Barriers and facilitators to utilizing digital health technologies by healthcare professionals.
Borges do Nascimento IJ, Abdulazeem H, Vasanthan LT, Martinez EZ, Zucoloto ML, Østengaard L, Azzopardi-Muscat N, Zapata T, Novillo-Ortiz D. · 2023
Read Barriers and facilitators to utilizing digital health technologies by healthcare professionals. by Borges do Nascimento IJ, Abdulazeem H, Vasanthan LT, Martinez EZ, Zucoloto ML, Østengaard L, Azzopardi-Muscat N, Zapata T, Novillo-Ortiz D. (2023) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc10507089.txt.
Introduction
Borges do Nascimento and co-authors pooled reviews in 2023 on what helps or blocks digital health tools at work. Digital tools now touch most parts of care, from records to remote visits. The team searched five data banks for past reviews on barriers and aids. They kept 108 reviews that covered doctors, pharmacists, and nurses.
Weak networks and tech faults were the most cited barrier, Borges do Nascimento reports. Staff also feared more work hours and felt personal strain with new systems. Training and teaching plans stood out as a top aid. Rewards shared across sectors helped too. Staff who saw a tool as useful were far more apt to adopt it.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Borges do Nascimento IJ, Abdulazeem H, Vasanthan LT, Martinez EZ, Zucoloto ML, Østengaard L, Azzopardi-Muscat N, Zapata T, Novillo-Ortiz D. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2023 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 79 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Barriers and facilitators to utilizing digital health technologies by healthcare professionals By Israel Júnior Borges do Nascimento, Hebatullah Abdulazeem, Lenny Thinagaran Vasanthan, Edson Zangiacomi Martinez, Miriane Lucindo Zucoloto, Lasse Østengaard, Natasha Azzopardi-Muscat, Tomas Zapata, David Novillo-Ortiz Published in: NPJ Digital Medicine DOI: 10.1038/s41746-023-00899-4 ABSTRACT Abstract Digital technologies change the healthcare environment, with several studies suggesting barriers and facilitators to using digital interventions by healthcare professionals (HPs). We consolidated the evidence from existing systematic reviews mentioning barriers and facilitators for the use of digital health technologies by HP. Electronic searches were performed in five databases (Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Embase®, Epistemonikos, MEDLINE®, and Scopus) from inception to March 2023. We included reviews that reported barriers or facilitators factors to use technology solutions among HP. We performed data abstraction, methodological assessment, and certainty of the evidence appraisal by at least two authors. Overall, we included 108 reviews involving physicians, pharmacists, and nurses were included. High-quality evidence suggested that infrastructure and technical barriers (Relative Frequency Occurrence [RFO] 6.4% [95% CI 2.9–14.1]), psychological and personal issues (RFO 5.3% [95% CI 2.2–12.7]), and concerns of increasing working hours or workload (RFO 3.9% [95% CI 1.5–10.1]) were common concerns reported by HPs. Likewise, high-quality evidence supports that training/educational programs, multisector incentives, and the perception of technology effectiveness facilitate the adoption of digital technologies by HPs (RFO 3.8% [95% CI 1.8–7.9]). Our findings showed that infrastructure and technical issues, psychological barriers, and workload-related concerns are relevant barriers to comprehensively and holistically adopting digital health technologies by HPs. Conversely, deploying training, evaluating HP’s perception of usefulness and willingness to use, and multi-stakeholders incentives are vital enablers to enhance the HP adoption of digital interventions. Subject terms: Health occupations, Public health INTRODUCTION Recent developments in health technology have positively affected multiple and essential sectors of the economy, especially the healthcare sector, by providing solutions that guarantee the exchange of medical knowledge and information and establish long-lasting health outcomes1,2. Digital health technologies, such as wearables devices, computerized decision support systems, and telemedicine improve the technical performance and satisfaction of healthcare employees, demonstrate potential to decrease direct and indirect costs of medical services, and enhance the quality of delivered care3. Worldwide, using digital solutions in practice seems inevitable, with modality-specific prevalence (e.g., 50.8% for telemedicine, 89.9% for electronic health records, and 91.9% for social media platforms)4–6. However, the prevalence of use might be even higher, as no previous study has collated and assessed the overall prevalence of using digital health technologies by healthcare providers. Likewise, several studies have suggested that ethnicity, race, geographic location, age, and medical specialty directly interfere in the adoption of technology use, evidencing the importance of understanding variables accounting for the digital divide and disparity of access7–9. Several barriers to healthcare’s overall quality, transparency, and efficiency naturally arise during or following the creation, implementation, and maintenance of digital health technologies. Therefore, during the design of any health-related project, it is essential to identify and quanti-qualitatively analyze its risks and facilitators, enhancing the likelihood of obtaining favorable outcomes and optimizing the chances of success. The efficient implementation of digital technologies, characterized by proper implementation of a systematic management approach, including strategic planning, resource allocation, and control and evaluation processes, is fundamental to refining healthcare services, equipment, and technologies10–12. In reaction to these aforementioned elements, multiple efforts have strengthened healthcare systems through employing DHTs for healthcare professionals and stakeholders from low-, middle-, and high-income countries. For instance, the World Health Organization (WHO) endorsed in the 73rd World Health Assembly the institution of the Global Strategy on Digital Health 2020–2025, in which four guiding principles rely on the acknowledgment that the institutionalization of digital health in a national system requires a decision and commitment by countries, recognition that successful digital technologies require an integrated strategy, promotion of the appropriate use of digital interventions for health, and recognition of the urgent need to address the major impediments faced by least-developed countries implementing digital health technologies13. Furthermore, the Regional Digital Health Action Plan for the WHO European Region 2023–2030 has a critical regional focus area on strengthening digital literacy skills and capacity-building in the general population, with particular attention to the health workforce, for the use of digital health services and disease prevention and management14. Due to these global actions, numerous studies have focused on assessing barriers to and facilitators for many technologies15–17. To date, hundreds of clinical trials based on specific technologies applied to the healthcare professionals’ environments have assessed the implementation of digital interventions in the healthcare system, while several systematic reviews have combined these publications, evidencing their effectiveness, safety, and feasibility. However, a summary of enablers and restraints to healthcare professionals’ coordinated and integrated use of digital health technologies has not been published yet, making the current evidence dispersed, misused, and overlooked. Therefore, in this overview of systematic reviews and semantic-based occurrence meta-analysis, we report all published evidence from existing systematic reviews covering and mentioning barriers and facilitators to the solid use of digital health technologies by healthcare providers. RESULTS Study selection and characteristics Our database and PROSPERO search are shown in Fig. 1. Our January 21, 2022 search retrieved 9,912 records, of which 139 underwent full-text review (Fig. 1, section A). Based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 47 studies and seven ongoing studies were included. On March 1, 2023, 2,717 new publications were identified through an additional database search (Fig. 1, section B). Of those, 142 studies were shortlisted for full-text assessment, and 60 reviews were added to our umbrella review. Two additional ongoing studies or protocols were identified. In total, this overview of systematic reviews included 108 primary systematic reviews and nine ongoing studies (Fig. 1, section C).18–125 One study was identified from alternative resources.64 Justification for the exclusion of 165 studies is presented in Supplementary Information 1 (pp 2–7). Included study characteristics are characterized in Table 1 and Table 2. One study is pending classification as it required translation. No additional data needed to be requested from the corresponding authors. [Figure: PRISMA flow chart diagram.Reason 1—wrong intervention or platform was unclear. Reason 2—the study did not provide any relevant outcome influencing healthcare providers. Reason 3—targeted population was not healthcare providers. Reason 4—study design used did not match our inclusion criteria.] [Table: Main characteristics of included studies evaluating the impact of digital health solutions on health workers (n = 108).] [Table: Population being evaluated, studies’ methodologies and technologies being evaluated.] Few studies (n = 20; 18.5%) initially targeted evaluating the creation, implementation, long-lasting use, and self-reported barriers and facilitators to using digital health technologies by healthcare professionals25,27,29,43,45,51,66,68,70,72–74,82,86,93,96,98,101,107,120. Thus, the remaining reviews were cautiously evaluated in order to identify a report of any barrier or facilitator to using digital health technologies by healthcare workers. Included reviews were heterogeneous in terms of the digital health technologies being assessed (e.g., alert systems, clinical reminders applications, computerized clinical decision support systems, electronic documentation systems, mobile health applications, social media platforms, and telemedicine tools) and enrolling different healthcare professionals (e.g., general practitioners and specialists, nurses, pharmacists, community healthcare workers) at several levels of care (primary, secondary, and tertiary health facilities). Most reviews (n = 63; 58.3%) were executed in North America, Europe (n = 61; 56.4%), and Asia (n =