Results of Photo Comparison, Case no. 12,769

Central Intelligence Agency · 1971

Read Results of Photo Comparison, Case no. 12,769 by Central Intelligence Agency (1971) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000022664.txt.

Introduction

Photo comparison case number 12,769 has its results kept in a CIA record dated in 1971. The case sits one number below another result filed the same year. Numbered in the twelve thousands, these cases show the sheer scale of the picture matching effort. Behind each number stood a missing man, a family, and a folder of faces.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1971
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE3593
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000022664

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

DATE: § April 1971

MEMORANDUM FOR: Capt. C. E. Redman, AFINE

SUBJECT : Results of Photo Comparison,
Case No. 12,769

REFERENCE : Request from NOK of Major Richard r. Allee

i. Transmitted herewith are results of photo compari-
son analysis between the Christmas 1969 film of American

PWs in North Vietnam and photographs submitted with refer-
ence,

Zz. The evidence cited in the attached report does not
constitute definitive proof of the status or identity of
individuals portrayed in the questioned photographs,

3. Since the Agency's participation in this program
is classified, the fact of such participation must not be
revealed. This report, therefore, may not be used in an
unclassified arena, and the Agency cannot be responsible
for any action or decision based in whole or in part on the
Judgments expressed in the report.

4. All materials received from your office in connection
with subject request are returned herewith, .

.

eo Attachments:
(1) Christmas 1969 comparison No. -
(2) Materials submitted with request:
(a) Overlay
(b)

ts precapture photos +/ fy:
(c) Others tt

ra

OOO |}

ee a gh i ce eS

Date of Report: S$ April 1972

PHOTO COMPARISON ANALYSES RESULTS: Christmas 1969 No.

1. (Uj) Summary of request: (Date received: )

ue

a. Please compare the attached pre-capture .photo-

|
graphs of Majo. ; with the
Christmas reed Fifa abratne y Representative Zion,
especially prints numbered DEA USN

USAF 24, 36,+37

b. See attached overlay for exact location of image to
be compared. os

2. (U) Summary of comparison performed:

a. “The following frames were chosen for comparison with

the photographs submitted: — .
b. technicians working independently of each

oF €r analyzed the identifiable features listed

e low.

Results of analysis:

a. (U) Quatity of pre-capture photographs submitted:
Adequate/ixxdagaxte for analysis of recognizable
features, oS

;
b. (U) Quality of frames in Christmas film: Adequate/.
sanidagquxka for analysis of recognizable features.

The following features were considered similar:

(t) | Occipital ridgo ss
C2): 0 Wate dine
(3). shut shape Se
(4) __Nose shape

-

haga es, Me

PO ol la
Swat hele

= oe ad
pee

- . @ pe ee
a a ag die :
a eee ne ee —_ ——— Se ~ 5

= er er na marine opm reme OE Tae = - _
—_— ry id =

a

we

(5) os ee eee

OES seal ca aaa a ee

{7)
(8)

(9) :

The following features were considered dis-
similar:

(1)

. WES ecb asthe it cect At ee AAs ees ot ea

(3) os Fa Se ee

a (4) ee eee
(5) =
e. Conclusion:
' (1) In view of the similarity in general
appearance and significant number of
Similar features,
could be the subject of the questioned
photographs, :
(2) Im view of the significant number of
differences in distinguishable features,
probably is not
a the subject of the questioned photo- a
5 graphs.
: («)) In view of the quality of photography =
and the small number of distinguishable

features which could be compared, no
conclusion can be reached.

f. (U) The same image has been compared with pre-
capture photographs of Air Forc¢e,
Navy, Marine, Aray,

and. —ss—isi(séCAATYYan Personnel.

ee ee

—.-

: _ @ 23-2 eee
. rae a : _——
me ne 5
peerrree rout :
os Sd 5 . .

.
. ror =
or rs

D.

od

g- Comments: Although there appear to be the
Similarities Noted, the picture quality
(Christmas film) makes a definite conclusion
impossible,

Yr overriding
ualts case

rm Or invalidate the photo
comparison analysis,

Attachments:

(a) Post-capture Photographs, with Overlay or other exact
identification of image to

be compared:
(b) Pre-capture photographs:
sed

Read the complete text