Greek Rites (Catholic Encyclopedia article)

Adrian Fortescue · 1913

Read Greek Rites (Catholic Encyclopedia article) by Adrian Fortescue (1913) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/catholic-encyclopedia-1913-greek-rites.txt.

Introduction

Greek Rites is an article insisting that rite, language, and religion are three things always kept apart. A rite is a set order of words and acts for the Eucharist, the Hours, and other sacraments and sacramentals. A Catholic Encyclopedia article shows why language is no clue to rite.

The Roman and Gallican Uses are both written in Latin yet are completely different rites. The Roman Rite stays Roman in Old Slavonic in Dalmatia or in Greek in Italy. In the East nearly all liturgies were originally written in Greek, and even the Armenian, Nestorian, and Abyssinian exceptions are modified derivations from Greek originals. At the head of all Eastern liturgies stand the foundations of Alexandria and Antioch.

Catalog record

CREATORAdrian Fortescue
YEAR1913
COLLECTIONREFERENCE
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
LICENSEPUBLIC_DOMAIN
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCENew Advent — Catholic Encyclopedia (1913)

Source: https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06774a.htm

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rite, language, religion These are three things that must always be distinguished. A rite is a certain uniform arrangement of formulæ and ceremonies used for the Holy Eucharist , the Canonical Hours, the administration of other sacraments and sacramentals . These offices, as far as we know , have never been performed in the same way throughout Christendom . There are now, apparently there always have been, different rites, equally legitimate, used in different places both by Catholics and other Christians . Obviously each rite was originally composed in some language. But rite is not language; the various rites cannot be classified according to their languages. There are many different rites in the same language; on the other hand the same rite, remaining the same in every detail, is constantly translated. Thus, in the West, the Roman and Gallican Uses are both written in Latin, but they are completely different rites. The Roman Rite is used in Dalmatia in an Old Slavonic version (written in Glagolitic letters), occasionally in Greek in Italy ; but in any language it is always the Roman Rite . In the East this want of correspondence between rite and language is still more remarkable. Except those of the Armenians , Nestorians , and Abyssinians , all Eastern liturgies were originally written in Greek. Even the exceptions are only modified derivations from Greek originals. If, then, we take the language in which a rite was originally composed as our test, we must describe all Eastern liturgies as Greek. Indeed, the two great Western parent rites (of Rome and Gaul) represent, as a matter of fact, modified developments from Greek originals too. So we should come to the conclusion that every rite in the Church , every historic liturgy in Christendom is a Greek Rite. If, on the other hand, we make our test present use in the Greek language, we must separate the Byzantine Liturgy said in Greek at Constantinople from what is word for word the same service said in Old Slavonic at St. Petersburg. It is clear then that language is no clue as to rite. At the head of all Eastern liturgies , foundations of two great classes, are the Liturgies of Alexandria and Antioch. They are not only different rites, their difference underlies the fundamental distinction by which we divide all others into two main groups; and both are Greek. And the same Byzantine Liturgy is used unchanged in about fourteen different languages. A second false criterion that must be eliminated is that of religion . It would be convenient for classification if members of each Church used the same rite different from that of any other Church. But this is by no means the case. The historic origin and legal position of the various rites is a much more complicated question. Catholics , joined of course entirely by the same faith , obeying the same laws (though in details there are different laws for different branches of the Church ), united visibly to the same great hierarchy under the supreme rule of the pope at Rome , are divided according to rite, so that every Eastern liturgy is used by some of them. The same liturgies (but for a few modifications made by the Roman authorities in the interest of dogma ) are shared by the various schismatical Churches. Indeed, Catholics and Schismatics often use the same books. The Orthodox Church , that has for many centuries aimed at an ideal of uniformity in the Byzantine Rite (in different languages), till the thirteenth century used those of Alexandria and Antioch too. Now she has restored the Antiochene Liturgy for certain rare occasions, and there are signs that the Alexandrine Rite may soon be restored too. Other schismatical bodies have, it is true , each its own rite, though this rite generally contains alternative liturgies . It will be seen then that these three points are three quite different questions that must not be confused. In the case of any Christian bishop or priest we may ask: what is his Church or sect , what rite does he use and in what language? And the answers may represent all kinds of combinations. A Catholic may use the Roman Rite in Old Slavonic, the Alexandrine Rite in Coptic, the Byzantine in Georgian. An Orthodox priest may use the Byzantine Rite in Arabic or Japanese . The essential note of a rite We have seen then that neither its language nor the sect of people who use it can be taken as essential to a rite. The real note that defines it is the place where it was composed. All rites had their origin in some one place or city that was an ecclesiastical centre for the country round. After the service had been put together and used here, by a natural process of imitation churches around began to copy the order observed in the great town. The greater the influence of the city where the rite arose, the more widely the rite spread. It was not a question of inherent advantages. No one thought of choosing the rite that seemed most edifying or beautiful or suitable. People simply copied their chief. The rites were formed at first in the patriarchal cities: Rome , Alexandria, Antioch , Constantinople. Jerusalem had already given hers to Antioch. The bishops of each patriarchate naturally thought that they could not do better than celebrate the holy mysteries in the same way as their patriarch. We know in the West how, long before there were any laws on the subject, every one began to copy what was done at Rome . It seemed safest to follow Rome in the matter. The Frankish Church in the eighth century gave up the Gallican Rite , and adopted that of the patriarchal see. The "Liber sacramentorum Romanæ Ecclesiæ" spread throughout Western Europe till it had displaced all other uses, except in one or two remote districts. We see the same tendency at work still — uniformity in accordance with Roman customs, even in such details as the shape of vestments and the pronunciation of Latin. So it was in the East with regard to their patriarchal sees . Local customs are gradually suppressed in favour of the patriarch's way of doing things. Schisms and heresies accentuate this uniformity among Catholics . It was a sign of adherence to the Catholic centre — Alexandria, Constantinople, or whichever it might be — to agree entirely with it in rite. Lastly come laws determining this tendency; and so we have the principle that (with exceptions) obtains still throughout Christendom , namely: "Rite follows Patriarchate". The Roman Rite is used throughout the Roman patriarchate , by the clergy subject to the pope as their patriarch, and only by them; the Alexandrine Rite belongs to Egypt — where the patriarch of Alexandria has jurisdiction ; that of Antioch to Syria ; that of Constantinople to the Byzantine territory. The National Nestorian (East-Syrian) and Armenian patriarchates have their own rites. Such was the principle for many centuries everywhere. Except for the two remnants of other Western rites at Milan and Toledo, it may still be taken as a

Read the complete text