Results of Photo Comparison Case no 12517-MEMO Also Mentions- Thomas H. Pilking
Central Intelligence Agency · 1970
Read Results of Photo Comparison Case no 12517-MEMO Also Mentions- Thomas H. Pilking by Central Intelligence Agency (1970) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000039306.txt.
Introduction
Case number 12517 receives its photo comparison results in a CIA record dated November 5, 1970. An attached memo also mentions Thomas H. Pilkington in connection with the case. The record belongs to the MIA and POW identification work of the Vietnam War.
Inside are the findings for the numbered case, with the memo adding its own notes. Attached memos often carried the context that the bare result left out. Together they show how a single case file could hold two things at once. It held a laboratory judgment and the office discussion around it. Both were preserved on the same few pages for later readers.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Central Intelligence Agency |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1970 |
| COLLECTION | DECLASSIFIED |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 4830 |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Internet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror |
Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000039306
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
ead Saat, Meet ae RTEIVENER CE Ome
rob
[TRANSMITTAL (ALT YE, Ee hb.)
DATE: VEL PL 4b |
EMORANDUM SOR: °./Militery Service7
SUBJECT Resuits of Pho
Cese No ? Py
ae oe Se v
REFERENCE : Request Bo NOK of Lar. AY. POLE
1, Transmitted herewith are results of photo comparison
anelysis between the Christmas 1969 film of American PWs in
North Vietnem end photographs submitted with reference.
to Comparison,
The evidence cited in the attached report does not
08 epee,
Oe eee ee ee ee
?
constitute cefinitive proof of the status or identity of in-
Gividwsls portreyed in the questioned photographs. : oe Oe
3. Since the Agency's participation in this program is =
clessified, the fact of such participation must not be re- a :
yerled. This report, therefore, may not be used in an unclas- 1 . i
sizied erena, and the Agency cannot be responsible for any ? ae !
action or decision besed in whole or.in part on the judgivents 3
expressed in the report. | : Re ag i
- ". 8 All materials received from your office in connection es 3g
with subject request are “returned herewith. 7
~ : : :
7 FOR THE CHIEF® .
, - -
7 H
Attachments: H . ' |
(1) Christm2zs 1959 comparison No. . 4
(2) Materiais submitted with request” : :
(2) Overta :
ie precapture photos : :
¢ :
EMORANDUM SOR; ° /Militery Service7
SUBJECT ; Results of Photo ‘Comparison,
Case No, Bae /
: . - # : } 2!) a
REFERENCE : Request from NOK of Lo Ki. D fy :
1, Transmitted herewith are results of photo comparison
analysis between the Christmas 1969 film of American PWs in
North Vietnam and photographs submitted with reference.
e cited in the attached report does not
2. The evidenc
constitute definitive proof of the status or identity of in-
dividesls portrayed in the questioned photographs.
= Since the Asency's participation in this program is
clessified, the fact of such participation must not be re-
yeslec. This report, therefore, may not be used in en unclas-
sizied arena, and the Agency cannot be responsible for any
é
action or decision tased in whole or.in part on the judgments
eg in the report. .
in connection
- ". 8° All materials received from your office
with subject request are ‘returned herewith.
‘
: FOR THE CHIEF
Attechments:
(1) Christmas 21959 comparison No. as
(2) Materiasis submitted with request ,
(2} Overlay
(b) precepture photos
(c) tner!:
ed
1) tae
22. ere we re
- a i ee
mee ee
PHOTO COMPARISON ANALYSIS RESULTS:
sitery
Service]
. photog
' Chris
Zion,
- USN -.
7 4 :-
Date of eae [Lob
1. (U) , Surinary of request: (Date received: ‘3
2. Please compare the attached
wa
raphs of Uy) TOOK S ent wt th the
tmas 1969 fi¥m obteainea by Representative
prejcepture
especially prints nunbered DIA™ 34
USAF a
b: See attached overlay for exact location of
image to be compared.
2. (U} Summary of comparison performed:
2. The following frames were chosen for conperison
with the photogrephs submitted: vae)
do. &
- otner ena
below.
a. €
technicians working independently of each
) u2)
lyzed the identifieble features listed
md
Resuits of enelysis: “%.
ity of pre-cepturé photographs submitteg:
Rdequate/inadequate for analysis of recognizebdle
peatures o
' be. (UB, \-+--- - co frames in Christmas film: (Adequet
: eg Ser : 7 ° i
: inadeovate for enaiysis of recognizable features”
1 ¥@
The
(2)
(2)
(3)
(4)
following features were considered sinilar:
Thih ; ae ;
Lal
meres
Are A Nwatens
i agar ann LY: ‘ANG
J Td
i SER Erte Se hie EAC
Christmas 1969 No. 3 } { p4)
ween le MAM Bu Car aere = ta, hae wea ries at .
—
Bona
ee eRe oes
(3)
(6) __
(7)
- (8)
(9) |
The following features were considered dis-
similar:
"Qe an at. foncbioe
Q) __ Mss Ae
a) eae hope,
- (4) ‘
a
C50. cls et et ee De
Conclusion:
(1) In view of the similerity in general
appearence end significant number of
similar features,
could be the subject of the questioned
photographs.
afet aot 7
ee CF (2) In view of the significent number oF
: _differgnces in distinguishable features,
pA j i) #44 probably is not
Rc . Phe sroject or the questioned photo-
ae ' + graphs.
(3) In view of the quality of photography
end the small number of distinguishable
features which could be compared, Fo
concivsion can be reached. ~
" €, (U) The sene image hes been compared with pre-
capture photographs of Air Force,
Navy, Merine, Army, and
a
civilian personnel.
*
WARNING: This photo comparison analysis wes
performed utilizing the best available tech-
nicues, however, the quality of the photo-
graphs in question precluded positive identi-
‘fication. There may be other overriding fac-
“tors: concerning the individual's case which
could confirn.or invalidate the photo compari-
son analysis.
moments: Bee .
fe
} Overiay. or-questioned photo
} Precepture photo 4