Correlation is magic in electronic structure Hamiltonians

Basie Seibert, Sam Alterman, Qingfeng Wang, Feng Qian (钱丰), Akimasa Miyake, Peter J. Love · 2026

Read Correlation is magic in electronic structure Hamiltonians by Basie Seibert, Sam Alterman, Qingfeng Wang, Feng Qian (钱丰), Akimasa Miyake, Peter J. Love (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31799.txt.

Introduction

Seibert and five colleagues tie a classic chemistry quantity, correlation energy, to a quantum resource called magic. Magic measures how far a quantum state sits from the stabilizer states that classical computers can simulate easily. It is quantified here by the 2-stabilizer Rényi entropy. Electronic ground states carry both entanglement and magic, yet their resource content was poorly mapped.

Perturbation calculations show the entropy is proportional to a state's overlap with a reference stabilizer state. For post-Hartree-Fock states it tracks the correlation energy recovered. Simulations on 190 molecular species confirm the linear links for weakly and moderately correlated systems. The relations break past the Coulson-Fischer point, where Hartree-Fock itself fails badly.

Catalog record

CREATORBasie Seibert, Sam Alterman, Qingfeng Wang, Feng Qian (钱丰), Akimasa Miyake, Peter J. Love
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE116 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31799

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Correlation is magic in electronic structure Hamiltonians Basie Seibert, Sam Alterman, Qingfeng Wang, Feng Qian (钱丰), Akimasa Miyake, Peter J. Love Abstract The gate and qubit requirements of quantum computations of electronic structure have been extensively studied. However, the quantum resources present in electronic ground states, as measured by entanglement and magic, remain less well understood. We study the relationship between correlation in electronic structure Hamiltonians and magic as measured by the 2 2 -stabilizer Rényi entropy ( 2 2 -SRE). Perturbative calculations show that the 2 2 -SRE of a given state is proportional to its overlap with a reference stabilizer state. In the context of quantum chemistry, this links the magic of electronic structure ground states to their Hartree-Fock weight, an established measure of electronic correlation. We then show that the 2 2 -SRE of post-Hartree-Fock ground states is proportional to the correlation energy they recover. We explore this connection through the contextual subspace (CS) method. We present a theoretical framework showing that the CS method can be used to monotonically vary the magic of approximate CS ground states, and we prove that the correlation energy recovered by the CS ground states is proportional to the magic present in the approximate ground state. We present simulation results using 190 molecular species under Jordan-Wigner encoding at a range of bond lengths. The linear relationships between magic and correlation are robust across the Hamiltonians in our dataset, but break down at bond lengths beyond the Coulson-Fischer point, where Hartree-Fock fails to capture key physical features of the true ground state wavefunction. By establishing linear relationships for both correlation energy and Hartree-Fock reference weight with the 2 2 -SRE, we conclude that for weakly- and moderately-correlated electronic structure Hamiltonians, the correlation is directly represented by 2 2 -SRE, and thus by the magic. gbsn I Introduction The electronic structure problem is the determination of the electronic energy given the position of the nuclei. Classical Hartree-Fock (HF) methods approximately solve the electronic structure problem by restricting the ground state to a single Slater determinant. The full configuration interaction (FCI) method represents the ground state in a linear combination of Slater determinants, but has historically been challenging to implement on classical computers for large molecules of interest Lewars 2003 ; Szabo and Ostlund 2012 ; Helgaker et al. 2013 . The difference between the FCI energy and the HF energy is the correlation energy . Recovery of the correlation energy is the target of all post-Hartree-Fock methods Löwdin 1954 ; Löwdin 1995 ; Lewars 2003 ; Szabo and Ostlund 2012 ; Helgaker et al. 2013 . Electronic structure calculations have been of interest as applications of quantum computers for almost two decades Aspuru-Guzik et al. 2005 ; Lanyon et al. 2010 ; Whitfield et al. 2011 ; Kassal et al. 2011 ; McArdle et al. 2020 ; Schleich and Aspuru-Guzik 2025 . Small numbers of qubits can represent FCI problems whose dimension puts them out of reach of direct simulation on classical supercomputers. However, quantum algorithms must exploit problem structure to, for example, prepare ground states. This problem structure can also be exploited by classical algorithms, leading to a competition between quantum and classical heuristics that is closer than naive estimates would suggest Lee et al. 2023 . This motivates the development of algorithms for problems in chemistry beyond FCI electronic structure Bauer et al. 2020 ; Chen and Chan . It also motivates study of the quantum resources present in chemical ground states, so that the quantum and classical cost of various heuristics can be stated in terms of these resources. This is the topic of the present paper. Entanglement has long been a characteristic of uniquely quantum phenomena, and is the prototypical quantum resource Schrödinger 1935 . However, it has long been understood that entanglement alone is insufficient to explain the power of quantum computation. For example, stabilizer states are highly entangled, yet the Gottesman-Knill Theorem tells us that Clifford operations acting on stabilizer states can be efficiently simulated on classical computers Nielsen and Chuang 2010 . This motivates the study of resource theory that includes both entanglement and non-stabilizerness. For example, Bravyi and Gosset gave an algorithm for the simulation of circuits over the Clifford +T gate set in which the simulation cost rises exponentially with the number of T gates, but only polynomially with the number of qubits Bravyi and Gosset 2016 ; Bravyi et al. 2019 . The property of non-stabilizerness, also known as magic, has previously been linked with other notions of non-classicality in quantum information theory including contextuality Howard et al. 2014 ; Bermejo-Vega et al. 2017 and Wigner negativity Spekkens 2008 ; Kocia and Love 2017 . The resource theory of magic has been developed significantly in recent years Veitch et al. 2014 ; Bermejo-Vega et al. 2017 , with stabilizer Rényi entropy (SRE) emerging as a convenient measure for the amount of magic in any given quantum state Leone et al. 2022 ; Leone and Bittel 2024 ; Bittel and Leone 2026 . Previous work has connected the amount of magic in a given quantum state to the number of non-Clifford gates required to prepare it Haug et al. 2025 ; Oliviero et al. 2022a ; Beverland et al. 2020 . There is also a growing body of literature which considers the quantum computational resources themselves as measures related to physical structures White et al. 2021 ; Robin and Savage 2025 ; Chernyshev et al. 2025 ; Falcão et al. 2025 ; Cao et al. 2025 ; White and White 2024 ; Gargalionis et al. ; Aoude et al. ; Tarabunga et al. 2023 ; Oliviero et al. 2022b ; Turkeshi et al. 2025 ; CMS Collaboration 2025 . In this paper we connect the resources which distinguish quantum from classical computation to the physics of electronic structure Hamiltonians. We examine the SRE of a given quantum state as a distance measure relative to a reference stabilizer state Bittel and Leone 2026 . We show that, when the state has large overlap with the reference stabilizer state, there is a linear relationship between the SRE and the overlap. For chemical systems, this is equivalent to saying the magic is proportional to the Hartree-Fock reference weight, an established measure of electronic correlation Xu et al. 2023 ; Helgaker et al. 2013 ; Lee and Taylor 1989 ; Izsák et al. 2023 . The requirement that the overlap with a reference stabilizer state is large is equivalent to stating that the state is weakly- or moderately-correlated in electronic structure Hamiltonians. We then show that, within the weakly- and moderately-correlated regime, the correlation energy recovered by a post-Hartree-Fock state is linearly proportional to its magic. Drawing on the established connection between magic and contextuality Howard et al. 2014 ; Bermejo-Vega et al. 2017 ; Spekkens 2008 ; Kocia and Love 2017 , we utilize the contextual subspace (CS) method to probe the role of magic in physical systems. First introduced as part of the contextual subspace variational quantum eigensolver Kirby et al. 2021 ; Ralli et al. 2023 ; Weaving et al. 2023a , the CS method partitions the Pauli Hamiltonian H into two portions: a non-contextual

Read the complete text