Findings of the Special Honor Commission in the San Sebastian Case - TruthH Com

Central Intelligence Agency · 1989

Read Findings of the Special Honor Commission in the San Sebastian Case - TruthH Com by Central Intelligence Agency (1989) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000049130.txt.

Introduction

Findings of the Special Honor Commission in the San Sebastian case fill a CIA item from 1989. An honor commission was the armed forces' own court of inquiry, judging soldiers by the institution's code. Its findings carried weight inside the army even when outsiders doubted them, and the file kept them for the record.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1989
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE8372
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000049130

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ps 1418522 MAR ba DIST: 14 MARCH 1989 COUNTRY: EL SALVADOR SUBJ: FINDINGS OF THE SPECIAL HONOR COMMISSION IN THE SAN SEBASTIAN CASE DOI: 9 MARCH 1989 SUMMARY: ON 9 MARCH 1989, THE ESAF SPECIAL HONOR COMMISSION PRESENTED ITS FINDINGS IN THE SAN SEBASTIAN CASE. ACCORDING TO THE COMMISSION'S REPORT, MAJOR BELTRAN, THE 5TH BRIGADE S-11, WAS PRIMARILY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE 21 SEPTEMBER 1988 KILLING OF 10 CIVILIANS IN SAN SEBASTIAN. THE KILLING OF THE 10 CIVILIANS, WHO WERE IN FACT INVOLVED IN FMLN SUBVERSIVE ACTIVITIES, WAS A CRIMINAL ACT AND WAS OUTSIDE NORMAL OPERATING PROCEDURES. MAJOR BELTRAN CONCOCTED A FALSE AMBUSH TO CAMOUFLAGE THE KILLINGS AND ORDERED THE ESAF PERSONNEL INVOLVED, WHO OPPOSED HIS ORDERS, 10 CARRY OUT THE FALSE AMBUSH AND KILL THE CIVILIANS. THE COMMISSION FOUND THE COMMANDER OF THE 5TH BRIGADE INNOCENT OF ANY KNOWLEDGE REGARDING THE KILLINGS AND RECOMMENDED THAT HE BE RETURNED TO HIS COMMAND. THE COMMISSION PROVIDED A LIST OF PERSONS INVOLVED IN THE KILLINGS WHO Kee Approved for Release NOV 1993 ee ee aes PAGE O00? premio SHOULD BE TURNED OVER TO THE COMPETENT TRIBUNALS FOR LEC ar acTTON. TEXT: 1. ON 9 MARCH 1989, THE SPECIAL HONOR COMMISS TOK (sue) OF THE SALVADORAN ARMED FORCES (ESAF) PRESENTED ITS FINDINGS Th tll SAN SEBASTIAN CASE @@*THE MINISTER OF DEFENSE. ACCORDING TC) Ht SHC'S REPORT, THE SAN SEBASTIAN KII.LINGS WERE FOUND Tt bt. THE PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITY OF MAJOR MAURICIO DE JESUS ((BEILIRAN)) GRANADOS, THE 5TH INFANTRY BRIGADE S-I]. THE SHC ALSO LOUND THAT THE 10 PERSONS KILLED HAD BEEN INVOLVED IN SUBVERSIVE ACTIVITItS OF THE FARABUNDO MARTI NATIONAL LIBERATION FRONT (FMLN) BUT THEIR KILLING WAS A CRIMINAL ACT. 2. THE SHC'S REPORT PROVIDES AS BACKGROUND TO THE FINDINGS THE STORY AS ORIGINALLY PUT OUT BY MAJOR BELTRAN AND A LIST OF ALL THE PERSONS INTERVIEWED BY THE SHC. THE REPORT THEN PROVIDIS A TRUE ACCOUNT OF THE EVENTS, BASED ON THE INTERVIEWS, AND THE SUC'S CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS. ee | ae ‘ » OPS F oe ane: an ’ ‘ : aoe) t A. PRECIS OF ACTUAL EVENTS: -ON 20 SEPTEMBER 1988, THE 2ND SECTION OF THE 2ND COMPANY OF THE 'JIBOA" BATTALION OF THE 5TH INFANTRY BRIGADE, UNDER THE COMMAND OF LIEUTENANT ARNOLDO ANTONIO ((VASQUEZ) ) Ai-VARENGA, WHICH HAD BEEN OPERATING IN THE AREA FOR A NUMBER OF DAYS, RECEIVED THE ORDER TO CAPTURE A SUPPOSED INSURGENT NAMED JOSE MAtlA ( (FLORES) ) WHO RESIDED IN THE TOWN OF SAN FRANCISCO, SAN SEBASTIAN JURISDICTION. THIS MISSION WAS CARRIED OUT AND THE CAPTURED INSURGENT WAS RELIEVED OF TwO M-16 RIFLES, EXPLOSIVES, PROPAGANDA, AND TWO BI-AcK UNIFORMS WHICH HE HAD IN THAT PLACE. AT APPROXIMATELY 0730 HOURS LOCAL ON 21 SEPTEMBER, IST LIEUTENANT MANUEL DE JESUS ((GALVEZ)) GALVEZ, COMMANDER OF THE 2ND COMPANY, MET UP WITH THE 2ND SECTION, ACCOMPANIED BY HIS COMMAND GROUP; HE HAD RECEIVED A REPORT OF THE CAPTURE FROM HIS SECTION COMMANDER. -BASED ON THE INTERROGATION OF THE CAPTURED INSURGENT, THREE OTHER SUSPECTED PERSONS WERE DETAINED; WHILE THIS WAS BEING CARRIED OUT AN UNDETERMINED NUMBER (30-40) OF PEOPLE HAD BEEN GATHERED IN THE STREET IN FRONT OF THE SCHOOL, WHICH LED TO THE TOWN OF LA CEBADILLA. THESE PERSONS HAD BEEN GATHERED TOGETHER SO THAT THE MILITARY COULD COMMUNICATE TO THEM THE MILITARY'S €ONCERN THAT THEY WERE BEING USED BY THE FMLN FOR TERRORISTIC PURPOSES. _——— SEE Baer 0003 m0 Aaa ~AT APPROXIMATELY 1130 HOURS LOCAL ON THE. sit DAY, MAJOR BELTRAN ARRIVED ON THE SCENE. BELTRAN IS THE S li oor tite STH BRIGADE. BELTRAN WAS ACCOMPANIED BY TWO INTERROGATORS sab stuitlIVED BY HELICOPTER. -AS A RESULT OF THE INTERROGATIONS OF THE PRA SONERS, SIX MORE PERSONS WERE DETAINED, MAKING A TOTAL OF 10. -BETWEEN 1300-1400 HOURS LOCAL, MAJOR BELIan 100K THE DECISION TO KILL THE 10 PERSONS AND WAS OPPOSED IN THIS obec ty tON BY THE TWO LIEUTENANTS, WHO MAINTAINED HIS WAS AN ILLEGAL onbt li WHICH WOULD COMPROMISE THE MILITARY PERSONNEL. FROM THAT MOMINI ON, MAJOR BELTRAN ASSUMED COMMAND OF THE UNIT AND BEGAN GIVING Dies | ORDERS TO SUBORDINATES. HE ORDERED SGT. JORGE ALBERTO ((TOBAR)) Gil7MAN TO GO ALONG THE ROAD TO LA CEBADILLA AND SET UP AN AMBUSH USING HIE CAPTURED EQUIPMENT. be -SGT. GUZMAN, ACCOMPANIED BY SOME SOLDIER, 151 ABLISHED THE AMBUSH AT APPROXIMATELY 1530 HOURS LOCAL. THE CIVIPTANS WERE LED BY VARTOUS MEMBERS OF THE TROOP TO THE SELECTED LOCATION A MINE WAS EXPLODED AND A HAND GRENADE WAS THROWN, RESULTING IN AN UNDI TERMINED NUMBER OF DEAD BUT THE MAJORITY OF THE CIVILIANS WOUNDED, WHO WERE THEN KILLED BY MEMBERS OF THE UNIT ON THE ORDERS OF MAJOK WEL TRAN. -A POSTER AND SUBVERSIVE PROPAGANDA WERE Ut IN THE PLACE WHERE THE DEAD WERE TO JUSTIFY OR SIMULATE AN INSURGENT AMBUSH. THE LEG OF ONE SOLDIER WAS SMEARED WITH BLOOD AND HE WAS, EVACUATED TO THE BRIGADE ON THE ORDERS OF MAJOR BELTRAN. IN THAT SAME HELICOPTER WAS TRANSPORTED THE CAPTURED EQUIPMENT, WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE EXPLOSIVES WHICH WERE LATER DESTROYED. -DURING THE FOLLOWING DAYS, MAJOR BELTRAN SPREAD THE FALSE VERSION OF EVENTS AND ORDERED ALL SUBORDINATE PERSONNE:I. TO STICK TO THAT STORY. -IN ORDER TO LEND CREDENCE TO HIS FALSE VERSION OF EVENTS, MAJOR BELTRAN SELECTED A SOLDIER WOUNDED IN ANOTHER OPERATION TO PRESENT AS THE SOLDIER ALLEGEDLY WOUNDED IN THE SUPPOSED AMBUSH. THIS VERSION OF EVENTS IS BASED ON THE SPONTANEOUS DECLARATIONS MADE TO THE SHC BY THE MILITARY PERSONNEL WHO WERE PRESENT Al THE SCENE. B. CONCLUSIONS: -THE EVENTS WHICH TOOK PLACE ON 2] SEPTEMNER 1988, IN THE TOWN OF SAN FRANCISCO, SAN SEBASTIAN, SAN VICENTE DLPARTMENT, WERE NOT THE RESULT OF AN INSURGENT AMBUSH BUT INVOLVE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF MILITARY PERSONNEL OF THE 5TH INFANTRY BRIGADE. ESA EE, eb baRihaN ht A A Aad Ad ieee ees aanneaginenae eas -THE 10 PERSONS DETAINED AT THAT TIME AND Wit WERE SUBSEQUENTLY KILLED, ACCORDING TO THE INFORMATION OBTAINHD AND THE MATERIAL CAPTURED, WERE INVOLVED IN PARTICIPATING IN FMIEN SUBVERSIVE ACTIVITIES. -PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITY, THAT IS TO SAY Tih DRCTSTON AND PLANNING OF THE CRIMINAL ACT, FALLS ON MAJOR BELTRAN. -ALSO RESPONSIBLE FOR THEIR PARTICIPATION IN ITtlt EXECUTION OF THE EVENTS WERE: LT. ARNOLDO VASQUEZ AI.VARENGA SGT. JORGE ALBERTO TOBAR GUZMAN SGT. RAFAEL ((ROSALES)) VILLALOBOS CPL. HERNAN CCAYALA)) ARIAS PVT. JOSE CARLOS ((HERNANDEZ)) MATUTE PVT. FRANCISCO ((PONCE)) RAMIREZ PVT. FERMIN ((CRUZ)) CASTRO PVT. JOSE ALFRERO ((MENDEZ)) BELTRAN ALTHOUGH THESE PERSONS COULD BE CHARGED LEGALLY WITH THE ACTIONS DESCRIBED ABOVE, THIS WOULD NOT BE JUSTIFIED AS, ACCORDING 10° THE INFORMATION AVAILABLE TO THE SHC, AT NO TIME DID THEY SUPPORT THE DECISIONS TAKEN BY MAJOR BELTRAN, BUT ON THE CONTRARY OrPOSED HIS ORDERS WITHIN THE LIMITS OF MILITARY HIERARCHY. THEIR ACTIONS CAN BE EXPLAINED BY THE DAMAGING EFFECTS AND THE DYNAMIC OF THIS WAR AND IN THE DIFFICULT BALANCE BETWEEN SUBORDINATION TO COMMAND AND CARRYING OUT ILLEGAL ORDERS. -THE ACTS CARRIED OUT CONSTITUTE A GRAVE VIOLATION OF THE NORMAL OPERATING PROCEDURE WHICH REGULATES THE ARRESTS MADE BY PERSONNEL OF THE VARIOUS UNITS OF THE ARMED FORCES. -THE COMMANDER OF THE 5TH BRIGADE HAD NO KNOWLEDGE AT ANY TIME OF THE REALITY OF THE EVENTS UNTIL HIS INTERVIEW BY THIS COMMISSION. -THESE KINDS OF ACTIONS, WHICH BY THEIR NATURE ARE ISOLATED TO

Read the complete text