Ancient gene linkages support ctenophores as sister to other animals.
Schultz DT, Haddock SHD, Bredeson JV, Green RE, Simakov O, Rokhsar DS. · 2023
Read Ancient gene linkages support ctenophores as sister to other animals. by Schultz DT, Haddock SHD, Bredeson JV, Green RE, Simakov O, Rokhsar DS. (2023) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc10232365.txt.
Introduction
Schultz and co-authors report that ancient gene linkages support comb jellies as the sister group to all other animals, in a 2023 study. Which came first, sponges or comb jellies, is a deep puzzle in animal evolution. The answer changes how scientists think the first nervous systems and muscles arose.
The team compared the arrangement of genes on chromosomes across animals. Those arrangements change very slowly, so they hold ancient signals. The patterns point to comb jellies as the earliest branch. The study offers a fresh line of evidence in a long debate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Schultz DT, Haddock SHD, Bredeson JV, Green RE, Simakov O, Rokhsar DS. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2023 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ancient gene linkages support ctenophores as sister to other animals By Darrin T. Schultz, Steven H. D. Haddock, Jessen V. Bredeson, Richard E. Green, Oleg Simakov, Daniel S. Rokhsar Published in: Nature DOI: 10.1038/s41586-023-05936-6 ABSTRACT A central question in evolutionary biology is whether sponges or ctenophores (comb jellies) are the sister group to all other animals. These alternative phylogenetic hypotheses imply different scenarios for the evolution of complex neural systems and other animal-specific traits1–6. Conventional phylogenetic approaches based on morphological characters and increasingly extensive gene sequence collections have not been able to definitively answer this question7–11. Here we develop chromosome-scale gene linkage, also known as synteny, as a phylogenetic character for resolving this question12. We report new chromosome-scale genomes for a ctenophore and two marine sponges, and for three unicellular relatives of animals (a choanoflagellate, a filasterean amoeba and an ichthyosporean) that serve as outgroups for phylogenetic analysis. We find ancient syntenies that are conserved between animals and their close unicellular relatives. Ctenophores and unicellular eukaryotes share ancestral metazoan patterns, whereas sponges, bilaterians, and cnidarians share derived chromosomal rearrangements. Conserved syntenic characters unite sponges with bilaterians, cnidarians, and placozoans in a monophyletic clade to the exclusion of ctenophores, placing ctenophores as the sister group to all other animals. The patterns of synteny shared by sponges, bilaterians, and cnidarians are the result of rare and irreversible chromosome fusion-and-mixing events that provide robust and unambiguous phylogenetic support for the ctenophore-sister hypothesis. These findings provide a new framework for resolving deep, recalcitrant phylogenetic problems and have implications for our understanding of animal evolution. MAIN Five major lineages arose early in animal evolution and survive to the present day: sponges (poriferans), ctenophores (comb jellies), placozoans (microscopic flat animals), cnidarians (such as anemones, jellyfishes and hydra) and bilaterians (such as chordates, molluscs, arthropods and diverse worms)1,8,10,13,14. Although morphological and phylogenomic studies consistently unite bilaterians, cnidarians, and placozoans into a monophyletic clade (Parahoxozoa) that excludes sponges and ctenophores8,10,14 the relationship between sponges, ctenophores and Parahoxozoa remains controversial. There are two competing scenarios—the sponge-sister hypothesis7,8 and the ctenophore-sister hypothesis9,10—reflecting which lineage diverged first among animals (Fig. 1a).Fig. 1Conserved synteny and the phylogenetic position of ctenophores and sponges.a, Two alternative metazoan phylogenetic hypotheses, with either ctenophores (left) or sponges (right) as sister to all other animals. b,c, Specimens of species of which the genomes are reported here. Scale bars, 1 cm. b, The lobate ctenophore B. microptera from the Monterey Bay, California. c, Undescribed cladorhizid demosponge collected offshore of Big Sur, California at a depth of 3,975 m. d, Ribbon diagram showing conserved syntenies among animals (α ≤ 0.05, permutation test one-sided false-discovery rate), including (from top to bottom) two ctenophores (B. microptera (BMI) and H. californensis); the jellyfish R. esculentum; the bilaterian amphioxus B. floridae; and two demosponges (E. muelleri and the cladorhizid demosponge). Each horizontal black bar represents a chromosome. The vertical lines between species represent orthologous genes, coloured according to the BCnS synteny groups12. Only groups of genes that have significantly conserved chromosome-scale linkage (synteny) between metazoan species are shown. There is extensive 1:1 conserved chromosomal synteny between the two ctenophores, consistent with the conserved ctenophore karyotype. Orthologous gene pairs in the two ctenophores that do not participate in conserved syntenies with BCnS are shown in grey. Photography credits: Shannon Johnson © 2019 MBARI (b), © 2021 MBARI (c). As sponges and ctenophores are such disparate animals13, the nature of the first diverging animal lineage has implications for the evolution of fundamental animal characteristics. Adult sponges are generally sessile filter-feeding organisms with body plans organized into reticulated water-filtration channels, structures built out of silica or calcium carbonate, and specialized cell types and tissues used for feeding, reproduction and self-defence, but they lack neuronal and muscle cells15. By contrast, ctenophores are gelatinous marine predators that move using eight longitudinal ‘comb rows’ of ciliary bundles16,17; they are superficially similar but unrelated to cnidarian medusae13,18 and possess multiple nerve nets19. Thus, whereas the sponge-sister scenario suggests a single origin of neurons on the ctenophore–parahoxozoan stem, the ctenophore-sister scenario implies either that either ancestral metazoan neurons were lost in the sponge lineage, or that there was convergent evolution of neurons in the ctenophore and parahoxozoan lineages3,6. Similar considerations apply to other metazoan cell types18, gene regulatory networks, animal development13,18 and other uniquely metazoan features. Despite its importance for understanding animal evolution, the relative branching order of sponges, ctenophores and other animals has proven to be difficult to resolve2. The fossil record is largely silent on this issue as verified Precambrian sponge fossils are extremely rare20 and putative fossils of the soft-bodied ctenophores are difficult to interpret21. Morphological characters of living groups (for example, choanocytes of sponges) are not sufficient to resolve the question because true homology is difficult to assign, and such characters are easily lost or can arise convergently13,22. The ctenophore-sister hypothesis is supported by a pair of gene duplications shared by sponges, bilaterians, placozoans and cnidarians but not ctenophores23. Although sophisticated methods for sequence-based phylogenomics have been developed and applied to increasingly large molecular datasets, there is still considerable debate about the relative position of sponges and ctenophores as results are sensitive to how sequence evolution is modelled11, which taxa or sites are included24,25, and the effects of long-branch artifacts and nucleotide compositional variation26. New approaches are needed. We reasoned that patterns of synteny, classically defined as chromosomal gene linkage without regard to gene order27, could provide a powerful tool for resolving the ctenophore-sister versus sponge-sister debate. Chromosomal patterns of gene linkage evolve slowly in many lineages12,28–30, probably because it is improbable for interchromosomal translocations to be fixed in populations with large effective population sizes28,31,32. Notably, some changes in synteny are effectively irreversible. For example, when two distinct ancestral synteny groups are combined onto a single chromosome by translocation, and subsequent intrachromosomal rearrangements mix these two groups of genes, it is very unlikely that the ancestral separated pattern will be restored by further rearrangement and fission, in the same sense that spontaneous reduction in entropy is improbable12. Such rare and irreversible changes are particularly useful for resolving challenging phylogenetic questions as they give rise to shared derived features that unambiguously unite all descendant lineages33–35. Deeply conserved syntenies observed between animals and their closest unicellular relatives12 suggest that outgroup comparisons could be used to infer ancestral metazoan states and polarize changes within animals to address the sponge-sister versus ctenophore-sister debate. Yet, chromosome-scale genome sequences of the unicellular or colonial eukaryotic outgroups closest to animals (choanoflagellates, filastereans and ichthyosporeans) have not been reported. Here we show that conserved syntenies between animals and their closest unicellular relatives support ctenophores as the sister group to all other animals. Specifically, we find seven sets of genes for which (1) ctenophores share ancestral metazoan gene linkages with one or more unicellular eukaryotes; and (2) bilaterians, cnidarians, placozoans and sponges are united (to the exclusion of ctenophores) by shared derived patterns of synteny that arose by ancient interchromosomal translocations. In four of these cases, irreversible mixing after chromosome fusion evidently occurred on the bilaterian–cnidarian–sponge (BCnS) stem lineage, providing unambiguous support for the ctenophore-sister scenario. The alternative sponge-sister hypothesis is not supported by any synteny-based characters, and would require reversal of four sets of fusion-with-mixing