El Salvador Performance on Certification Issues(truth Commission I)

Central Intelligence Agency · 1983

Read El Salvador Performance on Certification Issues(truth Commission I) by Central Intelligence Agency (1983) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000027407.txt.

Introduction

El Salvador's performance on certification issues is graded in a CIA paper dated in 1983, tagged Truth Commission in the catalog. Certification meant Congress required proof of progress on human rights before aid flowed. Grading an ally's record in wartime put the agency between policy and fact. The tag links the paper to the later truth inquiry into that war.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1983
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21174
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000027407

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

OP, Director of aSoeretaie— = oe f %, Central mE aba 5 a 5 3 Incelligence j g : a Wea -_ oo to Paes SATE 83.3-83 oe 44 Jonuary 1983 on329 Approved for Relsaae Date “= Warning Notice * “Sensitive Inteligence Sources ond Methods Involved as NATIONAL SECURMY 1 INFORMATION - es " -Anowthorized ‘Disclosure ‘Subject 9 40 Criminal Sonctions | ADISSEMINATION SONTROL ABEREVIATIONS SOFORNE : PROPIN— aN AIBONLY= DROON- RELL Ge sorranged through uy ; _- Not Releasable to Foreign Nationo’s * % HOCONTRATH . thot Releasable to Lontroctorsor -“ Comrector/Gonsyttonts ; Lovtion~—Propretory information anvolwed NEB Deportments Only Dissemination ond Extraction of informetion | Leontroilied by Driginator This informotion Has Geen Authorized tor ‘Release 40... Toreign Government information - Teena <i 27S | “ laiviEW De GuDE ee ONIE 83.1-83 EL SALVADOR: PERFORMANCE ON CERTIFICATION ISSUES Information available as of 15 January 1985 was used in the preparation of this Estimate. ed . THIS ESTIMATE IS ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR OF CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE, | THE NATIONAL FOREIGN INTELLIGENCE BOARD CONGURS. The following intelligence organizations participated in the greporotion of the Estimate: ‘The Centro! Intelligence Agency, the Defense intelligence Apency, the Flationol Security Agency, ond the intelligence organization of the Department of State. Also Participeting: The Assistont Chief of Stoff for Intelligence, Department of the Army The Director of Novel intelligence, Department of the Navy id The Assistont Chief of Staff, Intetligence, Department of the Air Force The Director of Intelligence, Headquorters, Morine Corps ‘KEY JUDGMENTS During the past six aponths ave have seen signs of modest_progress- - insome areas, and nosigns of backsliding on the part of the government. or the military in their commitment to improve the human rights situation and reinforce Cemocratic institutions in El Salvador. Neverthe- less, positive efforts by the government in al] areas continue to be _.... hindered by deep-seated problems, and overall we conclude that Liere . >=. fave deen few dramatic changes since July. We expect progress do © - ‘ semain slow.and ardvous.421r 7” heer a os ° "The government has-made limited progress on duman tights issues inthe past-sia months, although in at Jeast one zrea—the zate-of civilian . deaths—the improvement ‘has been substantial. Other positive trends, such aszood treatment of political-prisoners, remain overshadowedsbya . virtuslly nonfunctional criminal justice system that has proved amable to indictama prosecute the.accused. ea} OS Although some progress hhas been made in curbing abuses dy the a armed forces, =) Salvador continues to -have serious problems in this respect. Major problem areas semain the Jack of fire -control in poptlated combat 2onesand arbiuary violence commi tted by amsuper- ae viseé security forces. Nevertheless, the military has increased efforts to aoe educate and discipline subordinate officer. anc’ troops, anc-§ a =: Pa ln advitian, replace (WG. wmnem of 2 dew commanoers pas peen ioliowed by 2 subsequent improvement in the human sights records of their units. Moreover, - before launching operations some field commanders reportedly have fae received specific instructions to respect the sights of the Jocal civilian Saban He _ we population and to take guerrilla prisonezs. Thex increasingly -have adhered tothese orders in operations of the past six ‘mor ths. 4eae) “The government hes demonstrated advances in political and economic programs, particularly in Phase I of the agrarian sefonns, and the parties have shown a sillingness 10 cooperate on Jaajor issues. A anity pact signed by the maior parties has Jed to establishment of political and human aights commissions and 2 new (Centra) Elections Council. A new constitution is scheduled to be completed this spring, and presidential elections 2te scheduled for March J964. -toqepte | The government continues its interparty discussions on teconcilia- tion. On the issue of negotiations. the positions of all government and military elements have coalesced against guerrilla terms for dialogue, but they will discuss a role for the guerrillas in the ongoing political process. San Salvador has renewed offers to the left to compete in elections and is drafting an amnesty law to help convince leftists to-end the fighting. The government le. ves the door open for possible informal talks to that end. en} a The killers of the US churchwomen have been identified, indicted, and have been remanded for trial in civilian crimina} courts. There is no evidence of higher level complicity in these murders. Two members of the National Guard have confessed to killing two US representatives from the American Institute for Free Labo: Development (AIFLD) and the president of the Salvadoran land reform institute. They have been ordered ‘to stand ‘trial. However, the three accused authors of these crimes—two military officers and a businessman—remain free. {ear Oe Sone mm Exnbassy in San Saivador continues to provide our rimary base of information on the fundamental issues eae in certification; the data provided appear objective and accurateard reflect the judgmentofal _ selements of the mission.<frarrje oe Humon Rights US Congress criterion for “spdging Salvadoran Covernment's performance: Making 2 concerted - and significant effort to comply «vith internation- 2liy recognized human tights” ~- 2. Overall, the Salvadoran Goveroment has «made Jenited progress on human sights issues in the past six snonths relative 10 the period covered in the Jest seport, although in al Jeast one ares—-the aate of civilian death:—the improvement ‘has been substan tial. Given the virtualiy nonfunctional erimina) fustice - system in E] Salvador, the standard Jur measuring progress in this yegard is elusive. According to the LS Embassy, only 300 criminals had been sprovessed through civilian courts oui of 2 pationa) prisoner population of 4.000 «ca S. Tne government's record on treatment of prison ers, however, is good. “These abuser that de occur, according te the US Embeacty, usually happen suring the process of 2rresi.and not during detention. For” example.-the- government claims to have ander detex- ~ tion approximately $00 politica) prisoners. We Jnuw that some 700 are housed .at ‘the relatively modern Reporting fron: the US : number of detainees. The establishment of an amnesty comthission also is being considered to oversee the Droader issue -of ascmilating guerrilla defectors inte the political and economic mainstream as one phase of a democratic solution to the insurgent war. A seven- amember human rights commission was appointed ia early December, charged with formulating an “insti- tutional mechanism that will promote and protect human zights "fep= 3S. The ansurgent var has intensified ace qulys and - the rate-of combat deaths on -both sides has increased. -_ The sate of civilian political deaths, however, has continued to decline-rnarkedly.’ The monthly averages eof-political deaths in 196] was about 510,-but for 1982 - dt dropped to 2}7—a dectease of S7 percent. Since : - Julythe death rate bes dropped mmoze than-40 percent - i. drom thatec! the fests anonths of 1982. ee, Control xt athe genes Forces ~Isachieving subs‘antia) contro! over. a elements - sof dts -own aimed Jarces”™” =. For example, the genera! staff rernains dargely © Marions Prison outside the capital. These prisoners _ ineffective in promoting ‘fire contro} among corbat ange in status from -captured guerrillas to Jeftist — inits although some improvement: shove deen made jnteliectuals suspected of subversion. According to LS Eanbassy officers who have visited the prisoners, they are well Jed ane zeceive excellent treatment, including -

Read the complete text