Experimental Report: Multi-Instrument Comparison of AAF Condensation Particle Counters

Mei, Fan, Pekour, Mikhail S. · 2026

Read Experimental Report: Multi-Instrument Comparison of AAF Condensation Particle Counters by Mei, Fan, Pekour, Mikhail S. (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/doe-osti-3364048-experimental-report-multi-instrument-com.txt.

Introduction

Pacific Northwest National Laboratory report DOE/SC-ARM-TR-336, by F. Mei and M. S. Pekour and dated May 2026, compares condensation particle counters flown by the ARM Aerial Facility. These instruments count tiny airborne particles by growing them with vapor until they are big enough to detect. The test lined up several counter designs side by side against shared reference instruments, including an aerosol electrometer.

Against the electrometer, the counters read low, with slopes from 0.736 to 0.860 at 100-nanometer particle size. The team traced the gap to multiply charged particles inflating the electrometer's reading. A leave-one-out method, judging each counter against the average of the other seven, gave a cleaner reference. The results tell aircraft instrument operators how much each counter type can be trusted in flight data.

Catalog record

CREATORMei, Fan, Pekour, Mikhail S.
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEDOE OSTI

Source: https://www.osti.gov/biblio/3364048

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

DOE/SC-ARM-TR-336 Experimental Report: Multi-Instrument Comparison of AAF Condensation Particle Counters F Mei MS Pekour May 2026 This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by the U.S. Government. Neither the United States nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the U.S. Government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the U.S. Government or any agency thereof. DOE/SC-ARM-TR-336 Experimental Report: Multi-Instrument Comparison of AAF Condensation Particle Counters F Mei MS Pekour Both at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory May 2026 How to cite this document: Mei, F, and MS Pekour. 2026. Experimental Report: Multi-Instrument Comparison of AAF Condensation Particle Counters. U.S. Department of Energy, Atmospheric Radiation Measurement User Facility, Richland, Washington. DOE/SC-ARM-TR-336. Work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Biological and Environmental Research Acronyms and Abbreviations AAF ARM Aerial Facility AE aerosol electrometer aMCPC advanced mixing condensation particle counter ARM Atmospheric Radiation Measurement CNC condensation nucleus counter CPC condensation particle counter DMA differential mobility analyzer FCE Faraday cup electrometer LOO leave-one-out MAE mean absolute error MBE mean bias error MCPC mixing condensation particle counter RMSE root-mean-square error SMPS scanning mobility particle sizer UCPC ultrafine condensation particle counter iii Contents Acronyms and Abbreviations .............................................................................................................iii 1.0 Introduction................................................................................................................................1 2.0 Instrument Description ................................................................................................................1 3.0 Experimental Setup .....................................................................................................................2 3.1 Aerosol Generation and Conditioning .................................................................................. 4 3.2 Reference Measurements .................................................................................................... 4 4.0 Data Analysis and Results ...........................................................................................................4 4.1 Overall Comparison of CPCs Against the Aerosol Electrometer ............................................ 6 4.2 Leave-One-Out Averaged CPC Comparison for the Same Size Particles ................................ 7 4.3 Leave-One-Out Averaged CPC Comparison for the Different Size Particles........................... 9 5.0 Summary..................................................................................................................................10 6.0 CPC Operation under Lower Pressures.......................................................................................11 6.1 Butanol-Based CPC Performance ...................................................................................... 11 6.2 Water-Based CPC Performance......................................................................................... 13 7.0 Recommendations for Future Deployments ................................................................................14 8.0 References................................................................................................................................15 Figures 1 Experimental setup for CPC comparisons.......................................................................................3 2 Illustration of the CPC comparison setup........................................................................................3 3 The total number concentrations measured by all nine CPCs versus the aerosol electrometer- inferred concentrations for the same-size, monodisperse aerosol tests...............................................5 4 Time series plot of all CPCs and AE tested on March 10, 2026........................................................6 5 The total number concentrations measured by eight CPCs versus the aerosol electrometer- inferred concentrations for the same-size, monodisperse aerosol tests...............................................7 6 Leave-one-out averaged CPC comparison for the aerosol particles with the same size.......................8 7 Leave-one-out averaged CPC comparison for the aerosol particles with different sizes......................9 8 Figure 3 from Bauer’s paper: Counting efficiency curves (a: Grimm 5410 CEN and b: TSI 3772 CEN) as a function of the mobility diameter.. ...............................................................................12 iv Tables 1 Summary of CPC specifications.....................................................................................................2 2 Linear regression results—All CPCs versus aerosol electrometer.....................................................4 3 Statistical performance metrics of various CPCs referenced to the aerosol electrometer.....................6 4 Side-by-side comparison of LOO regression parameters—same size versus different sizes..............10 5 Table 2 from Bauer’s paper: Results of the fits from Figures 2 and 3 for the different CPC models and pressure stages..........................................................................................................12 6 Approximate plateau efficiency of TSI 3789 (7 nm mode) versus pressure with near‑optimized conditioner temperature (same initiator and moderator temperatures, 59°C, 10 °C)..........................14 v 1.0 Introduction Condensation particle counters (CPCs), also known as condensation nucleus counters (CNCs) are sophisticated instruments designed to measure the concentration of aerosol particles in the atmosphere. These devices are pivotal in environmental monitoring, industrial applications, and scientific research, particularly in atmospheric studies. CPCs are vital for understanding the role of aerosols in climate systems. Aerosols influence cloud formation, radiative forcing, and atmospheric chemistry. By providing accurate measurements of particle concentrations and distributions, CPCs contribute to models that predict atmospheric impact and weather patterns (Mei et al. 2021). CPCs operate by enlarging submicron particles, including those as small as a few nanometers, to sizes detectable by optical methods. This report delves into the mechanisms, importance, and contributions of CPCs to atmospheric research at the U.S. Department of Energy Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) Aerial Facility (AAF), highlighting their role in advancing air quality assessment, pollution control, and atmospheric studies. 2.0 Instrument Description CPCs work by exposing aerosol particles to a supersaturated vapor, typically water or alcohol-based. The particles act as nucleation centers, leading to the condensation of the vapor into droplets. These droplets grow to approximately 10 µm in diameter, making them large enough to be detected and counted using optical scattering techniques (Chen and Pui 1995, Stolzenburg and McMurry 1991). The supersaturation process is diffusion-limited, ensuring uniform droplet sizes regardless of the original particle composition or dispersity. This characteristic allows CPCs to measure total particle concentrations without classifying them into size bins, making them ideal for applications requiring high sensitivity and broad detection ranges (Mei et al. 2021). Modern CPCs can detect particles as small as sub-3 nm and as large as 3 µm, with concentration measurements reaching up to 100,000 particles per cubic centimeter. They provide real-time readings with temporal resolutions as fine as in sub-second, enabling precise monitoring of dynamic aerosol environments (Kerminen et al. 2018). The instruments included in this comparison study represent a range of designs, working fluids, and detection capabilities from three manufacturers. A total of nine CPCs were evaluated: three TSI CPC 3772, two TSI CPC 3789, one TSI CPC 3025, two Magic CPCs from Aerosol Dynamics Inc., and one Brechtel advanced Mixing CPC (aMCPC).(Bian et al. 2020, Hering et al. 2019, Kangasluoma and Attoui 2019, Kangasluoma et al. 2017, Mei et al. 2021) The TSI CPC 3772 is a general-purpose, butanol-based CPC with a 50% counting efficiency (D50) cut size of approximately 10 nm. It is a robust and widely deployed instrument suitable for routine ambient aerosol monitoring. The TSI CPC 3789, also known as the versatile water-based CPC, replaces butanol with water as its working fluid and features a tunable D50 cut size ranging from approximately 2 nm to 7 nm, offering flexibility across a range of measurement applications. The TSI CPC 3025 is a well-established ultrafine CPC (UCPC) with a D50 of approximately 3 nm, making it one of the most sensitive instruments for detecting freshly nucleated particles; it has long served as a reference standard in intercomparison studies. The Magic CPC, developed by Aerosol Dynamics Inc., employs a water-based, three-stage growth tube design (moderator, initiator, and growth region) that activates particles under gentle supersaturation 1 conditions, avoiding the need for butanol. The Brechtel MCPC uses a mixing-type condensation approach, combining warm saturated and cool unsaturated airflows to generate supersaturation. Its compact, lightweight design and tolerance to varying pressures make it particularly well-suited for aircraft deployments and operations at different altitudes. The key specifications of each instrument are summarized in Table 1. Table 1. Summary of CPC specifications. Feature TSI CPC TSI CPC 3789 TSI CPC 3025 Magic CPC Brechtel MCPC 3772 (Aerosol Dynamics) Working Fluid Butanol Water Butanol Water Butanol D50 Cut Size ~10 nm ~2–7 nm ~3 nm ~5 nm (varies

Read the complete text