Toroidal Alfven Wave Coupling (Nonlinear Wave-Wave Interactions) on DIII-D
Koepke, Mark · 2025
Read Toroidal Alfven Wave Coupling (Nonlinear Wave-Wave Interactions) on DIII-D by Koepke, Mark (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/doe-osti-3007751-toroidal-alfven-wave-coupling-nonlinear.txt.
Introduction
Close-out report by Mark Koepke of West Virginia University for a DOE grant on toroidal Alfven wave coupling in the DIII-D tokamak. The question was whether nonlinear wave-wave interactions set the saturation level of toroidal Alfven eigenmodes, plasma waves that can drain energy from fusion reactions.
Archival work in fiscal 2019 found evidence of nonlinear interactions in 175 relevant DIII-D shots, using Mirnov coil spectrograms and bispectral analysis. An improved bispectrum code, grown from a 1995 master's thesis tool, was also tested on the TJ-II stellarator and T-10 tokamak. The run plan drove one eigenmode against others and swept driver frequency to watch amplitudes respond. The same coupling physics appears in space plasmas and radiation belts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Koepke, Mark |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 17 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | DOE OSTI |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Close-Out Project Description for Koepke's Dept of Energy grant entitled Toroidal Alfven Wave Coupling (Nonlinear Wave-Wave Interactions) on DIII-D A. Overall goal, Scientific Rationale, and Fundamental question or problem being addressed 2020-2024: Overall goal Connect DIII-D physics with space plasma phenomena. In this case of using the toroidal Alfvén eigenmodes and frequency-chirping Reversed-Shear Alfvén eignmodes in DIII-D, we will document how the nonlinear interactions among dipolar Kinetic Alfvén Wave eigenmodes in space plasmas may determine saturation levels of these fluctuations. We seek evidence of nonlinear energy transfer and wave-wave coupling during 3-wave interactions mediated by a much lower-frequency mode. In FY2019, we found evidence of nonlinear “wave-wave” interactions in 175 relevant shots of archival DIII-D data. Toroidal mode number was identified and spectrograms were produced from each shot’s Mirnov- coil data. Bispectral analysis was performed using a preliminary version of a new user- friendly code derived from a 1995 M.S. thesis at WVU. These results formed a part of a May 2019 M.S. thesis at WVU. In FY2020, during the proposal preparation, we significantly improved the bispectrum code and used it to analyze fluctuations in TJ-II stellarator and T-10 tokamak. Dominant nonlinear interactions and operating parameters in DIII-D were next identified. The objective/motivation of this DIII-D proposed project is to quantify and explain how nonlinear wave-wave interactions influence or control Toroidal Alfvén Eigenmode (TAE) amplitude. A TAE spectrum will be self-driven and/or externally driven to the largest possible amplitude. Another mode (either a TAE or possibly a magnetic field perturbation) will be imposed and changes will be observed in mode frequency and relative mode amplitude. Scientific rationale: Plasma waves in the intermediate frequency range, between the ion and electron gyrofrequencies, are important to the dynamics of space plasmas and are vital to the evolution of the radiation belts, magnetic-field-reconnection processes, and particle- energy-transfer at the interfaces between boundary layers. Improved understanding of how nonlinear Alfven eigenmode interactions saturate mode amplitudes could lead to the development of a predictive capability for ion energization in the magnetosphere. Intellectual insights from in-depth experimental interpretation will motivate new expts, expanded conclusions, and the next generation of modeling nonlinear wave-wave coupling. Improved understanding of nonlinear Alfven eigenmode interactions and how they saturate mode amplitude could lead to the development of a predictive capability for ion energization in the magnetosphere. Intellectual insights from in-depth experimental interpretation will motivate new experiments, expanded conclusions, and the next generation of modeling nonlinear wave- wave coupling and wave-wave-wave coupling. Anticipated outcome: Improved understanding of how nonlinear Alfven eigenmode interactions saturate mode amplitudes could lead to the development of a predictive capability for ion energization in the magnetosphere. Intellectual insights from in-depth experimental interpretation will motivate new experiments, expanded conclusions, and the next generation of modeling nonlinear wave-wave coupling. Improved understanding of how nonlinear Alfven eigenmode interactions saturate mode amplitudes could lead to the development of a predictive capability for ion energization in the magnetosphere. Realized outcome: We articulated evidence of nonlinear energy transfer and wave-wave coupling during 3-wave interactions mediated by a much lower-frequency mode. In FY2019, we found evidence of nonlinear “wave-wave” interactions in 175 relevant shots of archival DIII-D data. Toroidal mode number was identified and spectrograms were produced from each shot’s Mirnov-coil data. Bispectral analysis was performed using a preliminary version of a new user-friendly code derived from a 1995 M.S. thesis at WVU. These results formed a part of a May 2019 M.S. thesis at WVU. Broader Impact: The involved a graduate student (S. Nogami) on previous DIII-D experiments (2017-19 inaugural Frontier Science Experiments). The PI was involved in delivering outreach to the public as Chair of the APS Distinguished Lecturer in Plasma Physics program and Member of the Fusion Outreach Team. He was one of ten departmental co-investigators of a 2020-awarded APS Inclusion, Diversity, and Equity Alliance (APS-IDEA) network application, which brought together representatives from about 30 physics departments to form a national leadership network to exchange ideas, explore effective practices, and develop strategic plans to support equity, diversity, and inclusion with physics. By leveraging existing initiatives of APS and other organizations, the goal was to transform the culture of physics to advance equity, promote diversity, and establish an inclusive profession. At the time of project-start, he was Chair of Omega Laser User Group, which advocates for student participation and professional development. The project involved one WVU grad student whose dissertation incorporated DIII-D data. B. Results achieved that were related to the question or problem being addressed: Analyzing archival data from DIII-D and upgrading the WVU bispectral analysis capabilities using electro-nic nonlinear oscillators, audio signals, Cluster spacecraft data, Texas Helimak data, TJ-II stellarator data, and T-10 tokamak data has resulted in new tools to interpret nonlinear wave-wave coupling. The first Figure illustrates DIII-D Shot 153593 as analyzed with the upgraded conventional bispectral analysis algorithm. The second Figure illustrates both the bicoherence magnitude and phase for DIII-D Shot 170803. The third Figure illustrates both the bicoherence magnitude and bispectrogram, i.e., the time- resolved bispectrum, for DIII-D Shot 170803. TAEFL, a reduced-dimensionality Landau-fluid-closure model for energetic particle driven instabilities (D. A. Spong, Long-term Landau-fluid simulation of Alfvén eigenmode Instabilities, Plasma and Fusion Research 9, 3403077, 2014) was applied to the DIII-D experiment case where several Alfvén instabilities are present. This type of model has several features that make it useful for the simulation of long-lived nonlinear states: (a) it is a continuum model so particle noise and associated error accumulation over time is not an issue, (b) it is computationally efficient so longer time interval modeling is feasible, and (c) a variety of source/sink models can be used and nonlinear coupling effects can be turned on and off to test different mechanisms. Fundamental question or problem being addressed: How do nonlinear wave-wave interactions control mode amplitude in curvilinear geometries (toroidal, dipolar)? How does nonlinear and linear energy transfer processes compete in such cases? Facility novelty of existing DIII-tokamak capabilities needed for success: The DIII-tokamak at General Atomics (San Diego, CA) is the nation's plasma confinement chamber having the largest size dimension, highest product of plasma density:plasma temperature:trapped-plasma duration. The facility has the most complete diagnostic portfolio for acquiring data and an extroordinary range of data acquisition resolution. Specific relevant area of plasma physics: Nonlinear interactions among Alfvenic modes arise in space and astrophysical plasma environments, such as the solar wind and Earth’s magnetosphere, as well as in fusion plasmas. In the solar wind, these nonlinear interactions mediate the turbulent cascade of energy from large to small scales. In the magnetosphere, it is proposed that kinetic Alfven eigenmodes energize ionospheric ion in geomagnetic storms. What sets amplitude of these eigenmodes? In fusion plasmas, Alfven eigenmodes have been observed to interact nonlinearly. Although saturated TAE amplitude may be controlled by scattering of energetic particles, nonlinear energy transfer is another potential saturation mechanism. Can we control TAE saturated amplitude in DIII-D by imposing additional modes that tap energy nonlinearly? Diagnostics used: ECE, Toroidal-mode magnetic pick-up, B-dot measurement in space and time, Interferometers, time-averaged spectra plus raw time series, time-resolved transport. Facility novelty of existing/new DIII-D capabilities needed for success: (Why DIII-D?): Significant controllability for driving TAEs. Thorough diagnosis of modes. Capability to enable a thorough study of nonlinear interactions in