BlankK) Country Commentary: Attitude of the Salvadoran Armed Forces on the Jes

Central Intelligence Agency · 1991

Read BlankK) Country Commentary: Attitude of the Salvadoran Armed Forces on the Jes by Central Intelligence Agency (1991) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000049209.txt.

Introduction

A country commentary from 1991 gauges the Salvadoran armed forces' attitude toward the Jesuit case, in a partly blacked-out CIA item. Country commentaries were the station's considered take, written for readers who set policy. This one measures an army's mood toward the case that was remaking its future, month by month.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1991
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE6147
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000049209

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

COUNTRY COMMENTARY: ATTITUDE OF THE
ED FORCES ON THE. JESUIT CASE

SUBJECT: COUNTRY COMMENTARY - ASSESSMENT OF SALVADORAN JOINT
GENERAL STAFF'S ATTITUDES TOWARD THE JESUIT MURDER
INVESTIGATION

1. IN A LETTER TO THE MINISTER OF JUSTICE DATED 22
FEBRUARY 1991, THE SALVADORAN ARMED FORCES JOINT GENERAL STAFF
(EMCFA) REQUESTED THAT THE MINISTRY OF JUSTICE AMPLIFY ITS
INVESTIGATION INTO THE MURDERS OF SIX JESUIT PRIESTS AND TWO
CIVILIANS ON 16 NOVEMBER 1989. IN THE LETTER, THE EMCFA

Approved for Release *
> Nov 1993

SUGGESTED THAT THE MINISTRY OF JUSTICE, THROUGH THE SPECIAL.
INVESTIGATIVE UNIT (SIU), INVESTIGATE A MEETING WHICH OCCURRED
AT THE MILITARY SCHOOL ON THE EVENING OF 15 NOVEMBER 1989, AND
ONCE AGAIN QUESTION THE ALLEGED PARTICIPANTS OF THIS MEETING.

2. CAN ONLY SPECULATE AS TO THE MOTIVE WHY, AFTER
ALMOST ONE AND A HALF YEARS, THE EMCFA, AND MINISTER OF DEFENSE
RENE EMILIO ((PONCE)) IN PARTICULAR, WOULD SUDDENLY SHOW
CONCERN FOR THE CONDUCT OF THE INVESTIGATION INTO THE JESUIT
MURDERS AND THE !5 NOVEMBER 1989 MEETING AT THE MILITARY
SCHOOL. SOME POSSIBLE MOTIVES INCLUDE:

A. PONCE WANTED TO INFLUENCE THE U.S. TO RELEASE THE
MILITARY AID FUNDS WHICH WERE TO BECOME AVAILABLE ONE WEEK
LATER.

B. THERE JS AN EFFORT BY THE EMCFA TO FURTHER CONFUSE
AND DELAY THE TRIAL BY INTRODUCING A NEW LINE OF
INVESTIGATION.

C. PONCE RECEIVED PRESSURE FROM PRESIDENT ALFREDO
(CCRISTIANI)) AND THE GOVERNMENT OF EL SALVADOR TO BE MORE
FORTHCOMING IN THE INVESTIGATION.

D. PONCE AND THE EMCFA ARE SINCERE IN THEIR DESIRE TO
RESOLVE THIS CASE AND ARE JUST BEING HELPFUL.

3. IT IS ENTIRELY POSSIBLE THAT PONCE DID, IN FACT, TIME
THIS ANNOUNCEMENT TO INFLUENCE THE U.S. CONGRESSIONAL DECISION
TO RELEASE MILITARY AID. PONCE IS WELL AWARE OF THE IMPORTANCE
THE U.S. GOVERNMENT PLACES ON A JUST SOLUTION TO THIS CASE. HE
IS ALSO ASTUTE ENOUGH TO UNDERSTAND THAT, SHOULD THIS
INVESTIGATION STALL OR PROVE TO BE A DEAD END, THE ESAF'S
REPUTATION WILL BE FURTHER SULLIED AND COULD EFFECTIVELY KILL
ANY CHANCES OF THE ESAF RECEIVING U.S. MILITARY AID IN THE
FUTURE. WHILE THE TIMING OF THE ANN EMENT MAY HAVE BEEN
INFLUENCED BY THE MILITARY AID VOTE, DOUBT IT WAS A PRIMARY
MOTIVATING FACTOR.

4. THE POSSIBILITY EXISTS THAT PONCE AND THE EMCFA ARE
ATTEMPTING TO FURTHER DELAY THE TRIAL BY INTRODUCING NEW
AVENUES OF INVESTIGATION. AN INTEGRAL PART OF THIS THEORY IS
INFORMATION THAT THE EMCFA MET WITH THE OFFICERS MENTIONED IN

TER AND BRIEFED THEM ON WHAT THEIR TESTIMONY WOULD BE.
me EVIDENCE TO INDICATE THAT PONCE NOR SENIOR OFFICERS
IN EMCFA MET WITH THE OFFICERS INVOLVED TO ORDER THEM TO
TESTIFY TRUTHFULLY OR OTHERWISE.

THE ESAF OFFICERS CALLED TO
GIVE ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY EXPRESSED SURPRISE, ANGER, AND SOMT-
CONFUSION, WHEN CALLED TO SUBMIT TO FURTHER QUESTIONING.

~~ ee THERE TS NO OUTWARD INDICATION
THAT THE ESAF FICERS WERE COACHED ON WHAT TO SAY. IP PONCE

AND THE EMCFA WANTED 10 DELAY THIS CASE FROM GOING TO TRIAL,
THEY HAVE SUCCEEDED. THE CASE 1S NOW BOGGED DOWN IN THIS NEW
LINE OF INVESTIGATION WHICH HAS YET TO DEVELOP ANY DAMAGING
INFORMATION OF SIGNIFICANCE. TO THE CONTRARY, AND AS REPORTED
IN PREVIOUS TRAFFIC, THERE IS THE POSSIBILITY THAT THIS NEW
INVESTIGATION WILL ACTUALLY STRENGTHEN THE DEFENSE'S CASE,
THERE 1S NOW TESTIMONY, DEVELOPED IN THIS LATEST ROUND OF
INVESTIGATION, THAT THERE WAS NO DISCUSSION OF THE JESUITS AT
THE 15 NOVEMBER 1989 MEETING. THIJS UNDERCUTS THE SINCI
RETRACTED TESTIMONY THAT COLONEL GUILLERMO ((BENEVIDES))
ORDERED THE KILLINGS AT THIS SAME MEETING.

5. ANOTHER POSSIBLE MOTIVE FOR PONCE'S ACTIONS IS THAT
PRESIDENT CRISTIAN] IS PRESSURING THE ESAF TO BE MORI
COOPERATIVE IN THE INVESTIGATION. THE REASONING BEHIND THIS
THEORY IS THAT PONCE WOULD NOT HAVE EMBARKED ON THIS INITIATIVE
ON HIS OWN; THE ESAF HAS NOT BEEN COOPERATIVE FOR THE PAST ONE
AND A HALF YEARS, WHY WOULD IT COOPERATE NOW? PRESIDENT
CRISTIAN] IS BEING PRESSURED FROM ALL SIDES TO PROSECUTE THIS
CASE AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE, AND THE ESAF'S UNCOOPERATIVE
STANCE WOULD HAVE BEEN A LOGICAL PLACE FOR PRESIDENT CRISTIANI
TO BEGIN HIS OWN PRESSURING. THIS THEORY IS ENTIRELY POSSIBLE,
BUT THERE IS NO EVIDENCE TO DATE TO SUPPORT THIS THEORY.

6. YET ANOTHER POSSIBILITY 1S THAT PONCE AND THE EMCFA ARE
SINCERE IN WANTING TO RESOLVE THIS CASE, AND THIS INITIATIVE IS
A DEMONSTRATION OF THIS NEW FOUND SINCERITY. THERE ARE FEW
PEOPLE WHO WOULD SIGN ON TO THIS THEORY, ESPECIALLY GIVEN THE
HISTORY OF THIS CASE. THERE IS PRECIOUS LITTLE EVIDENCE TO
SUPPORT A CHANGE OF HEART ON THE PART OF THE ESAF AND PONCE IN
PARTICULAR. IN FACT, CLOSE EXAMINATION OF THIS LATEST
INITIATIVE REVEALS THAT PONCE AND THE EMCFA MAY NOT HAVE BEEN
PROVIDING NEW LEADS AT ALL. THE FACT IS THAT PONCE ATTENDED
THE 15 NOVEMBER 1989 MEETING AND IS FULLY AWARE OF THE
PROCEEDINGS. HE IS, THEREFORE, FULLY AWARE THAT TESTIMONY
WOULD PROVE THAT THERE WAS NO DISCUSSION OF THE JESUITS AT ALL
(AS BORNE OUT BY SUBSEQUENT EVENTS). IT IS CONCEIVABLE THAT
PONCE AND THE EMCFA WERE WELL AWARE OF THE OUTCOME OF THIS LINE
OF INVESTIGATION BEFORE JT STARTED.

HIS NEW INITIATIVE WILL

‘
NOT PROVIDE sai wean ABOUT THE MURDER OF THE

JESUITS, NOR WILL IT MOVE THE CASE ANY CLOSER TO BEING
RESOLVED. THIS NEW INITIATIVE HAS SERVED TO DELAY THE CASE
FROM GOING TO TRIAL, MUDDIED THE ALREADY MURKY WATERS AND
GENERATED BOTH HOPE AND DESPAIR THAT A JUST SOLUTION WILL BE
FOUND. IT IS LOGICAL TO EXPECT THAT SUCH AN INITIATIVE FROM
THE MINISTER OF DEFENSE AND EMCFA WOULI) SIGNAL TO THE ESAF THAT
PERHAPS THE HIGH COMMAND ACTUALLY WANTED THIS CASE TO BE
RESOLVED. IN FACT, THE SUBJECT OF THE JESUIT MURDERS [5 NOT
DISCUSSED AMONG OFFICERS, PERHAPS OUT OF FEAR OF GUILT BY
ASSOCIATION OR SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY WANT IT TO GO AWAY. THE
UNFORTUNATE REALITY IS THAT UNTIL A WITNESS OR RELIABLE SOURCE
WITH ACCESS TO SIGNIFICANT INFORMATION ON THE AUTHORS OF THIS
CRIME ARE FOUND, THE CASE WILL BE STALLED. JF THE CASE GOES TO
COURT UNDER THESE CIRCUMSTANCES IT IS NOT BEYOND THE REALM OF
POSSIBILITY THAT COLONEL BENEVIDES WILL BE EXONERATED AND THE
OTHERS WILL RECEIVE SENTENCES COMMENSURATE WITH THEIR
INVOLVEMENT.

Read the complete text