On the Crania and Bones of Les Eyzies; or, The Ancient Cave-Men of the Périgord
Paul Broca · 1868
Read On the Crania and Bones of Les Eyzies; or, The Ancient Cave-Men of the Périgord by Paul Broca (1868) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/broca-eyzies-1868.txt.
Introduction
Paul Broca, a French surgeon and sage of the brain, wrote this memoir on the Eyzies finds in 1868. The text here is the English version of his report. Work men in the Perigord had found five frames in a rock shelter that year.
The frames were the first Cro-Magnon men known to science, tall and fine boned. Broca set out their skulls and bones with care and told how they stand to living races. The paper is the first learned word on the Cro-Magnon folk, our own kind in the ice age.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paul Broca |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1868 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Internet Archive |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Crania and Bones of Les Eyzies; or, The Ancient Cave-Men of the Périgord (Paul Broca, 1868) ================================================================================================== Broca's 1868 Eyzies memoir in English — the first scientific description of the Cro-Magnon skeletons. Public domain. Source: Internet Archive (jstor-3025031) — Anthropological Review, October 1868. 408 ANTHROPOLOGICAL REVIEW. by the aid of a language he has made his own ; all animals do the same. He can articulate sounds ; other animals can imitate sounds as well as he can. He presents simply in this respect a greater develop- ment of a faculty common to all social animals. ON THE CRANIA AND BONES OF LES EYZIES; Oil, THE ANCIENT CAVE-MEN OF PERIGORD.* By Prof. Paul Broca, Secretary-General of the Anthropological Society of Paris, and Honorary Fellow of the Anthropological Society of London. No discovery could offer more interest to Anthropology than that of these bones. It is the complement — one would almost say the crowning work — of the important discoveries which Mr. Lartet, sen., and his much lamented fellow-labourer, M. Christy, made four years ago in the caverns of Perigord. The numerous objects found in these caverns have not only furnished to us the most incontestible and striking proofs of the contemporaneity of man with the mammoth, but they have revealed to us the most curious details of the life and customs of the ancient cave-men of Perigord. The anatomical cha- racteristics of the intelligent and artistic race, whose admirable carv- ings and sculptures are to us a subject of astonishment, yet, however, remain to be disclosed to us. The latest researches in Les Eyzies cave, by M. Lartet, jun., permit us now to bridge this gap. No doubt can be raised as to the authenticity and high antiquity of the bones which these researches have brought to light. The stratigraphical details furnished by this gentleman, prove not only that they are as ancient as, but that they are even more ancient than the carved objects of the great cavern of Les Eyzies ; the latter correspond to the eptoch in which the reindeer was already predominant among the fauna, while the former seem to approximate rather to the time of the mam- moth ; and although a very long period between these two epochs might have elapsed, we are compelled to believe that the passage from one to the other took place gradually, without any ethnographical revolution ; that the same race remained without interruption in the same place ; and that, if the bones which we are about to examine, are not those of the artistes of the reindeer period, they are at least those of their ancestors. The remains of quaternary man that we * This article is the most important part of a long Memoir by Prof. Broca, which will appear in Lartet's and Christy's Reliqmce Aquitanicw. BROCA ON THE CRANIA AND BONES OP LES EYZIES. 409 have examined hitherto, belong for the most part to individuals of short statiu-e, in whom the cranium is of small capacity, and the face more or less prognathous. We should hence conclude that the primi- tive population of Europe either belonged to a Negroid or Mongoloid race (according to either hypothesis), in whom the stature did not much exceed that of the modern Laplanders. We consider that this opinion rests on well-ascertained facts. It rests also on a pre- conceived idea which we have for a long time opposed, viz., that there is in quaternary Europe only one single race of men. Based on the ethnographical theory that the diversity of the human race results from the influence of media (such as climate, food, soil, etc.) we admit that the typical differences must be effaced as we pass backwards in time ; and when the polygenists objected that the separation of the principal groups of races was already complete from the origin of his- toric time, we replied, that it was not in very recent times, but in the immense and incalculable periods which preceded them, that the divergencies from the original type were manifested. Reduced to these terms, the question of the unity of the human race became ad- journed to the moment when palceontology should have discovered some remains of primitive man, or at least those of races of the qua- tenary epoch. We should consider that these races, separated from us by thousands of ages perhaps, and of a certainty infinitely more approximated to the human origines than the most ancient of the his- toric races, must present, if not an absolute uniformity, at least a manifest convergance towards the type of the common mould in which we can conceive them to have been cast. But it happens here, as does so frequently happen in other things, that the facts brought to light contradict a pre-conceived theory. The quaternary race of Les Eyzies, differs from the quaternary race of the caverns of Belgium, as much as the most dissimilar modern races differ among themselves. The contrast is complete, not only when we consider the conformation and volume of the head, but also when we consider the form and dimensions of the limb bones. The greater part of the bones which have been discovered belong to three individuals. There are three crania, of which one is perfect. Not one of the skeletons is capable of being put together, but in closing the bones of the trunk and of the members, in accordance with their shape, colour, and density, we are able to separate them chiefly into three groups, which, in respect of the character referred to, appear to belong to the three crania. There are, besides, some small fragments of a cranium belonging to an adult, and some others of one belonging to a child. The number of bodies deposited in this burying place was five ; it can hardly be said that there were more. It is, therefore, not VOL. vi. — no. xxin. 2 F 410 ANTHROPOLOGICAL REVIEW. impossible that all these individuals should have been members of one family. Of the relics of these five persons, we can only speak of three, the remains of the two others being represented by only insignificant fragments. The author then minutely described the character of each of the bones, and said, if, in conclusion, we cast a general glance over the divers elements that we have just examined, we shall find in the race of Les Eyzies a remarkable combination of characters — some of supe- riority and some of inferiority. The great capacity of the brain, the development of the frontal region, the fine elliptical form of the ante- rior part of the profile of the skull, the orthographic disposition of the superior facial region (from which arises a considerable enlargement of the facial angle of Camper) are incontestable characteristics of supe- riority such as we are accustomed to meet with only in civilised races. On the other hand, the great breadth of the face, the alveolar pro- gnathism, the enormous development of the ascending ramus of the jaw, the extent and roughness of the surfaces for the insertion of muscles, and especially of the masticators, lead to the idea of a savage and