The contact temperature of arbitrary quantum states
Alain Joye, Marco Merkli · 2026
Read The contact temperature of arbitrary quantum states by Alain Joye, Marco Merkli (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31969.txt.
Introduction
Joye and Merkli define a temperature for arbitrary quantum states through physical contact with a thermometer. Temperature is no problem for Gibbs equilibrium states, but a general state of a quantum system sits far from equilibrium and carries no obvious temperature. Earlier proposals match average energy or use the slope of entropy, without a direct operational test.
Their universal thermometer is prepared in a Gibbs state at some inverse temperature, then coupled to the system in any state. For exactly one thermometer setting, the heat flow between system and thermometer vanishes identically. That unique setting is declared the contact temperature of the state under study. One fixed thermometer model works for arbitrary states of finite-dimensional quantum systems. This gives an operational meaning to temperature far from equilibrium.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alain Joye, Marco Merkli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 102 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31969
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The contact temperature of arbitrary quantum states Alain Joye, Marco Merkli Abstract An intuitive scheme to assign a temperature to an arbitrary state of a quantum system is to investigate the heat flow resulting from the coupling to a thermometer. We introduce a simple model of a universal thermometer with the following property. When it is prepared in a Gibbs equilibrium state at inverse temperature β ∈ ℝ \beta\in\mathbb{R} and brought into thermal contact with a system in any state, the heat flow between the system and thermometer vanishes for a unique value of β \beta . We call this value the contact temperature β c ∈ ℝ \beta_{\rm c}\in\mathbb{R} of the system state. The thermometer is universal in that it yields a unique contact temperature for arbitrary states of finite dimensional quantum systems. 1 Introduction The equilibrium state of a quantum system whose dynamics is generated by a Hamiltonian H is given by the Gibbs density matrix \gamma_{\beta}=\frac{e^{-\beta H}}{{\rm Tr}\,e^{-\beta H}}\,, where \beta\in\mathbb{R} is the (inverse) equilibrium temperature. The Gibbs density matrix is obtained as the maximizer of the entropy under the constraint of a fixed mean energy. Different approaches have been proposed to extend the notion of temperature to general quantum states \rho , see the review [ 4 ] . Among them is the effective temperature \beta^{*} of \rho defined as the Gibbs equilibrium temperature resulting in the same average energy, determined by {\rm Tr}(H\rho)={\rm Tr}(H\gamma_{\beta^{*}}) . The effective \beta^{*} is the unique minimizer of the function \beta\mapsto S(\rho|\gamma_{\beta}) , the von Neumann relative entropy of \rho with respect to the Gibbs state. An approach parallel to standard (equilibrium) thermodynamics is developed in [ 1 ] , where a non-equilibrium temperature is constructed as the partial derivative of the von Neumann entropy with respect to an internal energy. In the current work we follow a more concrete, operational strategy for defining the temperature, in line with some previous work [ 17 ] . There a contact temperature is defined for classical thermodynamical systems. The idea is to couple the system in a non equilibrium state to a thermostat in equilibrium and to analyze for which thermostat temperature the total heat exchange through the contact boundary vanishes. In the current paper we develop this idea for quantum systems. We assign a temperature to arbitrary states \rho of any (finite dimensional) quantum system by coupling it to a thermometer or thermostat, an (infinite dimensional) quantum system in thermal equilibrium. The contact with the thermometer is mediated by an interaction producing equal transition probabilities between all system+thermometer states at a fixed total energy. We show that this results in a single value of the thermometer temperature before the coupling, for which the heat flow vanishes. This value is the effective contact temperature of the system. The contact temperature can be positive or negative, as is the case for virtual temperatures in thermal machines [ 2 ] and effective temperatures of a related approach [ 14 ] , where the authors introduce two temperatures \beta_{c} and \beta_{h} (cold and hot) associated to a quantum state \rho , defined by the ability of the system in the state \rho to either furnish or extract energy when coupled to reservoirs. 1.1 Outline of approach and of main results We now explain our main results in a somewhat informal way and we present the rigorous aspects in the coming sections. The system, called {\rm A} , is a d -level quantum system with a Hamiltonian H_{\rm A} having non-degenerate energies \varepsilon_{1}<\cdots<\varepsilon_{d} . The thermometer, or system {\rm B} , has Hamiltonian H_{\rm B} with eigenvalues \eta_{k}=k/N , k=0,1,\ldots and N large. {\rm A} and {\rm B} are coupled by an energy exchange interaction described by a thermal process U , a unitary acting on the total complex {\rm A}+{\rm B} , having the commutation property [U,H_{\rm A}+H_{\rm B}]=0. As a consequence of the commutation property, a change in the energy of {\rm A} is entirely due to a change in the energy of {\rm B} and vice versa. Given a state (density matrix) \rho of {\rm A} , our main quantity of interest is the change in the energy of {\rm A} due to the contact with {\rm B} in the Gibbs state \tau_{\beta}=\frac{e^{-\beta H_{\rm B}}}{{\rm Tr}e^{-\beta H_{\rm B}}}, which is given by Q_{\rm A}(\beta)=\mathrm{Tr}_{{\rm A}{\rm B}}{\big(U(\rho\otimes\tau_{\beta})U^{*}H_{\rm A}\big)}-\mathrm{Tr}_{\rm A}{(\rho H_{\rm A})}. The state \rho\otimes\tau_{\beta} of A+B before the contact is factorized, and so the energy change may be interpreted as heat. We call Q_{\rm A}(\beta) the energy (or heat) flow resulting from the contact with the thermometer. The thermometer Gibbs state \tau_{\beta} is defined only for \beta>0 as {\rm Tr}e^{-\beta H_{\rm B}}=\infty for \beta\leq 0 , because {\rm B} has infinitely many energy levels. Thus in the above definition of Q_{\rm A}(\beta) we consider \beta>0 . As expected, the flow vanishes if {\rm A} is in the Gibbs state at the same temperature as {\rm B} : for \rho=\gamma_{\beta} we have Q_{\rm A}(\beta)=0 , which follows from the commutation property [U,H_{\rm A}+H_{\rm B}]=0 . In order to guarantee a good thermal contact between {\rm A} and {\rm B} , the two systems should be able to exchange energy. In the theory of open quantum systems, particularly in weak coupling regimes, well-coupledness is often stated as a ‘Fermi Golden Rule’ condition. While the interaction in the present work is not scaled by any coupling constant, our well-coupledness condition shares the same two central physical aspects with the Fermi Golden Rule. Namely, the system and thermometer (reservoir) should have compatible Bohr energies (energy differences) and the interaction should allow energy transitions in tandem, within the system and the reservoir. In the current setup the total energy is conserved by U , so that energetic transitions in {\rm A} must be accompanied by equal and opposite energetic transitions in {\rm B} , that is, the Bohr energies of {\rm A} should also be Bohr energies of {\rm B} . Given that the thermometer spectrum is k/N , k=0,1,\ldots this leads us to the following assumption. (i) For all \ell,m , the difference |\varepsilon_{\ell}-\varepsilon_{m}| must be a multiple of 1/N . In order to allow for energy exchange transitions, the unitary U must have non-vanishing matrix elements between energy eigenstates of H_{\rm A}+H_{\rm B} . We consider a thermal contact for which all equal energy transitions are equiprobable . Namely, we assume that (ii) The transition probabilities induced by U , between any two equal energy eigenstates of the uncoupled Hamiltonian H_{\rm A}+H_{\rm B} , are the same. The equal probability property (ii) is an expression of randomness , which we think is natural for complex or ‘generic’ systems. Namely, we show in Section 2 that for the purpose of the heat flow, the property (ii) is equivalent to taking the unitary U as a random operator, drawn according to the unique, bi-invariant probability measure on the unitary group (the Haar measure). Besides its spectrum, the manner how the thermometer couples to systems {\rm S} is an equally important part of its definition. In our model this manner is encoded in the operator U which depends on the spectrum of {\rm S} due to the condition (ii). Part