ) summarize and critique studies of pyrethroid neurotoxicity after developmental exposure; and g) make recommendations regarding future research needs related to the developmental neurotoxicity of pyrethroids. In addition to being important to scientists interested in characterizing the neurotoxicity of these compounds, this information will be useful when considering the scientific data needed to inform risk decisions related to pyrethroid insecticides. Under the Food Quality Protection Act (FQPA; 1996), the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is required to include a default 10× safety factor (uncertainty factor) in risk decisions to protect against potentially greater sensitivity of developing individuals to toxic insult. This factor can be adjusted only if compelling scientific data exist regarding age-related differences in sensitivity. Furthermore, developing individuals must be considered under FQPA requirements for cumulative risk assessments (classes of compounds with the same mode of action). The quality of the scientific data used to support these and other risk decisions is an important component of scientifically based risk assessment. In addition, information regarding mode of action improves the scientific basis for risk decisions (Brock et al. 2003; Mileson et al. 1998; Sonich-Mullin et al. 2001), including those related to developmental neurotoxicity (Costa 1998; Tilson 2000a, 2000b). The U.S. EPA has recently released the revised cumulative risk assessment of the organophosphate class of insecticides (U.S. EPA 2002) and has requested that registrants of these insecticides submit developmental neurotoxicity studies to the agency. In the near future, the U.S. EPA must consider developmental and cumulative risk for other classes of insecticides, including pyrethroids. Thus, in this review we focus on issues of mode of action and age-dependent and developmental neurotoxicity as related to risk decisions under the FQPA. OVERVIEW OF PYRETHROID TOXICITY The pyrethroid class of insecticides was derived from natural compounds (the pyrethrins) isolated from the Chrysanthemum genus of plants (Casida 1980). Although natural pyrethrins do have insecticidal activity, they also are inherently unstable when exposed to light. Therefore, the pyrethrin structure was modified to produce more stable compounds that retained the desirable insecticidal and toxicologic properties (Valentine 1990). All pyrethroids contain several common features: an acid moiety, a central ester bond, and an alcohol moiety (Figure 1). The acid moiety contains two chiral carbons; thus, pyrethroids typically exist as stereoisomeric compounds. Furthermore, some compounds also contain a chiral carbon on the alcohol moiety, which allows for three chiral carbons and a total of eight different stereoenantiomers. Pyrethroid insecticidal activity (Elliot et al. 1974), acute mammalian neurotoxicity (Gray and Soderlund 1985), and effects on VSSCs (Lund and Narahashi 1982) are stereospecific, indicating the presence of specific binding sites. For some compounds, several commercial products are available that differ in stereoisomer content. For example, allethrin is a mixture of all possible allethrin stereoisomers, d-allethrin contains only the 1R isomers, bioallethrin contains only the 1R-trans isomers, and S-bioallethrin is enriched in the S stereoisomer of the 1R-trans isomers (Figure 2). [Figure: Structures of pyrethroids for which developmental neurotoxicity has been examined. Developmental neurotoxicity studies have been conducted using either technical compound or formulations of the seven pyrethroids illustrated; the numbers in parentheses after each compound name indicate the number of studies that have been conducted using that compound or a formulation containing that compound. Only one stereoisomer is illustrated for each compound.] [Figure: Eight possible stereoisomers of allethrin (A–H). The inset lists allethrin-containing products and the stereoisomer content of each.] The acute mammalian neurotoxicity of pyrethroids has been well characterized, and several comprehensive reviews of pyrethroid toxicity, metabolism, and actions are available (Kaneko and Miyamoto 2001; Narahashi 2001; Ray 2001; Soderlund et al. 2002). Verschoyle and colleagues (Verschoyle and Aldridge 1980; Verschoyle and Barnes 1972) conducted structure–activity relationship studies with a series of pyrethroids and described two generalized syndromes after acute exposure. Based on toxic signs in the rat, pyrethroids have been divided into two types: a) compounds that produce a syndrome consisting of aggressive sparring, increased sensitivity to external stimuli, and fine tremor progressing to whole-body tremor and prostration (type I or T syndrome); and b) compounds that produce a syndrome

Read the complete text