Product Defect Detection System: SYSM- 5620 Final Project

Estrada, Emily · 2026

Read Product Defect Detection System: SYSM- 5620 Final Project by Estrada, Emily (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/doe-osti-3363541-product-defect-detection-system-sysm-562.txt.

Introduction

Emily Estrada, an electrical engineer at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, presents this April 2026 final project for the SYSM-5620 course (LLNL-TR-2018842): a system to catch defective products on retail shelves. Retail returns were estimated at $850 billion last year, and stores must keep damaged or unsafe goods from reaching buyers.

Estrada develops three design concepts and compares them. Staff could tag suspect items for inspection, a sensor suite could watch products directly, or smart shelves could monitor weight and radio tag presence section by section. The shelf concept logs odd weight changes, which can signal leaks or missing parts, and alerts an employee to inspect the tagged item.

Catalog record

CREATOREstrada, Emily
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEDOE OSTI

Source: https://www.osti.gov/biblio/3363541

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

LLNL-TR-2018842 SYSM- 5620 Final Project E Estrada May 2026 This document was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States government. Neither the United States government nor Lawrence Livermore National Security, LLC, nor any of their employees makes any warranty, expressed or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States government or Lawrence Livermore National Security, LLC. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States government or Lawrence Livermore National Security, LLC, and shall not be used for advertising or product endorsement purposes. This work performed under the auspices of the U.S. Department of Energy by Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory under Contract DE-AC52-07NA27344. Product Defect Detection System SYSM - 5620 Final Project April, 08, 2026 Emily Estrada, Electrical Engineer Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory This work was performed under the auspices of the U.S. Department of Energy by Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory under Contract DE-AC52-07NA27344. IM NUMBER Table of Contents Introduction ........................................................................................................... 5 Job to Be Done ........................................................................................................5 Current Situation .................................................................................................... 5 Current Systems and Operations .............................................................................5 Deficiencies/Opportunities......................................................................................6 Stakeholder Analysis .............................................................................................. 7 Stakeholder Identification and Analysis ....................................................................7 Active Stakeholders .....................................................................................7 Passive Stakeholders ...................................................................................8 Stakeholder Interview ..................................................................................8 Stakeholder Requirements .................................................................................... 11 Acceptance Criteria...............................................................................................13 Concept for the Proposed System ...........................................................................13 Concept Generation .............................................................................................. 13 Desing Concept 1: Digital Image Processing System ................................... 13 Design Concept 2: Sensor Suite Tag ............................................................ 14 Design Concept 3: Smart Shelf Monitoring .................................................. 15 Concept Selection ................................................................................................ 15 System Context ..................................................................................................... 16 “To be” Operational Scenarios ............................................................................... 17 Scenario 1: Defective Item Detected and Removed from Shelf ..................... 18 Scenario 2: Store Manager Reviews Trends and Generates a Defect Report .. 18 Scenario 3: System Maintainer Updates Product Reference Data After Package Chang .......................................................................................... 19 Use Case Model .................................................................................................... 19 Use Case Specification ......................................................................................... 20 Use Case Specification 1: Identifies Product Defects in Store ...................... 20 SYSM – 5620 Final Project 2 Use Case Specification 2: Generates Product Defect Summaries ................ 21 Use Case Specification 3: Monitors System Health and Performance .......... 22 QFD Analysis ........................................................................................................ 23 System Requirements ........................................................................................... 25 Functional & Physical Architecture......................................................................... 26 Risk Assessment ................................................................................................... 28 Technical Risk Identification ....................................................................... 28 Technical Risk Mitigation ............................................................................ 30 Technical Performance Measures ............................................................... 31 Reflection ............................................................................................................. 32 References ...........................................................................................................33 Table of Tables Table 1: Active Stakeholders .........................................................................................................7 Table 2: Passive Stakeholders .......................................................................................................8 Table 3: Stakeholder Interviews ....................................................................................................9 Table 4: Desired System Characteristics and Capabilities from Stakeholders ............................... 10 Table 5: Stakeholder Requirements ............................................................................................. 12 Table 6: PUGH Matrix .................................................................................................................. 16 Table 7: System Requirements .................................................................................................... 26 Table 8: Technical Risks Pre Mitigation ........................................................................................ 28 Table 9: Technical Risks Post Mitigation ....................................................................................... 30 Table 10: Technical Performance Measures ................................................................................. 31 Table of Figures Figure 1: Retail Market Growth and Retail Return Statistics [1][2]....................................................5 Figure 2: Reason for Returns [4] ....................................................................................................6 Figure 3: Digital Image Processing System ................................................................................... 14 Figure 4: Concept 2 Sensor Suite [5] ........................................................................................... 14 Figure 5: Smart Shelf Monitoring [6] ............................................................................................ 15 Figure 6: Context Diagram .......................................................................................................... 17 Figure 7: Use Cases Diagram ...................................................................................................... 20 Figure 8: Interaction Diagram 1 ................................................................................................... 21 Figure 9: Interaction Diagram 2 ................................................................................................... 22 Figure 10: Interaction Diagram 3 ................................................................................................. 23 3 Figure 11: QFD ........................................................................................................................... 25 Figure 12: Functional Decomposition Diagram ............................................................................ 27 Figure 13: IDEF0 ......................................................................................................................... 28 Figure 14: Risk Assessment Before Mitigation .............................................................................. 29 Figure 15: Post Mitigation Risk Assessment ................................................................................. 31 SYSM – 5620 Final Project 4 Introduction Job to Be Done Retail sales is a growing market estimated to up to seven percent year over year. [1] With this growing market there is also a trend in growing rate of retail returns, estimated just last year at $850 billion. [2] Retail stores must ensure that products available for purchase remain safe, undamaged, and acceptable to customers throughout their time in the store. This job exists regardless of the specific solution used because stores are always responsible for preventing damaged or defective products from reaching customers and when they fail to this is categorized under operation inefficiencies which accounts for an estimated $12 billion in returns.[3] When defective items remain on the sales floor, stores may experience increased returns, reduced customer satisfaction, loss of customer trust, and potential safety concerns depending on the product type. As a result, the core job to be done is to identify defective products quickly, remove them from the sales floor before they are purchased, and preserve useful information about the defect so that the store can improve its handling, stocking, and supplier coordination over time. Figure 1: Retail Market Growth and Retail Return Statistics [1][2] The need for a more reliable process is especially important in high volume retail environments where employees manage large numbers of products across many aisles, shelves, and storage areas. In these settings, manual inspection alone can be inconsistent and difficult to sustain at the individual item level. At the same time, broader retail trends continue to emphasize operational efficiency, product visibility, and improved customer experience, creating an opportunity for more automated and data driven defect detection methods. Current Situation Current Systems and Operations In many retail environments, defective products are still identified primarily through manual observation by store employees, customer complaints, routine shelf checks, and product returns 5 are purchase. Employees may notice visible damage such as dents, leaks, broken packaging, etc. while stocking shelves or assisting customers, but this process depends heavily on time, attention, and consistency. Customers may also discover damaged products only after purchase resulting in returns or complaints that reveal the issue too late to prevent the original sale. [4] Figure 2: Reason for Returns [4] The current systems used in stores generally focus on inventory quantity, product movement, and transactions rather than item condition. For example, barcode systems, inventory management systems, Point of Sale (POS) software systems, are useful for tracking stock levels, product IDs, and purchases, but they do not typically evaluate whether an individual item has visible packaging damage or signs of product deterioration. General incident reporting tools may allow stores to document customer complaints or damaged goods, but these tools are often reactive and do not provide a continuous or systematic way to detect defects before purchase. As a result, current practice is more reactive than proactive and does not provide consistent traceability from the defective item back to a shipment, supplier, or handling process. Deficiencies/Opportunities The current approach creates several deficiencies in store operations. The first being that defect detection is inconsistent because it relies heavily on employee attention and customer reporting rather than continuous monitoring. This increases the chance that damaged items remain available for sale, especially in busy store environments with high product volume. The second noticeable deficiency is that existing store systems generally do not capture structured item condition data, making it difficult to analyze defect patterns, identify recurring handling issues, or trace problems back to specific lots, suppliers,

Read the complete text