Reuter: Duarte Weakened Government by Handling Kidnapping

Central Intelligence Agency · 1985

Read Reuter: Duarte Weakened Government by Handling Kidnapping by Central Intelligence Agency (1985) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000045188.txt.

Introduction

Reuters judged that Duarte's handling of the kidnapping weakened his government, in a CIA record dated September 3, 1985. A wire service verdict carries weight in capitals around the world. The judgment cut at the president in his hardest personal crisis.

Inside, the agency's analysis of his position is preserved. A president bargaining for his daughter looked, to many, like a state bending. That look cost him authority with soldiers and rivals alike. The file keeps the wire's cool verdict, which is part of how the crisis was understood abroad while it was still unfolding at home.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1985
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE5472
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000045188

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

UNCLASSIFIED
Department of State :

8916487

PAGE 81 B8G8 = ARAIB72
ACTION KR~18
INFO FRLE-81 ARA-84 PPC-81 OAS-Bi PPA-#1 SSE-BL OCER-81
REG-81 §S-82 /913 AI DH
UKFO LOG-88 ARA-~88 SY-96 HA-98 AHAD-61  PH~18 PA-82
MCT-84 = A~B2 SYE-08  SP-82 SLPO-8i 046 W

wrt t ene ee nn ee ene 377812 B3164SZ /38
P 8915382 OCT 85
FH FBIS CHIVA CHIVA PH
TO AIG 4678
USCOHSOL ANT
FBIS KEY WEST FL
CDR 29TH MI BH FT DAVIS PH//AFZU-HI-C//
FBIS ASUNCION PA
PDG COROZAL PN
ACCT FBPA-EVOK

UNCLAS 6XX 62
coPY TO Hoo

(UE TO COPYRIGHT OR OTHER RESTRICTIONS, THE FOLLOWING ITEM {S
UKTENDED FOR USE ONLY BY U.S.. GOVERNMENT CONSUHERS

SUBJ -

REUTER: DUARTE WEAXERS GOVERNMENT BY HANOLING KIDNAPPING

PABS1535

BUENOS AURES REGTER IM ENGLISH TO REUTER LONDON 1587 GHT
§$ ocT 8&5

(BY ROBERT BLOCK)) R

(ITEXTI), SAH SALVADOR, OCT $, REUTER -- PRESIDENT JOSE
NAPOLEON DUARTE’S HANDLING OF HES DAUGHTER'S KIONAPPING HAS
WEAKENED H1S GOVERNHENT ANC SHAKEN HIS RELATIONSHIP WiTH THE ARMED
FORCES, MILITARY OFFICIALS, GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS AND DIPLOMATS
SAY. :
THE RESULTS OF TaE CRISIS, THEY ADDED, COULD BE TRE LOSS OF
THE PRESIDENT’S AUTHORITY, A WAVE OF LEFTIST GUERRILLA SPONSORED
KIDHAPPINGS AKD A WIDESPREAD ABUSE OF HUNAN RIGHTS BY THE ARKY
IH ITS SEX-VEAR-OLD CIVIL WAR AGAINST THE GUERRILLAS

"THIS [S THE BIGGEST CRISIS WE HAVE EVER FACED. 1 ON'T THINE
THINGS ARE GOING TO BE QUITE THE SAHE WITH THIS GOVERNMENT HEX
IT 1S ALL OVER,” ONE GOVERNMENT INSIDER SAID.

THE SOURCES AGREED THAT THE PROBLEMS STEMMED FROM DUARTE’S
APPARENT IMPOTENCE 1M THE NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE KIDNAPPERS AND
HES WILLUNGHESS TO GIVE IM TO THEIR DEMANDS

MILITARY OFFICERS, tH PARTICULAR, EXPRESSED THEIR DISAGREEMENT
WITH THE PRES{DENT'S DISPOSITION TO HAND OVER 75 OF THE 3! SEBEL
PRISONERS THE KIDNAPPERS WANT IM RETURN FOR INCS GUADALUPE DUARTE
DURAN AND A WOHAK CAPTURED WITH NER LAST HCITH,

ARMY COMMANDERS INITIALLY SYMPATHIZED WITH DUARTE’ S
PREDICANERT AND BACKED A PLAN TO RELEASE A HANGFUL OF REESL
PRISONERS, BUT THE POSITION HAS CHANGED IN RECENT Days a3 17
HOS BCCONE APPARENT THAT DUARTE WAS READY TO COMPLY WITH NEGRLY
ALL IKE KIDNAPPERS WISHES.

DURING A RADIO CONTACT WITH THE KIDHAPPERS MONITORED BY
REPORTERS LAST SATURDAY, DUARTE SAIO HE HAD ALRCADY RELEASED
THREL PECELE Gk THE RIDNEPPERS’ LIST AND WAS READY TO FREE 22
MORE, BE ALSO ASKED THCH FOR HELP 10 CLARIFY THE CASES OF NINE
OTHER REECLS TRE GOVERNMENT COULD NOT ACCOUNT FoR.

HANY OFFICERS BELIEVE DUARTE WAS SOFT ON THE KIDNAPPERS AN
PLACED FAMILY CONCERNS AQOYE NATIONAL INTERESTS.

“AS A FATHER VE UNDERSTAND NIM, BUT AS "A PRESIDENT THERE 1S
ALSO THE BUSINESS CF NATIONAL SECURITY TO CONSIDER ... I ASK
MYSELF WHETHER THE CHICRESTS GF INE COUNTRY ARE-INVOLYCD IN ALL

. : UNCLASSIFIED

See rele trey Curse
x ee

INCOMING
TELEGRAM

- 8866

g

an? 979

THIS," A HIGH-RANKING FIELD COMMANDER TOLD REUTERS.

. ACCORDING TO MILITARY OFFICERS AND GOVERNHENT OFFICIALS,
DUARTE DURAN'S ABDUCTION BY LEFTIST GUERRILLAS APPEARS 10 BE
ATHED AT WEAKENING OUARTE BY DRIVING A WEDGE BETWEEN HIS
CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATIC GOVERNMENT AND THE ARHED FORCES

DUARTE’S ABILITY AS THE FIRST CHVILIAM PRESIDENT IM EL
SALVADOR [H SS YEARS TO WIN THE CONFIDENCE OF THE TOP BRASS
HAS BEEN A KEY TO CONSOLIDATING POWER IN TURNING THE TIDE OF
THE COUNTRY’S CIVIL WAR AGAINST THE GUERRILLAS

OFFICIALS NOW SAY THAT WITH THE KIDNAPPING OF DUARTE'S
FAVOURITE CHILO, THE GUERRILLAS MIGHT SUCCEED IN THEIR ATTEMPTS
TO REVERSE THIS PROCESS.

"IT WAS A GOOD BLOW THEY (THE GUERRILLAS) DEALT US. THE
TENSIONS ARE GOING TO OPEN RIFTS BETWEEN THE GOVERNHENT AND THE
ARMY, THE GOVERNMENT HAS ALREADY STARTED TO WEAKER,” A TOP
CHRISTIAN DEMOCRAT AKO KEY GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL SAID.

THE OFFICHAL ADDED HIS HAIN FEAR WAS THAT HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES |

ARAIB72

TH EL SALVADOR, NOW ON THE DECLINE, WOULD INCREASE BECAUSE MANY
ARHY OFFICIALS ANGERED BY DUARTE’S DECISION HIGHT REFUSE To
TAKE PRISONERS.

ONE TOP FIELD COMMANDER ALREADY TOLD REUTERS IT WAS ‘HOT
WORTH THE TROUBLE’ TO CAPTURE GUERRILLAS IN COMBAT ANY MORE IF
THE GOVERNHENT WAS ONLY GOING TO ARBITRARILY RELEASE THEM LATER

OTHER OFFICIALS ALSO EXPRESSED CONCERN THAT DUARTE’S
NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE KIDNAPPERS HIGHT ENCOURAGE MCRE ABDUCTIONS

THE GOVERKHENT’S POSITION HAS TAKEN A DRAMATIC TURN SINCE
THE DAYS THNEDIATELY AFTER THE SEPTEMBER 18 KIDNAPPING.

GOVERNMENTS FROM AROUND THE WCRLD HAVE CONDEMNED THE REBEL
ACTION AND EXPRESSED SOLIDARITY WITH DUARTE, TURNING HES PERSONAL
TRAGEDY INTO SOMETHING OF A SHORTLIVED POLITICAL GOLD AIHE.

"THEY (THE GOVERNMENT) HAD THE (NITIATIVE BUT THEY DON'T
ANYMORE. {7 WAS TURNED AROUND AND THEY LOST 17,” ONE WESTERK
DIPLOHAT SAID.

OFFICTALS NOW SAY THE SITUATION CAN OHLY GROW WORSE AS THE
NEGOTIATIONS DRAG ON,

* DEFENCE MINISTER CARLOS EUGENIO VIDOES CASANOVA, KANED EY
DUARTE TO A SPECIAL THREE-MAN COMMISSION TO ADVISE HIM CH
NEGOTIATION STRATEGY, TOLD REUTERS THAT THE PRESIDENT WAS BWARE
OF THE HEED TO RESOLVE THE CRISIS AS FAST AS POSSIBLE SO THE
GOVERNHENT COULD START TO REPAIR THE DAMAGE IT SUFFERED.

BUT SO FAR THERE ARE FEW SIGHS THAT THE KIDRAPPERS ARE WILLING
TO COOPERATE WITH DUARTE AND THEY HAVE ALREADY REJECTED SOME = *
‘OF HIS COUNTER-DEMANDS, SOURCES CLOSE TO THE TALKS SAY

“HO MATTER WHAT THE RESULT, DUARTE {S GOING TO LOSE AUTHORITY
WHEN THE WAR TOUCHED HIM HE BROKE. POW CAN YOU HAVE AUTHCRITY
AFTER THAT?" ONE YOUNG OFFICER SAID
{ENDALL) =a9tSo? O9/NSSIZ C3F

EoT

toe

"Approved for Release

Read the complete text