Update on Progress in Jesuit Murder Case - TruthH Commission I)

Central Intelligence Agency · 1990

Read Update on Progress in Jesuit Murder Case - TruthH Commission I) by Central Intelligence Agency (1990) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000049168.txt.

Introduction

An update on progress in the Jesuit murder case is preserved in a CIA item from 1990, kept with the Truth Commission records. Updates like this one were the case's pulse, taken for readers in San Salvador and Washington. Each reported a step, a stall, or a name, in a case that took years to reach a courtroom.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1990
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE5337
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000049168

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

PAGE 0001

0318452 MAR TY

SUBJECT: UPDATE ON PROGRESS IN JESUIT MURDER CASE

1. ACTION REQUESTED: NONE. FY! ONLY.
2. AS THE JESUIT MURDER CASE ENTERS ITS FOURTH MONTH THERE
1S A NOTABLE DECREASE IN THE ATTENTION BEING GIVEN TO THE
AFFAIR IN THE 2. AND IN POLITICAL CIRCLES. ae
CONTINUEM@ TO WORK TO GA
INFORMATION ON THE INV GATION AND COURT PROGRESS AS WELL AS
MAINTAIN PRESSURE ON THE SALVADORAN JUDICIA C
WITH THE CRIME.

CLOSELY MONITOR THE COURT'S PROGRES ING THE CASE.
UNFORTUNATELY, PROGRESS HAS BEEN SLOW AND THERE JS LITTLE HOPE
THAT THE PROCESS WILL BE SPED UP IN THE NEAR FUTURE.

NOV 1993

TOR: O3193SZ MAR 90)

ed eas ees PS i Se a cn es Sn ies wee Sa ee Serpe ee gS

AGREED TO PROVIDE A WRITTEN STATEMENT OF WHAT HE SAW AND HEARD
BEFORE AND DURING THE NIGHT OF 15 NOVEMBER. TO DATE THE YOUNG
MAN HAS PROVIDED A CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS FROM THE BEGINNING OF
THE OFFENSIVE UP UNTIL 15 NOVEMBER.

INT OF WHAT HAPPENED

SHOWS PROMISE

THE YOUNG MAN IS THE
FIRST NON-MILITARY EYEWITNESS WITH WHAT MAY WELL BE VALUABLE
INFORMATION.

4, OMPLETED HIS INVESTIGATION INTO THE
POSSIBILITY OF AIR FORCE INVOLVEMENT IN THE KILLINGS AND
CONCLUDED THAT THERE IS NO EVIDENCE TO POINT TO ANY AIR FORCE
PARTICIPATION IN THE CRIMES.
REPORTED THAT ON THE NIGHT OF THE MURDERS
A UNIT OF THE LONG RANGE RECON PATROL (PRAL) LEFT
AIRBASE AT APPROXIMATELY 2300 HRS. REPORTED
THE SAME INFORMATION AND ADDED THAT THE UNIT WAS LEAD BY
MAJOR ((PERDOMO)). JNFIRMED THAT THE
PRAL DID INDEED LEAV T THAT HOUR, WITH THE
SPECIFIC MISSION OF PA THE AREA.
THIS WAS A LEGITIMATE MISSION AND IN NO WAY CONNECTED TO THE
MURDERS. TO DATE, NO OTHER INFORMATION HAS SURFACED TO
IMPLICATE THE AIR FORCE.

: ASSY OFFICERS CONTINUE TO MEET REGULARLY WITH
JUDICIAL OFFICIALS TO OBTAIN UPDATES ON THE PROGRESS IN THE
CASE AND TO PRESSURE FOR ADVANCEMENT. SEVERAL OBSTACLES HAVE
ARISEN WHICH MAY OR MAY NOT THREATEN THE ULTIMATE OUTCOME

Gi» PAGE 0003

OF THE TRIAL. THE MOST IMPORTANT OBSTACLE CONFRONTING THE COURTS
AT THE MOMENT IS FINDING SUFFICIENT EVIDENCE TO BIND COLONEL
GUILLERMO ((BENAVIDES)) MORENO OVER FOR TRIAL. JUDGE RICARDO
ORA)), WHO CURRENTLY HAS JURISDICTION, ADV 1 SED Qa
THE CASE AGAINST BENAVIDES 1S VERY WEAK A AID
IT IS POSSIBLE HE COULD BE FREED FOR LACK OF EVIDENCE.
ACCORDING TO SALVADORAN Law, AN INDICTED CO-CONSPIRATOR CAN
NOT TESTIFY AGAINST A FELLOW CO-CONSPIRATOR. THEREFORE, AT THE
PRESENT TIME THERE IS NO WITNESS TO IMPLICATE BENAVIDES IN
THE CRIME AND BENAVIDES STEADFASTLY DENIES ANY INVOLVEMENT.
ATTEMPTS TO SOLVE THIS PROBLEM HAVE BEEN FRUSTRATING.
CONFLICTING INFORMATION FROM A VARIETY OF SOURCES DIFFERS AS TO
WHETHER IT IS POSSIBLE TO "UNINDICT" ONE OF THE
LIEUTENANTS IN THE CASE AND USE HIM AS A WITNESS AGAINS1
BENAVIDES. JUDGE ZAMORA CLAIMS THIS IS NOT POSSIBLE, WHILE
OTHERS ARGUE THAT IT IS ACCEPTABLE UNDER EXISTING LAWS.

7. JUDGE ZAMORA'S
HANDLING CAN BE DESCRIBED AS LESS THAN ADEQUATE.
PERHAPS THE EXPLANATION FOR JUDGE ZAMORA'S LACK OF ENTHUSIASM

CAN BE ATTRIBUTED TO FEAR FOR HIS LIFE SHOUD GGRESIVELY
Sins is C4: aoe
IN FEARS THE ARMED FORCES, SPECIFICALLY THE

TANDONA", WILL SEEK REVENGE AGAINST HIM SHOULD HE PROSECUTE
THE CASE TO ITS FULLEST. ZAMORA HAS GONE AS FAR AS TO ASK FOR
PROTECTION AND VISAS TO SEND HIS FAMILY TO THE UNITED STATES.

8. WHILE ZAMORA'S PERCEPTION OF A THREAT IS UNDERSTANDABLE
GIVEN THE HISTORICAL REALITIES OF EL SALVADOR, THERE IS NO

EVIDENCE TO INDICATE THERE JS A THREAT AG
LIFE. IN 1D a crcsarrwrroe csc THE
ARMED FORCES AS TITUTION WANT SEE THIS CASE PROSECUTED

TO ITS FULL EXTENT, IF FOR NOTHING ELSE THAN TO CLEAR THE NAME
OF THE ESAF. ADDITIONALLY, COLONEL PONCE HAS STATED, PUBLICLY

AND PRIVATELY THE GUILTY MUST BE PROSECUTED. ON THE OTHER HAND,
PONCE HAS NOT GIVEN ZAMORA ANY SPECIAL ASSURANCES OR
GUARANTEES. PONCE IS UNDER

TREMENDOUS PRESSURE FROM AT LEAST SOME TANDONA MEMBERS TO
PROTECT FELLOW TANDONA MEMBER BENAVIDES. THIS PRESSURE MAY BE
ONE OF THE REASONS PONCE HAS ARGUED REPEATEDLY TO USG OFFICIALS
AND THE PRESS THAT THE MILITARY HAS DONE ITS PART IN THE
INVESTIGATION (THE HONOR TRIBUNAL) AND THAT NOW IT IS UP TO THE
COURTS. THE U.S. VICE PRESIDENT RECENTLY WARNED PONCE THAT THE
MILITARY MUST ENSURE THAT THE GUILTY ARE PROSECUTED AND PROVIDE
THE NECESSARY GUARANTEE SO THAT THE JUDICIAL PROCESS CAN GO
FORWARD WITHOUT INTERFERENCE OR THREATS.

a

0

TOR: OFL9357 MAR 90

9. OTHER ISSUES IN THIS CASE INCLUDE ALLEGATIONS OF A
MEETING OF CERTAIN TANDONA MEMBERS PRIOR TO THE KILLINGS IN WHICH
THE JESUITS WERE DISCUSSED, AND A MEETING AT DNI THE FOLLOWING
MORNING DURING WHICH THE ANNOUNCEMENT OF THE MURDERS WAS MET
WITH APPLAUSE. STATION COULD FIND NO PROOF THAT THE ALLEGED
MEETING OF THE TANDONA TOOK PLACE. THERE WAS A MEETING OF THE
JOINT STAFF (ESTADO MAYOR) ON THE EVENING BEFORE THE JESUIT
MURDERS, BUT THERE 1S NO INDICATION THERE WAS ANY DISCUSSION
OF THE JESUITS OR THAT ANY OF THE DISCUSSIONS HELD aT THAT
MEETING LEAD TO THE KILLINGS. CONCERNING THE MEETING AT ONI,
THERE IS NO EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT PRESS CONTENTIONS THAT THE
NEWS OF THE MURDERS WAS MET BY APPLAUSE.
DETAILED INVESTIGATION OF THE MEETING,

WHILE IT IS POSSIBLE A HANDFUL OF THE APPROXIMATELY 30 PERSONS
WHO ATTENDED THE MEETING MAY HAVE CLAPPED OR EXPRESSED THEIR
SATISFACTION THAT THE JESUITS HAD BEEN KILLED, THERE IS NOTHING

Read the complete text