Results of Photo Comparison Case no. BlankK)
Central Intelligence Agency · 1971
Read Results of Photo Comparison Case no. BlankK) by Central Intelligence Agency (1971) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000022532.txt.
Introduction
Results of a photo comparison, case number blank in the released title, fill a CIA record dated in 1971. The missing number was cut or left empty before release. Photo comparison matched faces in enemy pictures against missing Americans, case by case. A result without its number is half a record, yet the finding itself was still worth keeping on file.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Central Intelligence Agency |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1971 |
| COLLECTION | DECLASSIFIED |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 4343 |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Internet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror |
Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000022532
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
*
DATE: _14 December 1971 :
MEMORANDUM FOR: Capt. Charles Redman :
SUBJECT / Results of Photo Comparison,
Case No. :
REFERENCE ; Request from NOK of Frederick M. Hall
1. ° Transmitted herewith are results of photo compari-
son analysis between the Christmas 1969 film of American
Ps in North Vietnam and photograpas submitted with refer-
ence,
2. the evidence cited ‘n the attached report does not
constitute definitive proof of the status nr identity of o
individuals portrayed in the questioned photographs.
3. Since the Agency's participation in this program
is classified, the fact of such participation must not be
revealed. This report, therefore, may not be used in an
unclassified arena, and the Agency cannot be responsible
for any action oT decision based in whole or in part on the
judgments expressed in the report.
4, All materials yeceived from your effice in connection
with subject request are yeturned herewith.
CTA Rep.
Attachments: a
(1) Christmas 1969 comparison No.
(2} Materials submitted with request:
{a} Overlay
{b) 6 precapture photos re a
(c) Gther: : p na
APPROVED =
Date HEP FoR RELEASE -
y
PHOTO COMPARISON ANALYSIS RESULTS: Christmas 1969 No,
Date of Report: 44 December 1371.
1. (U) Summary of request: (Date received: )
a. Please compare the attached 6. -~pre-capture photo-
graphs of Frederick M. Hail "swith the
Christmas 1969 film obtained by Representative Zion,
especially prints numbered DIA USN
Sce attached overlay for exact locaticn of image to
be compared, .
Sunmary of comparison performed:
The following frames were chosen for comparison, with
the photographs submitted: _ _ Ses a eet
w_... technicians working independently of each
other analyzed the identifiable features listed
helow, a
Results of anal ‘sis:
(VU) Quality of pre-capture photographs submitted:
Adequate/inadequate for analysis of recognizable
features.
(U} Quality of frames in Christmas film: Adequate/
inadequate for analysis of recognizable features.
The foliowing features were considered similar:
(1)
5) Seater eee eR aed AML EOE SS EN ET PTR DAS ee
1) Sa aa PNA cena
ON falas! 2 Scots tae teat a base
AC) eee an ne ea
CTE eT Oe Cn ee _
The following features were considered dis-
Similar:
i sate ag ae een See
3) eee eee TR ORE eee Tere eee we
Oe ele acta tsa eater eed i
2 eee TE a ee ee Re
BS athe ees la SIN Se ee otal ee,
Conclusion:
(1} In view of the similarity in general
, appearance and significant number of
Similar features, a
could be the subject of the questionéd
photographs.
(2) In view of the significant number of
(3) In view of the quality of photography
and the small number of distinguishable
features which could be compared, no
conclusion can be reached.
The same image has been compared with pre-
capture photographs of ss Air Force,
ee Nay, _. Marine, sss Army,
and _. civilian personnel, :
®
rs
.
gout 4 te aks de a ae 2g"
#. Comments: Prederick M. Hall photo comparison
case: Images USAF 84-1, 85-1, and 86-1 from the 1969
Christmas film have been positively identified as Capt.
Gary R. Sigler, USAF. Careful examination of these
photos convinces us that they were taken in the Protestant
service. Jmage 16-7 is inadequate for comparison analysis,
but we believe that it is again an image of Captain Sigler.
Images 92-2 and 93-2 are of an individual in the Catholic
service. Carefully tracing this image throughout the film
leads to the conclusion that it is identical with much_
clearer images of an individual wearing the PW identifi-
cation number 2-233 but seen from the back. Aithough the
individual has not yet been identified, we feel reasonably
certain it is not Captain Sigler. The image 107-1 is of
an-individual in the Catholic service. We feel reasonably
certain it is Lt.Col. Albert E. Runyan, USAF, who has been
positively identified from image 97-1.
S
WARNING: This photo comparison analysis was
performed utilizing the best available tech-
niques; however, the quality of the photo-
; graphs in question precluded positive iden-
: tification. There may be other cverriding
factors concerning the individeal's case
which could confirm or invalidate the photo
comparison analysis.
Attachments:
(a) Post-capture photographs, with overlay or other exact
identification of image to be compared:
(b}) Pre-capture photographs: ;