El Salvador: Progress and Problems on Human Rights - TruthH Commission I)

Central Intelligence Agency · 1987

Read El Salvador: Progress and Problems on Human Rights - TruthH Commission I) by Central Intelligence Agency (1987) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000049244.txt.

Introduction

Progress and problems on human rights in El Salvador are weighed in a CIA paper from 1987, preserved in the Truth Commission file series. By then, American aid hung on regular judgments about whether the Salvadoran forces were abusing fewer people than before. The paper is one of those judgments, made mid-war.

Inside, gains are set against failures: units or practices that improved, and the killings and cover-ups that continued. The mixed verdict was the era's standard product, since a clean report would have been disbelieved and a wholly black one would have cut the aid. Read now, it shows the grading system under which the war was supplied.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1987
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE12086
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000049244

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

so ee Central intelliperee Aperi y ‘ . . ! Somer / Washingjon 2 C 20508 DIRECTORATE OF INTELLIGENCE 8 JUNE 1987 El Salvador: Progress and Problems on Human Rights ee Summary GREED toa tcates that El Salvador has made consider e progress in improving human rights since President Duarte was inaugurated in 1984. Official government links to rightwing death squads have ended, and political killings have decreased dramatically. Neve eless, same problems remain, including a corrupt and inefficient judiciary, continuing abuses by lower-ranking soldiers and police, and the failure to prosecute high-ranking of ws for human rights violations in the years prior to 1984. eres data indicates that most terrorism against civi 1 Salvador now is being carried out by the insurgents and that most guerrilla allegations of government abuses are unfounded. Lack of evidence to support insurgent claims--and the guerrillas' own tarnished human rights record-- will continue to hamper their efforts to undermine San Salvador's international credibility. There is little likelihood the government @ill make significant progress in reforming the judiciary or prosecuting former officers suspected of human rights violations during the remainder of the Duarte administration. This memorandum was prepared b African Latin Analysis. Approved for Release NOV 1993 angie t * * During the 1970s and early 1980s, government human rights violations were responsible for driving many moderates into the insurgency, and the guerrillas effectively used the issues of repression and abuse to undercut San Salvador's legitimacy. Since President Duarte came to power, the insurgents have tried to maintain the pressure through constant allegations--mostly unsubstantiated--of atrocities and abuses. These efforts are intended to mobilize international opinion against the war in El Salvador and--optimally--end US assistance to the government. Nevertheless, the querrillas have had declining success with the tactic because of the marked progress the Duarte administration has made in cleaning up its human rights record. Although the a: rebels now are guilty of most human rights abuses, ée Insurgents have deflected attention from their activities through the use of human rights front groups and sympathizers that deliberately distort and manipulate information. Guerrilla defectors from these fronts have publicly identified such groups as the Human Rights Committee for El Salvador (CDHES) and the Committee of Mothers of the Disappeared (Co-Madres) as staffed and advised by insurgents. A former member of Co-Madres has cited the head of the Salvadoran Archdiocese Office of Human Rights and Legal Aid (Tutela Legal)-- whose human rights statistics are widely cited by governments and international organizations such as Amnesty International and Americas Watch-- ing involved in channeling funds to the guerrillas. CEE indicates these groups fabricate stories of human rights abuses and attribute them to the government. For example, the guerrillas have falsely alleged indiscriminate bombing and aistreatment of the population when the government has mounted its military sweep operations in rural areas. Of 50 “death squad" killings alleged by Tutela Legal for the last half of 1985 only three were directly linked by to rightwing extremists. The remainder were e criminal murders (10), probable political murders by unknown assailants (18), or unverifiable incidents (19). In 1984, analysis of Tutela Legal's methodology determined it was using military reports of guerrillas killed and converting them to civilians killed by the Army--a practice that was temporarily halted after complaints, but had resumed by January 1986. The UN Special Rapporteur for E] Salvador reported in 1986 that Tutela Legal's methodology is based on presumptian,.not facts, and that it counts ah Civilians even when they often are guerrillas. qui. Government Record Improves ... AS part of its efforts to demonstrate concern on the issue of human rights, the government has. allowed humanitarian interest groups--including the International Red Cross, Amnesty International, and Americas Watch--freedom to operate inside the country. Even human rights groups with links to the insurgents are allowed to organize actively, issue statements, and mount antigovernment demonstrations. With the exception of the guerrilla fronts--which focus entirely on alleged government abuses and seldom comment on rebel atrocities--most human rights groups and the responsible press agree that the government has made progress in ending its abuses. Among President Duarte's first initiatives after assuming office in 1984 was a campaign to ensure appropriate behavior by security officials. Scars ia crane eis earavvererrrs eran eR Duarte ordered the elimination of all official government ties to the rightwing death squads and appointed trusted, reform-minded officers to head the security services. In addition, he moved to purge human rights violators and to indoctrinate police and military officers. that police units that were notorious for their tle Oo the extremists have been abolished and that strict rules for handling and interrogating prisoners have been imposed. figures indicate that political murders declined fram 5, in 1983 to 261 in 1986. Moreover, between June 1985 and May 1986, 1,806 police officers were dismissed for crimes or unethical behavior, and 201 were remanded to civilian courts for punishment. In an effort to prevent future violations, the security services late last year began a 26-week course during which every police employee received 48 hours of instruction on human rights from the Red Cross, the Catholic Church, and the government human rights commission. The government continues to seek measures that will further humanize the treatment of prisoners. that Duarte is seeking antiterrorist legislation Gislative Assembly to replace the lapsed state of emergency and Decree 50 that allow prisoners to be held and interrogated for 15 days before being charged with a crime. At present, the police-- operating under a transitional law--are required to charge or release prisoners after 72 hours. Despite some grumbling, the military and security services have agreed to abide by these civilian-imposed rules. On 7 May, the President submitted legislation that would provide amnesty for 600 of 800 prisoners held under Decree 50, excluding only guerrilfa combatants, foreigners, and those charged with terrorism. In addition, the proposed law would release all prisoners awaiting trial for crimes punishable by less than three years imprisonment. By almost any account, the reform measures have had their intended effect, The International Red Cross has told that the human rights situation under Duarte is much improved. It reports the police and the Army have taken steps to minimize the abuse of prisoners and that only 15 to 20 percent of prisoners interviewed voice complaints. In October 1986, the UN Special Rapporteur for Bl] Salvador reported a steady decline in politically motivated murders since 1984 and the absence of links between death squads and senior military officers. Canada restored bilateral aid to El Salvador as early as 1984 in recognition of the government's improving human rights record, and other critics of San Salvador, such as Australia, have admitted that Duarte's efforts have borne fruit. Finally, the government has continued to respect the rights of free Speech, press, association, and assembly despite the ongoing civil war. qa - . . But Some Problems Remain Despite the improvements, some ab the security services and armed forces continue. that some prisoners have been deprived of sleep, threatened, and forced to exercise during prolonged interrogation. Occasional allegations of rape, electric stieck, and beatings that leave no marks are made by some prisoners and human rights groups, but seldom can be verified. In addition, there are

Read the complete text