Constraining dark energy with complementary probes of large-scale structure

Neel Shah, Kazuya Koyama, Johannes Noller, Lanyang Yi · 2026

Read Constraining dark energy with complementary probes of large-scale structure by Neel Shah, Kazuya Koyama, Johannes Noller, Lanyang Yi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31977.txt.

Introduction

Shah and three colleagues constrain dark energy by combining expansion-history probes with several probes of large-scale structure. The framework is the effective field theory of dark energy, which parametrizes how dark energy perturbs structure growth alongside the background expansion. Expansion data alone leave the perturbation parameters loosely pinned.

Adding redshift-space distortions from DESI, three-by-two-point measurements from DES, and Integrated Sachs-Wolfe cross-correlations sharpens the picture markedly. The figure of merit for the two perturbation parameters improves by a factor of 2.69 for the strongest combination in their analysis, and by 3.37 for the mapped present-day functions. Deviation from the standard cosmological model registers at 2.9 sigma for this framework on the baseline data.

Catalog record

CREATORNeel Shah, Kazuya Koyama, Johannes Noller, Lanyang Yi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE89 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31977

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraining dark energy with complementary probes of large-scale structure Neel Shah, Kazuya Koyama, Johannes Noller, Lanyang Yi Abstract To observationally pin down the nature of dark energy, it is essential to consistently model cosmological perturbations in the presence of dark energy alongside the background expansion and constrain this joint theory space with a large array of complementary probes. Here, we achieve this by constraining a model in the Effective Field Theory of Dark Energy (EFTofDE) framework by supplementing probes of the expansion history with several probes of large-scale structure: redshift space distortions (RSD) from DESI DR1, 3 × 2 3\times 2 pt measurements from DES Y3, and the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect from cross-correlating CMB temperature anisotropies with galaxy number counts or CMB lensing. We demonstrate the complementarity of different probes which leads to strong improvements on constraints on DE perturbations. For our most constraining dataset combination that supplements CMB+BAO+SNe probes with DESI DR1 RSD, DES Y3 3 × 2 3\times 2 pt and ISW cross-correlations between CMB temperature and galaxy counts, we find an improvement in the Figure of Merit (FoM) for the DE perturbation parameters { c B , c M } \{c_{B},c_{M}\} by a factor of 2.69. We show the phenomenological implications of these constraints by mapping them to the present-day values of the phenomenological functions { μ ⁡ ( z ) , Σ ⁡ ( z ) } \{\mu(z),\Sigma(z)\} , where we see an FoM improvement by a factor of 3.37. We find a significant interdependence between the posteriors of { w 0 , w a } \{w_{0},w_{a}\} and { c B , c M } \{c_{B},c_{M}\} , caused by the theoretical prior imposed by the gradient stability condition within the EFTofDE framework. Finally, we compute the significance of deviation from Λ \Lambda CM for the EFTofDE model when constrained with CMB+BAO+SNe datasets, finding it to be at 2.9 σ \sigma . This significance is nontrivially similar to the significance for the w 0 ​ w a w_{0}w_{a} CDM model for the same dataset combination which we find to be 3.1 σ \sigma . I Introduction Identifying the nature of dark energy (DE) has been one of the core pursuits in cosmology ever since the discovery of the accelerated expansion of the universe 128 ; 118 , and this pursuit has been renewed due to recent observational hints for dynamical DE 131 ; 7 ; 12 ; 97 ; 9 ; 10 ; 98 ; 123 ; 78 . The main phenomenological avenue for looking for dynamical DE signatures has been the background cosmic expansion history. The most well-established probes of the cosmic background expansion are the cosmic microwave background (CMB), baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO), and Type IA supernovae (SNe), with current state-of-the-art constraints coming from e.g. 14 ; 100 ; 42 ; 7 ; 12 ; 10 ; 39 ; 131 ; 9 ; 123 ; 78 . Constraints on dynamical DE signatures on the evolution of cosmic large-scale structure (LSS) are less explored and have scope to be improved by employing already existing LSS observations. Dynamical DE signatures on the evolution of cosmological perturbations contain further information about the microphysics of DE and are closely related to signatures of modified gravity. There is a wide variety of probes that constrain cosmological perturbations: CMB lensing, redshift space distortions (RSD), weak gravitational lensing, the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect, peculiar velocities, and more (see e.g. 15 ; 104 ; 68 ; 11 ; 153 ; 8 ; 43 ; 125 ; 92 ; 124 for recent cosmological constraints). A particularly useful framework for constraining the presence of dynamical dark energy systematically is the effective field theory of dark energy (EFTofDE) 73 ; 34 ; 70 ; 29 ; 71 (essentially equivalent to the Horndeski class of modified gravity theories on a cosmological background 76 ; 46 ; 58 ; 86 ) and related constructions (e.g. 90 ; 89 ), that parametrise a wide class of theoretically well-motivated models of dark energy – typically with a focus on linear perturbations, although non-linear extensions of these approaches exist, see e.g. 85 ; 144 ; 54 ; 37 ; 19 ; 138 . This complements more phenomenological approaches that e.g. parametrise modified gravity effects by explicitly modifying the Poisson-like equations relating the matter density perturbations to the Newtonian potential (which affects clustering of nonrelativistic matter) or the Weyl potential (which affects gravitational lensing of photons) 41 ; 20 ; 80 ; 82 ; 30 ; 156 ; 122 ; 155 ; 137 . These phenomenological modifications can likewise be computed in EFTofDE approaches, so the EFTofDE can be used as a theoretical prior in deriving such phenomenological parametrisations as well (e.g. 116 ; 114 ; 63 ; 136 ). We will primarily use the EFTofDE framework here – specifically we will work in the \alpha -basis pioneered by 29 ; 71 , which can be straightforwardly mapped to other related approaches. We will also link this to the phenomenological functions \{\mu,\Sigma\} described later. Recently, analyses focusing on deriving EFTofDE constraints by combining multiple recent LSS datasets (on top of the standard CMB+BAO+SNe probes of the background expansion) have started to appear: e.g. 135 , which obtains constraints combining CMB-galaxy cross-correlations probing the ISW effect and RSD measurements from BOSS and 6dF; 81 , which combines DESI DR1 full shape measurements with 3\times 2\text{pt} data from DES Y3; 143 , which combines cosmic shear from KiDS-Legacy with RSD from eBOSS; 103 , which combines CMB lensing and ISW-lensing cross-correlations from Planck PR4, full-shape information from BOSS, and photometric clustering data from DESI Legacy Imaging Survey DR9; and 95 , which combines gravitational potential decay rates measured from DESI photometric clustering and Planck, the lensing-inferred amplitude of matter perturbations from cross-correlation of Planck anisotropies with galaxy surveys, and growth rate measurements from DESI DR1 clustering and the DESI DR1 peculiar velocity survey. In this work, we derive constraints on the EFTofDE perturbations and background expansion by supplementing the CMB+BAO+SNe combination with RSD measurements from DESI DR1 98 , weak lensing 3\times 2\text{pt} measurements from DES Y3 6 , and ISW measurements from CMB-galaxy cross-correlations 142 and CMB tempertaure-lensing cross-correlations 44 ; 43 . We present constraints from various combinations of these datasets to demonstrate the complementarity of these probes. Furthermore, we demonstrate and quantify how the posteriors of the background expansion and DE perturbations affect other due to the underlying physics of the gradient stability condition in the EFTofDE, and how this affects the observational significance of dynamical DE over a cosmological constant. Outline : This paper is organised as follows. We introduce the underlying theoretical EFTofDE framework we are using, as well as its relation to the phenomenological \{\mu,\Sigma\} functions in Section II . This is followed by a detailed description of the datasets and likelihoods we are using in Section III . In Section IV we then present constraints obtained from various combinations of probes, discuss their complementarity and what these constraints mean for DE phenomenology. In Section V we then focus specifically on the interplay between constraints on the DE background ( \{w_{0},w_{a}\} ) and perturbation ( \{c_{B},c_{M}\} ) parameters, and evaluate the observational significance of deviation from \Lambda\text{CDM} in

Read the complete text