Improving Perturbation Theory with the Sum-of-squares II: Large Density-Density Terms
Matthew B. Hastings · 2026
Read Improving Perturbation Theory with the Sum-of-squares II: Large Density-Density Terms by Matthew B. Hastings (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31765.txt.
Introduction
Hastings extends a sum-of-squares method that gives certified lower bounds on the energies of fermionic quantum systems. An earlier paper generated these decompositions self-consistently, guided by perturbation theory, and beat the standard degree-four method on model problems. Real chemistry problems, though, carry strong density-density interaction terms that the perturbative choice of operators handles poorly.
Density-density terms couple the occupation of pairs of modes, and they can dominate a chemistry Hamiltonian. Hastings proposes ways to build the decomposition in their presence, alongside strong density-dependent hopping and spin-spin terms. One approach is favored because it needs only low-degree terms to reach a closure property. The aim is to widen where the faster method stays accurate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matthew B. Hastings |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31765
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Improving Perturbation Theory with the Sum-of-squares II: Large Density-Density Terms Matthew B. Hastings Abstract In Ref. 5 , a method was given for self-consistently generating sum-of-squares decompositions of quartic fermionic Hamiltonians. Perturbation theory was used to generate a useful choice of cubic operators in this sum-of-squares. On a range of model problems, this method, which is only a fragment of degree-six sum-of-squares, was able to outperform the full degree-four sum-of-squares in both speed and accuracy. Unfortunately for applications, many problems in chemistry have strong density-density interaction terms, as well as moderately strong density-dependent hopping and spin-spin interaction terms, limiting the power of the perturbative choice of the cubic operators. Here we propose a method for generating these decompositions in the presence of these strong interaction terms, hopefully extending the range of applicability of this method. I Introduction The reduced density matrix method (RDM) 1 ; 2 ; 10 ; 7 ; 9 ; 8 ; 6 is a method used in quantum chemistry to prove lower bounds on the energy of quantum Hamiltonians. It is an instance of the sum-of-squares hierarchy for quantum Hamiltonians. While the time required is likely to be polynomial at each level of the hierarchy (at least, it requires solving a semi-definite program (SDP) of polynomial size at each level), the degree of the polynomial increases with the level, so that one of the most common forms is the lowest nontrivial level, the degree-4 sum-of-squares. The degree-4 sum-of-squares is also called the 2RDM (2 reduced-density-matrix), as it tracks two-particle correlations. This 2RDM has some issues, however; in particular, it was shown 4 that it does not reproduce second-order perturbation theory for fermionic quantum Hamiltonians with quartic interactions, though degree-6 sum-of-squares does. In Ref. 4 , it was shown also that one could reproduce second- and third-order perturbation using a certain simple sum-of-squares decomposition involving only squares of operators which are either linear or cubic in the fermion creation and annihilation operators; those cubic terms were similar to those used in 3 for the SYK model, but here applied to a weakly interacting setting. In 5 , it was shown that one could rapidly find such a decomposition using a self-consistent method; the advantage of this method is that it does not require solving a semi-definite program 1 1 1 To be more precise, in a generalized algorithm of Ref. 5 , one does solve a semi-definite program, but the semi-definite program is the same kind as one solves when optimizing a single-particle fermionic Hamiltonian, where one optimizes a single-particle density matrix subject to all eigenvalues being in the interval [0,1] . Hence, this semi-definite program reduces to matrix diagonalization, and in this case it is of a matrix of size proportional to the number of fermion modes. We discuss a similar generalized algorithm applied to the method here at the end of this paper. while it still yields strict lower bounds on the energy. Further, this self-consistent sum-of-squares method significantly outperformed the 2RDM in both speed and accuracy for a range of model Hamiltonians, and also outperformed third-order perturbation theory in accuracy. These model Hamiltonian involved a quadratic part plus a randomly chosen quartic part, with all quartic terms chosen independently and of the same magnitude. We emphasize that while we used ideas from perturbation theory to guide the choice of the terms in the decomposition, the method is non-perturbative, yielding lower bounds on the energy and handling problems which perturbation theory could not handle. There was, however, a major barrier in applying this approach to quantum chemistry. The problem is that relevant quantum chemistry Hamiltonians often have certain strong terms in the Hamiltonian, with the largest corresponding to density-density interactions. These terms are large enough that the decomposition we chose did not accurately treat them. In this paper, we give an approach to dealing with these terms and also certain other large terms. Indeed, we provide more than one approach, but we suggest one approach in particular based on the low degree of terms needed to obtain a certain closure property for the self-consistent method, explained below. This paper may be seen as a sequel to 3 ; 4 ; 5 , and for that reason we omit giving some background which is standard in the field of the sum-of-squares. II Background and Relevant Large Interaction Terms We consider fermionic Hamiltonians of the form H=H_{0}+\epsilon V (1) where initially we take H_{0}=\sum_{i}e_{j}\psi^{\dagger}_{j}\psi_{j}, for some scalars e_{j}>0 , where \psi^{\dagger}_{j},\psi_{j} are fermionic creation and annihilation operators, with a total of n fermionic modes, where \epsilon is a scalar, and where V is quartic in the fermionic creation and annihilation operators and V is normal ordered. In Ref. 5 , this general form was considered, but then later spin and number conservation were used for speed in a numerical implementation of the self-consistent method. Here, we will not use spin and number conservation. Further, our choice of H_{0} assumes that all e_{j} are positive. Doing this may require performing a particle-hole conjugation on some of the fermioni modes. II.1 Self-Consistent Sum-of-Squares The self-consistent sum-of-squares method of Ref. 5 finds a sum-of-squares decomposition of H as H=\sum_{i}e^{\prime}_{i}\Bigl(\psi^{\prime}_{i}+\tau_{i}\Bigr)^{\dagger}\Bigl(\psi^{\prime}_{i}+\tau_{i}\Bigr)+\sum_{i}e^{\prime}_{i}\tau_{i}\tau_{i}^{\dagger}+\lambda, (2) proving that the lowest eigenvalue of H is at least some scalar \lambda . Here, the e^{\prime}_{i} are some new non-negative scalars, and the \psi^{\prime}_{i} are some unitary rotations of the \psi_{i} , and the \tau_{i} are odd polynomials of degree at most three in the fermionic operators. This use of \tau variables is similar to Ref. 3 , but the self-consistent method gives a way to find these variables. Note that the sum-of-squares decompositions we consider are sum of operators of the form O^{\dagger}O for some (possibly non-Hermitian) operator O . To find this decomposition, we pick some other Hamiltonian, H^{\prime} , called a trial Hamiltonian, which has quadratic part H^{\prime}_{0}=\sum_{i}e^{\prime}_{i}(\psi^{\prime}_{i})^{\dagger}\psi^{\prime}_{i} . We have some prescription for constructing a set of \tau_{i} for a given trial Hamiltonian. Then, from this set of \tau , we construct a sum-of-squares decomposition such that \sum_{i}e^{\prime}_{i}\Bigl(\psi^{\prime}_{i}+\tau_{i}\Bigr)^{\dagger}\Bigl(\psi^{\prime}_{i}+\tau_{i}\Bigr)+\sum_{i}e^{\prime}_{i}\tau_{i}\tau_{i}^{\dagger}=H^{\prime}+\sum_{i}e_{i}\{\tau_{i},\tau_{i}^{\dagger}\}. (3) Let \sum_{i}e^{\prime}_{i}\{\tau_{i},\tau_{i}^{\dagger}\}=W-\lambda, (4) for some scalar \lambda , where W is at most quartic in the creation and annihilation operators, and where W has vanishing scalar part when written in normal-ordered form. Then, from this trial Hamiltonian, we define an effective Hamiltonian H_{eff}=H^{\prime}+W so that Eq. 3 gives a sum-of-squares decomposition of H_{eff} . If we can adjust the trial Hamiltonian H^{\prime} so that the effective Hamilton H_{eff} is equal to H , then we have found the desired sum-of-squares decomposition of H . Since the operators \tau_{i} constructed by this prescription are O(\epsilon) , the resulting W is O(\epsilon^{2}) and so for small \epsilon one may find such a trial Hamiltonian by a simple iterative procedure: start with H^{\prime}=H , then compute the effective Hamiltonian, adjust the trial Hamiltonian by subtracting off the difference between H_{eff} and H , recompute the effective Hamiltonian, and so on, until convergence. This method has two important properties. First, the error in ground state energy (i.e., the difference between the true ground state energy and the bound from this decomposition) is O(\epsilon^{4}) because 5 each term in the sum-of-squares is a square of a term that annihilates the ground