Report on Lightning Simulation Standards and Facilities
Robinett, Logan Nicholas · 2026
Read Report on Lightning Simulation Standards and Facilities by Robinett, Logan Nicholas (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/doe-osti-3364733-report-on-lightning-simulation-standards.txt.
Introduction
Sandia National Laboratories report SAND2026-21189R, by Logan Robinett, surveys how lightning is simulated in laboratories and what standards govern the testing. Real lightning cannot be scheduled, so aircraft and explosives are certified against reproduced strikes instead. Sandia's own Lightning Simulator recreates a severe flash waveform, but its age brings operating difficulties and inconsistent output worth comparing against other facilities.
The report reviews lightning models, including an end-to-end modeling approach that connects strike physics across scales, then walks through testing standards and the methods peer facilities use. Comparisons aim to show where Sandia's simulator can improve and where its design quietly excels. The document was prepared as a course-linked study, ECE 551, and reads as a structured literature and facilities review.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Robinett, Logan Nicholas |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | DOE OSTI |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
SAND2026-21189R Report on Lightning Simulation Standards and Facilities Logan Robinett ECE 551 Sandia National Laboratories is a multimission laboratory managed and operated by National Technology & Engineering Solutions of Sandia, LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Honeywell International, Inc., for the U.S. Department of Energy’s National Nuclear Security Administration under contract DE-NA0003525. This page is intentionally left blank. I. Introduction Lightning strikes pose a significant threat to various forms of infrastructure and electrical equipment. Aircraft and high explosives are of particular interest due to the massive ramifications of the device being compromised due to exposure to lightning damage. However, due to lightning being a varying weather phenomenon, testing a device’s vulnerability to lightning is generally not as simple as simply exposing it to real world lightning. To consistently test a device’s ability to survive the worst-case scenario of lightning exposure, the effects of the most severe lightning strikes must be able to be reproduced consistently and measurably. One such facility for this purpose is the Sandia Lightning Simulator (SLS), which is designed to simulate the current waveform of a severe lightning flash. However, the SLS’s design and age lead to difficulties in its operation and inconsistencies in its output. The methodology used in other lightning simulation facilities may offer information on how to improve the SLS’s operation, or at the very least, expose the SLS’s hidden strengths. This report explores lightning simulation, lightning testing standards, and lightning simulation facilities. II. Lightning Models The study of lightning is incredibly broad and spans a great number of fields. As described in [1], there are a great number of models for different components of lightning with such variety in scale that using them holistically is quite difficult. The paper proposes an “End-to-End Lightning” (E2EL) model which comprehensively connects many of these models through four major components: weather, lightning, signals, and sensors. The weather model focuses on modeling electrification within clouds and has several mature existing models which could be effectively integrated into the holistic model. However, links between these models and physics-based models describing lightning initiation and discharge have not been built. This link is key, as in the lightning model, data from the cloud component is taken as an input to be used to describe the physical structure and current discharge of a lightning flash. The lightning model is the component most in need of development, as due to its complex nature, it has been mostly modeled in a modular approach, with individual simulation methods of various phenomena failing to be utilized together to create an accurate output waveform. The correctness of the currents from the lightning model is paramount to success for the signal model, as it generates RF and optical signals from the currents of the lightning model. This stage’s outputs will be compared to observational data to verify the quality of the whole holistic model up to this point. Finally, the sensor model receives the data from the signal model to be collected by modeled sensors for further validation. Despite the lack of a holistic model, lightning poses a great threat to electronic devices and infrastructure, and has been measured, studied, and protected against using empirical methods for centuries. From these empirical methods, the general behavior of a lightning strike has been able to be effectively approximated for testing and standards. As described in [2], a lightning strike is a transient, high current discharge which can occur over kilometers. The total discharge of a lightning strike, called a “flash,” involves several “return strokes,” where charge is transferred via high current pulses which occur fast enough to create a flickering effect when observed by the human eye. Between these strokes is a lower amplitude continuing current, where a smaller amount of charge is transferred but the electrical connection to the cloud remains. Charge can be transferred either via a cloud-to-ground flash or a cloud flash, which can happen either within the cloud itself (intracloud), to other clouds (cloud-to-cloud), or to the air (cloud-to- air). In the case of cloud-to-ground, the lightning flash is broken up between negative lightning and positive lightning [2]. A storm cloud can be modeled as an electric dipole, where typically positive charge accumulates on the top of the cloud while negative charge accumulates on the bottom. The cloud and earth then behave akin to a parallel plate capacitor, where the relative negative charge on the bottom of the cloud is attracted to the relative positive charge of the earth. In the case of negative lightning, as of that shown in Figure 1, breakdown occurs from the negatively charged bottom of the cloud down to earth. In positive lightning, the ground accumulates a relatively negative charge, causing breakdown to occur from the top of the cloud. Positive lightning makes up a significantly smaller percentage of cloud-to-ground lightning strikes and tends to be much more severe in their amplitude. In addition, they’ve been observed to have fewer return strokes, with the vast majority being a single stroke [3]. Figure 1, video still of negative cloud-to-ground lighting [4]. III. Lightning Standards Some of the most prominent lightning standards used for aerospace qualifications include the RTCA DO-160 [5], the SAE ARP standards [6, 7], and the Department of Defense military standards, MIL-STD-461 and MIL-STD-464 [8, 9]. Across these standards, very similar waveforms are characterized and utilized for specific lightning threats, and the MIL-STD reports contain idealized waveforms directly derived from SAE standards. The waveforms in [7] are broken up into voltage waveforms and current waveforms. The voltage waveforms are primarily used to simulate the effects of lightning either puncturing through or flashing over dielectric shielding. Two main voltage waveforms are established for this purpose, with Voltage Waveform A having a linear ramp of 1000kV/µs (± 50%) until breakdown, and Voltage Waveform D having a double exponential waveform which breaks down on the falling edge. Voltage Waveform B is designed for tests where the field does not quite reach breakdown and Voltage Waveform C follows a similar trend to Voltage Waveform A, but specifically breaks down at 1.2 µs. According to [2], Voltage Waveform A has historically been used for punch-through and flashover testing of full-scale hardware, while Voltage Waveforms C and D have been used for attachment point testing, and Voltage Waveform B has been used for fuel ignition tests. Current waveforms are described in [7] for multiple stroke and multiple burst testing, but the most relevant waveform is the multi-component current waveform, which is used to test the damage caused by a severe lightning flash. The waveform consists of four components: Component A consists of an initial return stroke, with a fast rise time to a peak current of approximately 200 kA which then decays exponentially. Component B describes the extended exponential decay of Component A which eventually becomes a constant current in Component C, which lasts for hundreds of milliseconds. Finally, component D describes a second return stroke with a similar rise time to Component A, but with a much lower peak current of approximately 100 kA. Components A and D can also be used for indirect effects, such as to test effects from induced magnetic fields from a nearby lightning strike. It's important to note that the