Lung cancer risk after exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: a review and meta-analysis.
Armstrong B, Hutchinson E, Unwin J, Fletcher T. · 2004
Read Lung cancer risk after exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: a review and meta-analysis. by Armstrong B, Hutchinson E, Unwin J, Fletcher T. (2004) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc1247189.txt.
Introduction
Armstrong, Hutchinson, Unwin, and Fletcher pooled studies on hydrocarbons and lung cancer in 2004. Hydrocarbon mixtures from work settings are known lung carcinogens. How risk climbs with dose was less clear. Thirty-nine worker cohorts entered the combined analysis.
At a set exposure unit, relative risk averaged 1.20, and that estimate held steady across methods and single studies. Coke ovens, gasworks, and aluminum plants clustered near 1.15 to 1.17, while other trades ran higher. Asphalt work and chimney sweeping showed far higher, though rougher, estimates. Dust exposure did not explain the pattern. Armstrong gives dose-response numbers for workplace limits. The authors say the results give risk checks a firmer base.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Armstrong B, Hutchinson E, Unwin J, Fletcher T. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2004 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| LICENSE | CC0 1.0 Universal |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Lung Cancer Risk after Exposure to Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons: A Review and Meta-Analysis By Ben Armstrong, Emma Hutchinson, John Unwin, Tony Fletcher Published in: Environmental Health Perspectives DOI: 10.1289/ehp.6895 ABSTRACT Typical polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon mixtures are established lung carcinogens, but the quantitative exposure–response relationship is less clear. To clarify this relationship we conducted a review and meta-analysis of published reports of occupational epidemiologic studies. Thirty-nine cohorts were included. The average estimated unit relative risk (URR) at 100 μg/m3 years benzo[a]pyrene was 1.20 [95% confidence interval (CI), 1.11–1.29] and was not sensitive to particular studies or analytic methods. However, the URR varied by industry. The estimated means in coke ovens, gasworks, and aluminum production works were similar (1.15–1.17). Average URRs in other industries were higher but imprecisely estimated, with those for asphalt (17.5; CI, 4.21–72.78) and chimney sweeps (16.2; CI, 1.64–160.7) significantly higher than the three above. There was no statistically significant variation of URRs within industry or in relation to study design (including whether adjusted for smoking), or source of exposure information. Limited information on total dust exposure did not suggest that dust exposure was an important confounder or modified the effect. These results provide a more secure basis for risk assessment than was previously available. Airborne polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which are emitted when organic matter is burned, are ubiquitous in the occupational and general environment. It has long been known that several PAHs can produce cancers in experimental animals, and epidemiologic studies of exposed workers, especially in coke ovens and aluminum smelters, have shown clear excesses of lung cancer and highly suggestive excesses of bladder cancer [Boffetta et al. 1997; International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) 1984, 1985, 1987; Mastrangelo et al. 1996; Negri and La Vecchia 2001]. The animal experiments have included some using airborne exposure and have been mixtures and individual compounds, including particularly benzo[a]pyrene (BaP). Although the existence of a cancer risk is beyond reasonable doubt, considerable uncertainty exists as to the exposure–response relationship, and hence as to the risks posed at today’s levels in the workplace and general environment. Information on this relationship is clearly important for setting of occupational and environmental standards. Estimating exposure–response relationships by extrapolation from animal studies is possible [Collins et al. 1991; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) 1984], but the limitation of this approach, particularly species differences, makes sole reliance on it problematic. Data from a large cohort of coke oven workers in the United States, which has been followed since the 1960s (Costantino et al. 1995; Lloyd 1971), have been used to estimate risk per unit residential exposure [Nisbet and LaGoy 1992; World Health Organization (WHO) 1987]. However, many other studies provide information that has not yet been systematically used to quantitatively assess risk. The fact that PAHs comprise a mixture, several components of which are animal carcinogens, adds to the complexity of the task. One issue is whether a single index of exposure, such as BaP or total benzene soluble matter (BSM) or cyclohexane soluble matter (CSM) is adequate to determine risk. If such an index is used, risk per unit exposure may differ between studies (and unstudied exposures) because of differences in the ratio of this index to the total carcinogenic potential of the mixture. It is possible that such variation, if present, can be adequately described by classifying exposures in broad categories (e.g., by source). However, this approach remains untested. We conducted a review and meta-analysis that aimed to use all relevant published evidence from epidemiologic studies to obtain an estimate or estimates of the relationship of PAH exposure with lung and bladder cancer and to identify sources of variation in this relationship. Here we report the results for lung cancer. METHODS The methods summarized here are described at greater length in a technical report on this work (Armstrong et al. 2002). Literature Search We sought all potentially informative peer-reviewed publications reporting epidemiologic studies on the occupational PAH–lung cancer exposure–response relationship. Specifically, we searched the following online electronic databases: MEDLINE (http://www.nlm.nih.gov/databases/databases_medline.html); EMBASE (http://www.embase.com/); OLDMEDLINE (http://www.nlm.nih.gov/databases/databases_oldmedline.html); NIOSHTIC-2 (http://www2.cdc.gov/nioshtic2/niosh2.htm); and CancerLit (http://www.cancer.gov/search/cancer_literature/). We searched publication dates 1958–February 2001) by text phrases and supplemented these publications with articles cited in the studies we obtained. We excluded the following: - Studies of workplaces where PAHs were considered unlikely to be the predominant lung or bladder carcinogen, to reduce potential for confounded results. Such workplaces included those in the rubber industry; those where primary exposure was from diesel exhaust; foundries; and steel works (because of co-exposure to silica), unless there were separate analyses specifically of coke oven workers. - Studies for which it was not possible to quantify exposure to PAHs. Hospital- and population-based case–control and registry studies were excluded for this reason. - Studies of occupational exposure other than by inhalation. - Superceded publications. Where repeated follow-ups of the same workforce were reported in several articles, only the most recent was included. - Biomarker studies because it was difficult to deduce relationships of exposure concentration to cancer incidence. - Proportional cancer analyses. - Articles not written in English. After these exclusions, 34 articles remained, of which 5 reported two distinct cohorts for which results were presented separately. Thus, there were 39 cohorts. For each included cohort we systematically extracted general descriptive information, information on potential modifiers of risk associated with PAHs, and information from which we estimated unit relative risk (URR) increments (see next two subsections). Exposure Estimation We distinguished studies according to author reports of the following: - exposures to PAHs measured as BaP (10 cohorts) - exposures to PAHs measured by a proxy that we could convert to BaP: benzene soluble matter (BSM), total PAHs, carbon black (6 cohorts) - no measures of exposure (n = 23 cohorts) For those studies with no exposure measures, we estimated exposure to PAHs for each workgroup for which cancer risk estimates were presented (e.g., for top-oven workers, side-oven workers). These exposure estimates were based on published exposure estimates in the same industries (IARC 1984; Lindstedt and Sollenberg 1982) and other published epidemiologic studies. Principle estimates thus derived are presented in Table 1. Cumulative exposure. We sought to relate cancer risk to mean cumulative exposures to BaP (duration × time-weighted mean concentration). Where risk by cumulative exposure was not published, it was derived as the product of mean estimated concentration of exposure in each group for which risk was reported and the mean duration of exposure in that group. In the absence of information on duration of exposure, 20 years was assumed, representing the average found in studies for which duration was reported. Dust exposure. At the inception of this study, we had not planned to seek information on potentially confounding exposures beyond those noted by the authors. However, interest has sharply increased recently in the hypothesis that inhaled dust carries a risk of lung cancer regardless of composition. We therefore sought to add information that we could find on dust exposure. Because few publications reported such estimates, we relied entirely on supplementary data and the judgment of the hygienists on the research team. We were aware that this would be a very rough assessment and chose a simple scale [low (< 1 mg/m3 total dust); moderate (1–5 mg/m3);