Securing Flexible Demand [Slides]
Christensen, Dane · 2025
Read Securing Flexible Demand [Slides] by Christensen, Dane (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/doe-osti-2588022-securing-flexible-demand-slides.txt.
Introduction
Dane Christensen of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory presented these slides, dated December 2, 2024, on securing flexible demand. As the grid grows more distributed and intelligent, loads that can shift in time become a resource: flexible demand. The deck lays out the vocabulary first, from demand-side management and demand response to virtual power plants, which aggregate homes and devices into something a grid operator can dispatch.
Federal rules frame the opportunity, including FERC Order 841 on storage and Order 2222 on distributed energy aggregations in markets. A Texas case from August 20, 2024 shows why flexibility matters: locational prices in the Texas interconnect spiked toward 5,000 dollars per megawatt-hour. Smart thermostats are the mass-market wedge. Adoption already reaches 32 percent of United States homes, led by Nest at 18 percent, Honeywell at 9 percent, and Ecobee at 5 percent.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christensen, Dane |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | DOE OSTI |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Securing Flexible Demand
Dane Christensen, Ph.D.
December 2, 2024
Our Dynamic Grid
Image source: EIA Annual Energy Outlook 2023 and NREL ResStock, https://www.nrel.gov/buildings/end-use-load-profiles.html NREL | 2
The grid is evolving to become more distributed, intelligent,
At the Edge of Energy and complex. Coupled with aging infrastructure, the
vulnerabilities of emerging energy systems to disruption are
Transformation not yet well understood.
NREL | 3
Aggregation and Virtual Power Plants
Demand-Side Management (DSM): electric
utility activities designed to encourage
consumers to modify their level and pattern
of electricity usage.
Demand Response (DR): DSM programs
whereby utilities directly (or indirectly)
control grid edge resource(s).
Virtual Power Plant (VPP): An aggregation
of generation, storage, and/or demand
resources (often at the grid edge) managed
to achieve a supply-side purpose.
FERC Rule 841: “Electric Storage Participation
in Markets […]” Feb 28, 2018
FERC Rule 2222: “Participation of Distributed
Energy Resource Aggregations in Markets
[…]” Sep 17, 2020
Image adapted from: DOE “Pathways to Commercial Liftoff: Virtual Power Plants” September, 2023 NREL | 4
NREL | 5
NREL | 6
Aggregation and Virtual Power Plants - Texas
TX Interconnect August 20, 2024
Image source: GridStatus NREL | 7
Aggregation and Virtual Power Plants - Texas
TX Interconnect August 20, 2024
Locational Marginal Price
Spikes to Limit: ~$5,000/MWh
Image source: GridStatus NREL | 8
Aggregation and Virtual Power Plants - Texas
TX Interconnect August 20, 2024
Image adapted from: GridStatus, “Breaking Down a Record-Setting Day in ERCOT”, 2024 NREL | 9
Aggregation and Virtual Power Plants - California
Historical Event: Sept, 2022 CAISO September 5-8, 2024
- Record load above 52 GW
- Roughly 1 GW load shed provided via Nest,
ecobee, Tesla, SunRun, and others
- Automated call across CA resulted in additional
2-2.5 GW voluntary load reduction by citizens
Left image from weather.gov NREL | 10
Right image adapted from: GridStatus, “Breaking Down a Record-Setting Day in ERCOT”, 2024
Aggregation and Virtual Power Plants - California
CAISO September 5, 2024
Image adapted from: CAISO data plotted at Engaging Data https://engaging-data.com/california-electricity-generation/ NREL | 11
Aggregation and Virtual Power Plants - California
2022 Sept 5-8 2024 Sept 5-8
2024 Sept 5-8
Images adapted from: GridStatus, “Breaking Down a Record-Setting Day in ERCOT”, 2024 NREL | 12
Nationwide by 2030, VPP may meet 10-20% of peak load
Image source: DOE “Pathways to Commercial Liftoff: Virtual Power Plants” September, 2023 NREL | 13
Geography Matters
NREL | 14
Regions & Level of Grid
Utility
NREL | 15
Regions & Level of Grid
Utility
NREL | 16
Regions & Level of Grid
Utility
NREL | 17
Regions & Level of Grid
Utility
NREL | 18
Regions & Level of Grid
Utility
NREL | 19
Regions & Level of Grid
Utility
NREL | 20
VPP Market Participation Models
Image source: DOE “Pathways to Commercial Liftoff: Virtual Power Plants” September, 2023 NREL | 21
What’s “inside” control of a smart thermostat?
Authority “Supply Chain”
CA #1: Manufacturer
Algorithms
OEM Cloud Service Bulk
Bulk Internet Demand Response
Internet Coordinator Bulk Utility
Internet Control
API
Cloud Service Center
Provider 1
Cloud Service Provider 2
Bulk Bulk CA #3: DR Coord,
Internet Internet on behalf of the utility
5G Cell Service
Home Wi-Fi
Bulk
Internet Regional
Market/
Balancing
Cloud Service Provider 3 Authority
CA #4: VPP Operator
CA #2: Homeowner
Image sources: Nest, TechNexus, Netgear NREL | 22
Could This Matter?
Residential Air Conditioners in WECC
Area Maximum (MW) Controlled* the Contingency
System Wide 34,438 11,020 ~4× Scenario Used for
Western Grid Risk
Arizona 6,477 2,063 Analysis (2.7 GW)
Nevada 1,088 348
Adoption today: 32% of US Homes
SCE 5,088 1,628 Nest: 18%
Honeywell: 9%
Ecobee: 5%
LADWP 2,719 870 Other: 1%
PG & E 7,121 2,279
Colorado** 2,771 887
* Assumes uniform adoption of smart thermostats
** Combined WAPA Rocky & PSC
Image Source: nest.com
Market Data: Statista Consumer Insights 2024 NREL | 23
NREL’s Unique Tools
Highly granular open-
source modeling
for national, regional,
+ =
and local housing
stocks
Center map from: Methods for Analyzing the Benefits and Costs of Distributed Photovoltaic Generation -
https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy14osti/62447.pdf NREL | 24
Power System Impacts from Sudden Loss of Generator
Findings from Prior Work (2014): 2.7-GW supply perturbation,
coupled with 7 GW distributed generation, resulted in
power grid instability in Western Interconnect.
Chart from: Western Wind and Solar Integration Study Phase 3 (WWSIS3) – http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy15osti/62906.pdf
Light Spring RAC Load
Modeled
Online
Area Maximum
(MW)*
(MW)
New Mexico 0 680
Arizona 0 5,690
Nevada 0 1,390
California 0 11,340
Colorado 0 900
Total 0 23,260
RAC = Residential Air Conditioner
* Online = RAC operating in initial power flow case
Kenyon, et.al., “Bulk Electric Power System Risks from Coordinated Edge Devices”, IEEE Open Access Journal of Power & Energy, vol. 8, pp 35-44, 2021.
DOI: 10.1109/OAJPE.2021.3052433. https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy21osti/76059.pdf NREL | 26
Light Spring RAC Control
Modeled
Controllable Online
Maximum
Fraction (MW)
(MW)
10% 0 2,330
15% 0 3,490
20% 0 4,650
NREL | 27
Light Spring Step to Max
• 15% and 20% with ride
through yield lower nadirs
than Double Palo Verde Trip
• All distributed solar lost in
15% and 20% cases
• Simulations fail to converge
• Under-Frequency Load Shed
10% Controlled
15% Controlled (UFLS) limit violated in 20%
20% Controlled case
Kenyon, et.al., “Bulk Electric Power System Risks from Coordinated Edge Devices”, IEEE Open Access Journal of Power & Energy, vol. 8, pp 35-44, 2021.
DOI: 10.1109/OAJPE.2021.3052433. https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy21osti/76059.pdf NREL | 28
Heavy Summer Residential Air Conditioner Load
Area Online Modeled
(MW)* Maximum
(MW)
New 270 690
Mexico
Arizona 3,410 8,200
Nevada 1,390 1,900
California 5,370 14,050
Colorado 1,010 1,670
Total 13,080 30,150
* Online is operating RAC in initial power flow case
RAC = Residential Air Conditioner
NREL | 29
Heavy Summer RAC Control
Modeled
Controllable Online
Maximum
Fraction (MW)
(MW)
10% 1,310 3,020
15% 1,960 4,522
20% 2,620 6,030
NREL | 30
Heavy Summer Step to Off to Max
• Stepping the controlled
residential air
conditioners on with all
off yields deeper
frequency nadirs
• All distributed solar
(9.7 GW) trips in 20%
controlled case
10% Contr.
15% Contr.
20% Contr.
– System Separates