El Salvador: Performance on Certification Issues - TruthH Commission I)

Central Intelligence Agency · 1983

Read El Salvador: Performance on Certification Issues - TruthH Commission I) by Central Intelligence Agency (1983) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000049227.txt.

Introduction

El Salvador's performance on certification issues is graded in a CIA paper from 1983, preserved in the Truth Commission file series. Certification was the process by which the president certified to Congress that El Salvador was improving on human rights, so aid could flow. The paper measures the country's showing against that test.

Inside, the record is checked point by point: the tests Congress had set, and what San Salvador could honestly claim on each. Papers like this one sat at the joint between the war and its funding, where facts were gathered to support a signature. The paper shows the aid pipeline's paperwork at its most consequential.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1983
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22582
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000049227

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

on central batethisenss P ee EI Salvador: Performance on Certification Issues Interagency Intelligence Assessment Approved for Release NIC M 83-1001! Pe nee 43 July 1983 NOV 1993 Lg . NIC M 83-10011 EL SALVADOR: PERFORMANCE ON CERTIFICATION ISSUES , Information availsble as of 11 July 1983 was used in the preparation of this Assessment. een KEY JUDGMENTS The government of El Salvador has made continued progress an most certification issues during the past six months Progress in achiev- ing substantial control over the armed forces and prosecuting those responsible for the murders of six Americans has been marginal at best, however. As in previous assessments, our primary base of information continues to be eumpanabiengpebenannstlereiiiiSi eat annnaan |) | ch we judge as accurate and objective FB Improvement has been most evident in the area of government reforms. Agrarian reforms have made steady advances, particularly in the distribution of land and titles to thousands of new beneficiaries. Recent banking laws also have completed a process begun in 1980 to re- organize financial institutions and reallocate credit to the general public. Cooperation among moderate elements in the government has increased over the last six months, with an attendant erosion of extreme rightist influence. This has énabled the administration to step up the process of democratization, especially evident in the enactment of an amnesty law that has reduced the number of political prisoners by 70 percent. Other advances include the creation of a Peace Commission charged with seeking political reconciliation with the guerrillas and completing the draft of a new constitution Major weaknesses remain, however, in the government's ability to safeguard human rights, particularly in the countryside. Killings by rightwing death squads and elements of-the armed forces continue. Efforts by the military high command fo instil] respect for human rights among the rank and file have had somé effect in elite units, but little in poorly trained garrison units and civil defense forces. The cases involving the murder of the six US citizens have yet to reach trial stage because of continued legal and procedural bottlenecks in the weak criminal justice system. Conspirators in the killings of two Note: This Interagency Intelligence At&eliment, approved by the Nationa! Forsign Intelligence Board, was prepared under the suspices of the National Intelligence Officer for Latin America. The Asesrnent was prepared by the Central Intelligence Agency. the Defenss Intelligence Agency, the National Security Agency, end the intelligence organization of the Depertment af State. Also participating were the intelligence organizations of the Army, the Navy. the Air Foros, and the Marine Corvs GP 1 Us Jabor advisers, moreover, continue Co aveid proseculon following appellate court decisions to drop current charges until new evidence can he developed ee DISc us Human Rights “Making a concerted and significant effort to comply with internationally recognized human nghts.” (Criterion for judging Salvadoran Gov- ernment's performance. 1. During the past six months, the Magana adminis- tration in El Salvador has continued to make progress on some human rights issues, particularly as evident in the recent implementation of the amnesty law. As noted in previous assessments, however, the measure- ment of progress in El Salvador is a relative thing. complicated by abuses of prisoners before detention in & government facility and the use of violence by extremists against their perceived political opponents 2 The insurgent war has intensified this year as the guerrillas have stepped up efforts to broaden their areas of control and inflict major damage on the country's already crippled economy. The rate Of com- bat deaths on both sides has increased, but the rate of civilian political deaths ' has not changed substantially. figures for the firs six months of 1983 show e slight incresse over those for the last six months of 1988—178 civilian political deaths versus 160. The average so far this year, however, Is well below the monthly death rate of 217 for all of 1982 (See accompanying chart. 3. The trend toward improvement {s also reflected in the recently enacted and swiftly implemented amnesty law. Since it went into effect in May 1983, the authorities have released more than 500 of the 783 political prisoners in jail at the time amnesty went into effect—guerrillas and labor leaders as well as leftist intellectuals suspected of subversion and detained under the emergency decree. Most of those teleased ‘Political deaths are those that take place outside a song af combat and which clearly sugges « political motive—for exexiple, civilians murdered because of suspected complicity with the inewr- sents. Civilians killed as a result of being caught in « crossfire er other military-related activities are classified as combet doy »>STOMN had been held at the relatively modern Mariona Presson outside the capital 4 Qaim, visit the facility frequently the prisoners are well fed and are Teceiving excellent treatment, including access to schooling and rights to conjugal visits in private darmi- tones. In addition, who recently visited the Hopango Women's Prison indicate that more than half of its 92 political prisoners have been released under the amnesty. Conditions there are reported as good, and some of the common criminals stated they are denied privileges that are extended to political detaine 5. We believe the government may extend the amnesty beyond its mid-July cutoff in an effart to altract political exiles and disenchanted members of insurgent groups inside the country. Despite the mnex- EI Salvador: Insurgency-Related Civilian and Military Deaths, 1981-June 1983 Tout Number of Civilian Deaths Monihly Average Number of Military Killed of Wounded (98) su) exniitiaeen pectedly high number of polities) prisoners wha have benetited from tne law, at reportedly has altracted su far only about 200 guerrillas and camp followers Nevertheless, qa the government's [lu man Rights Commisson—which is currently invest gating reported cases of abuse of ciwilians by both guerrilla groups and armed férces units and attempt: ing to locate over 100 missing persons-—appears apli- mustic that others will take advantage of the law , WER wvecrrillas are required only to sign a formal request for amnesty, and that they are not interregal- ed or required to provide details of their past actions. Like the released political prisoners, insurgents secking amnesty are free to remain in the country or to leave. Meanwhile, the Amnesty Commission's recently estab- lished rehabilitation committee is assisting beneficia- ries in finding work or in resettling on land belonging Yo the agrarian reform agencies. Those desiring to leave El Salvador are offered free passports, and | discussions are under way with governments in Latin America, Canada, Australia, and Western Europe pver resettlement programs. ; 6. Despite these and other efforts—including massive publicity campeign—we believe that fear of reprisals from the extreme left or right will inhibit most guerrillas and political exiles from taking advan- tage of the amnesty. The government hopes that fair treatment of Insurgents turning themselves in will spark additional defections, but this may be offset by accounts of former political prisoners of abuses before their internmen b tly are continuing. Qi government and military o ility for sations employed by the Army In combat situations before prisoners are transferred to detention centers. The positive effects of the amnesty program could be further offset by recent death squad activity against some prisoners who

Read the complete text