Comments and Suggestions of Ufo Panel PubdD Is Unknown)

Central Intelligence Agency · 1953

Read Comments and Suggestions of Ufo Panel PubdD Is Unknown) by Central Intelligence Agency (1953) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/cia-0000015458.txt.

Introduction

Comments and suggestions from the UFO panel fill an undated CIA item filed in 1953. The panel was a group of scientists asked to judge the saucer evidence for the government. Their added remarks show experts refining what should be done next. Even without a firm date in the catalog, the entry holds the tone of that first official review and its advice.

Catalog record

CREATORCentral Intelligence Agency
YEAR1953
COLLECTIONDECLASSIFIED
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28400
VERSION1.0
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEInternet Archive — CIA Reading Room mirror

Source: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-0000015458

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS OF UFO PANEL General. The Panel Members were impressed with the Lack of. 0.02 00 sound data in the-great-majority of case histories. Among ~~ the case histories of significant sightings discussed in. -! detail were the following? Bellefoutaine, Ohio {1 August 1952); Tremonton,-Utab -.2- 2 2 te (2 July 1952); Great_Falls, Monvana_ (15 Auzust 1950);. - Yaak, Montana (1 September 1952); Washington, D.C. “area (19 July 1952); and Haneda A.F.B., Japan -. (5 August 1952), Port-Ruron, Michigan. (29 July..1952);.. _- and Presque Isle, Maine (10 October 1952).. After review and discussion of these-cases: (and about oo 15 others, in less detail), the Panel concluded that reasonable explanations ¢ould-be suggested for most sight~ -- 9 2) ts ings and “py deduction and scientific method it could be induced (given additional-data) that other cases might be explained in a similar manner”. . The Panel_pointed out that beeause of the brevity.of some sightings (e.g.,.2-3 senonas) and the inability of the witnesses to ences themselves clearly (semantics) that conclusive explanations could not be expected for every case reported. Furthermore, it was considered that, normally, it would be a great waste of effort to try to solve most of the sightings, unless such — COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS OF UFO PANEL General. The Panel Members were impressed with the lack of sound data in the great majority of case histories. . Among _. the case histories of significant sightings discussed in detail were the following: Bellefontaine, Ohio (1 August 1952); Tremonton,-Utah” > (2 July 1952); Great Falls, Monvana (15 August 1950); Yaak, Montana (1. September 1952); Washington, D.C. . area (19 July -1952); and Haneda-A.FP.B., Japan .. ..=. ---.-(5 August 1952), Port Huron, Michigan (29 July. 1952); 0. 0.22. 0 22n 0s and Presque Isle, Maine—(10 October 1952). After review and discussion “of these cases (and about” 15 others, in less detail), the Panel concluded that. 00-050 2.0 L802. ane reasonable explanations could be suggested for most sight~ ings and "by deduction and scientific method it could be = -s.e::25 25 stein induced (given additional data) that.other cases might be explained in a similar manner",~ The Patel pointed out that. --~ because of the brevity of some Sightings (e.g.,' 2-3 seconds)— and the inability of the witnesses to express themselves 7 clearly (semantics) that-conclusiva explanations could not—~ be expected for every case reported. Furthermore, it was” 07 considered that, normally, it would be a great waste ee ee ee effort to try to solve most of the Sightings, unless such eer e | | believed to be electrostatic (similar to St. Elmo's fire): eee ers action would benefit a training and educational program - (see below). The writings of Charlés Fort were referenced -- to show that "strange things in the sky" had been recorded © for hundreds of years. It appeared obvious that there was no single explanation for a majority of the things seen. ._. “Qn Lack of Danger. = ee The Panel-concluded unanimously that there was no evidenea of a direct_threat_to national security in the .__. objects sighted. Instances of "Foo Fighters" were cited. These were unexplained: phenomena sighted by aircraft pilots during World War IJ in both European and Far East theaters of operation wherein "balls of light” would fly near or with the aircraft-and maneuver rapidiy. They were or electromagnetic phenomena or possibly light reflections from ice crystals in.the air, but their exact cause or nature was never-defined. If the term "Rlying saucers" _ had been popular-in 1943-1945, thése objects would have. been so labeled. — ae ee Air Force Reporting System. It was the Panel's opinion that some of the Air Force oo concern over UFO's (notwithstanding Air Defense Command anxiety over fast radar. tracks) was probably caused by public pressure. The result. today 4s.that the Air Force 2 -——-——- . se A eli MPN ns te OE a Me a At “Wun Gen “s : ae @ has instituted a fine channel for receiving reports of nearly anything anyone sees in the sky and fails to under- stand. This has-been-particularly- encouraged in popular articles on this and other subjects, such as space travel and science fiction. The result is the mass receipt of — low-grade reports which tend to overload channels of communication-with material quite irrelevant to hostile = = _.__. objects that might some day appéar. “The Panel_agreed ss generally that this mass of poor-quality reports containing the opposite, it was possibly _dangerous in having a military service foster public concern-in "nocturnal meandering lights". The implication being, since the interested. ___. agency was military, that. these objects were or might be Little, if any, scientific data was of no value. Quite 20. potential direct threats to national security. Accordingly, _ the need for deemphasization made itself apparent. Comments on a possible educational program are enumerated below. It was the Opinion of one of the Panel members-that the "saucer' problem had been _folind to be different in nature from the_detection and investigation’ of Geran vV-1. and V-2 guided missiles prior to their operational use-in-...--- World War II; ~In this 1943-1944 intelligence operation (CROSSBOW), there was excellent intelligence, and by June grace: once. < wer? ab Orage 1944 there was material evidence of the. existence of "hardware" obtained from crashed vehicles in Sweden. This , evidence gave the investigating team a basis upon which to... operate. The absence of any "hardware" resulting from __ unexplained UFO sightings lends a "will-of-the-wisp" nature to the problem. The results of the investigation, to-date, strongly indicate that no evidence of hostile act or... danger exists. -Purthermore ,the- current reporting ‘systen-— would have little value in the case of detection of enemy attack by conventional aircraft or guided missiles;-under such conditions-"hardware” would be available almost at fn BES ae ke de Fe aaa Artifacts of Extraterrestial” Origin. __ It was interesting to note that none of the members of the Panel were loath to accept that. ass ‘earth might be ak om visited by ‘extraterrestrial intelligened beings of sone” ae sort, some day. What they did not find was any evidence that related the objects sighted to space travelers. One of the Panel.members, in his presentation, showed how he had eliminated each of the known and probable causes of Sightings: leaving him "extra-terrestial” as the only one _ remaining in many cases. His— background as an aeronaut- ical engineer and technical intelligence” officer could not be slighted. However, the panel. could not accept any of “4 the cases cited by him because they were raw, unevaluated reports. Térréstrial explanations of. the sightings were suggested in-some cases, and in others the tine of sighting was so short as to cause Suspicion of visual impressions i> >= 75> 7" It was noted by others _of the Panel members that extra= terrestrial artifacts, if_they did exist, are no cause for &larm; rather, they ara-in. the realm of. natural phenonena_ a subject ta scientific study, just_as cosmic rays were at 20-202 the time of their discovery_20 to 30 years ago: This was >>" = an attitude in which another of the Panel members did not .__. . concur, as he felt that _suco artifacts would be of immediate... -- and great concern not only to the

Read the complete text