Cable from Lincoln Providing Views on Iden B's Reasoning re Communists Actions
Central Intelligence Agency · 1954
Read Cable from Lincoln Providing Views on Iden B's Reasoning re Communists Actions by Central Intelligence Agency (1954) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000135992.txt.
Introduction
The declassified CIA cable dated 1 February 1954 takes up views on the reasoning of IDEN B about communist actions, the heading breaking off at the end. Lincoln was the station cryptonym for PBSUCCESS, the CIA operation against President Arbenz in Guatemala that ended in June 1954. Read on its own terms, the record shows the operation at work in its own words, with some names still blacked out.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Central Intelligence Agency |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1954 |
| COLLECTION | DECLASSIFIED |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 5070 |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Internet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror |
Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000135992
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
owen BCTILW PRUGRAL
Sua = a aaa SANITIZED iM
fo CLASSIFIED MESSAGE
cate: «= 8:~*MARCH 5)y
To > DLtRECTOR
FROM: LINCOLN
ACTION: WH (1-2)
iro: pcr (3), D/DCH (h), DD/P (L)(5)
SSS
PRECEODERCE
TO: DIR CITE: SLINC
j PBSUCCESS RYBAT e
é
REF: (tn 2927)
IMMEDLATE ACTION
4. WETHOUT BENEFIT FACTS BEHIND IDEN BtS REASONING WHiCH LEO
TO DECIS{ON PARA 1, SEF MSG. LING FEELS OBLIGATED PRESENT {TS
AS
“ss
VIEWS FROM KNOWLEDGE OF SITUATION: {tF CORRECT, WOULD BE OF {i=
PORTANCE TO ODYOKE'S POSITION ViZ CURRENT COMMUNIST PROBLEM:
A. BELIEVE COMMUNISTS Wilt PROCEED TO EXPOSE ITS CASE
AGAINST {NTERVENTION WHETHER GDYOKE MAKES ANY FURTHER GHARGES OF
SOT. FALLURE TO RESPOND OR wARKE INETEAL ATTACK COULD BE TANTAMO NT
TO ACKNOWLEDGEMENT tN EYES OF WORLD AND RESULT IN DISCREDITING ANTI-
COMMUNIST CAMPAtSI HERETOFORE. MOTE £31S DATED 7 MARCH, REUTERS
TO SINGASORE, HELLSCHRE?GER FROM CARACAS.
B. FRGM PUBLIC VIEWPOINT ODYOKE HAS ALREADY SRANDED Woe
SBYUENT BNO COMMUNISTS HAVE INDICATED ISSUE WAS CRAYWN BEFORE OAS
CONVENED. THEREFORE FAILURE TO FOLLOM THROUGH WITH SUBS TANT FATT GN
REZUTES ODYOKE'S POSITION AN RENGTHENS COMMUN!ST CHARGES.
~~ {
1 o ‘| :
MSc ues Si EER ETRIGGH : :
IY 1S FORBIDDEN TO MAKE A CGPY OF THIS MESSAGE Ceny No.
TOP S$E& i
B MA CH Sk
LINC Yl (IN 25002)
PAGE ~2-
Co REF PLAN SIERELY MODIFIES BOGOTA RESOLUTION ANO
POSTPONES INEVITABLE SHOWDOWN. THES APPROACH COUPLED WITH A
CuULD BE CONSTRUED AS WIEAKNESS HIGH MOST CERTAINLY THE COKMe
MULLISTS WELL EXPLOIT FULLY.
D. PARA 3 REF “SG FIRST SENTENCE APPEARS OUT OF
CONTEXT YUTH NSO DECISION TO EMPLOY COVERT VEANS TO ACKIEVE
OBJECTIVE AND PRESUPPOSES THAT "PRESENTATION OF CASE” TO OAS
PREOCMINATES ISSUE. UNDERSTANDING LINC 1S THAT OAS YAS TO BE
PLATFORM FOR PRESENTING ODYOKE GASE AGAINST WSBURNT TO ENLIST
MORAL SUPPORT OTHER COUNTRIES AND PROVIDE JUSTIFICATECN COVERT
ACTION.
| E. GONCERN OVER FUTURE COMPROMISES OF COVERT ACTION
MULCH MIGHT PREJUDICE “OUR PRESENTATION APPEARS TO BE THE FRE=
SENT 1£SUE WHEREAS COMMUNISTS NOW POSSESS SUBSTANTIAL DATA,
WHETHER TRUE 08 NOT #S $RREVALENT TO COMMUNISTS. THIS HAS AND
WELL CONTINUE TO PREGUDICE OUR POSITION UNLESS FACED DOWN AS in
GEM SARFARE CASE WHICH ALTHOUGH “HOLLY FALSE HAO TO SE HET.
F. CONGERN COVER CURRENT COVERT OPERATIONS 1S NOT
CLEAR. $F BEANT FINAL ATTACK DATE THEN LESG COULD APPRECSATE CON
L REVOLUTIONARY OPERATIONS WERE PNTENDE
2
x]
x
my
SERIOUS QUESTIONS ARE RAISED. PSSUCCESS CURRENTLY EMPLOYING
MAME MUM SECURITY POSS?iBLE UNDES CIRCUMSTANCES BUT THERE With
ALSAYS RESAIN IMGERENT RISKS THICH LINC PRESUMED HAD SEEN CAL}
SULATED AND ACCEPTED AT BEGINGING AS FAR SACK AS NSC. VIEW
me ——
Topesecser -.
"eA
8 MARCH 5k
Lise Old, (th 25002)
PAGE -3-
KNOWN WSBUANT KNOWLEDGE OF PBFORTUNE AND SEEKFORD GASE ANO
POSSIBLY OF CURRENT OPERATIONS. WHETHER STOPPED GR “10T
"THE HORSE HAS BEEN STOLEN". THEREFORE LOCKING THE DOOR DOES
NOT RESOLVE THE PROBLEM. .
Go BELFEVE PERTINENT TO POINT OUT THAT UNLESS ALL
PRSUCCESS ACTIVITIES ARE COMPLETELY SUSPENDED IN NEXT 2 OR 3
MONTHS THE SITUATION WOULD UNCOUBLTEDLY BE IMMEASURABLY MOE
SERIOUS AS iT IMPOSSIBLE TO BE IN READINESS WITHOUT COMMUNISTS
HAVING GREATER AWARENESS CF REAL THREAT THAN AT PRESENT. THUS
MUST RECOGNIZE StGNtFiCANCE OF LATER OAS “SG.
He LINC FIRMLY BELIEVES ANY SUSPENSION CURRENT
OPLRATIONS WOULD SERIOUSLY IMPALE POSStBiLiTIES OF ULTERMATE
SUSCESS. FORGES HAVE BEEN SET IN MOTION, MORAL COVMETMENTS
HAVE GEEN MADE TO ATTAIN EARLIEST POSSIBLE DATE OF READINESS,
WHECH ALTHOUGH NOT I{RREVOCASGLE THUS FAR +S CLOSE TO SUCH STATUS.
ONGE ARMS REACH FOREWARD AREAS ANY ATTEMPT TO DELAY FOR DIPLOe=
MATIC REASONS MIGHT TELL RESULT EN UNILATERAL ACTION. ANY UN-
REASONABLE EXPLANATION IN EYES OF SYNCARP FOR DELAY i&iGHT ALSO
RESULT 1M PRECIPITATING UNFORTUNATE SSORTEVE ACTEON. LING
BeLIEVES TIME RUNNING OUT FAST FOR EFFECTIVE COVERT ACTIO..
Ze WITHOUT INTEHDING TO BE PRESUMPTIVE LINC SU_LGESTS
FOLLOWING COURSE OF ACTION AT OAS.
B MARCH Sk
LINC Old: CIN 25002)
PAGE -]-
A. IN ANTICIPATION THAT REF PLAN WILL PRECIPITATE
COMMUHEST DENTAL AND COUNTERATTACK, BELIEVE ODYOKE SHOULD PRE-
SENT RESOLUTION SUBSTANTIALLY AS STATEO (PARA 2 REF MSG.)
Bo FOLLOW ABQVE RESOLUTION WITH FACTUAL STATEMENTS
INDICATING EXISTENCE SUCH A THREAT IN WSBURNT: DRAWING
PARALLEL SHUMELAR STAGES OF DEVELOPMENT IN OTHER SATELLITE
COUNTRIES, DESCRIBING AS A CANCEROUS GROWTH IN WH FAMILY OF
NATIONS SHICH HUST BE RECOGNIZED AND DEALT WiTH EARLIEST.
Ge. PRESENT RESOLUTION CALLING FOR ESTABLISHMENT OF
A COMMISSION OF NUETRAL MEMBERS TO MEET 15 JUNE 5, TO STUDY THE
EATENT Gr TRE DANGER AND MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO OAS FOR POSSIBLE
COURSES CORRECTIVE ACTION.
A”
« ABCYE COURSE OF ACTION WOULD PROVIDE AN ANSWER TO THE
ISSUE. ALLOWING THE WORLD TO JUDGE AND PLACING COMMUNIST GHAR GES
IN FOSUS With ALL THE OTHER EtG LIES THEY HAVE PROPAGATED. THIS
SOULD BE A EID FOR MORAL SUPPURT MEANHILE PLACING GONFIOENCE
ffi PBSUCCESS, THE REVOLT WOULD BE STAGED PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION
OF THE COMMISSIONS WORK.
ENO OF MESSAGE _ -
=