A simulation-based analytic model of radio galaxies II: self-consistent radiative losses 2026

M.J. Hardcastle · 2026

Read A simulation-based analytic model of radio galaxies II: self-consistent radiative losses 2026 by M.J. Hardcastle (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31486.txt.

Introduction

Hardcastle extends an analytic model of radio galaxies to include radiative losses in a self-consistent way. Powerful radio-loud active galaxies at high redshift lose energy fast by inverse-Compton scattering, as the cosmic microwave background grows denser with redshift. Dynamical models of these jets usually ignore what those losses do to the source itself.

Building on an earlier simulation-based analytic model, Hardcastle shows that skipping the losses becomes unsafe at high redshift. Source dynamics and energetics shift enough to lower predicted luminosities in both bands that matter, radio synchrotron and X-ray inverse-Compton. Population models must include the effect to infer jet powers correctly and to count how many distant sources can backlight studies of the 21-centimetre forest, a probe of the early universe.

Catalog record

CREATORM.J. Hardcastle
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY SA
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31486

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A simulation-based analytic model of radio galaxies II: self-consistent radiative losses 2026 M.J. Hardcastle Abstract The evolution of the radio properties of high-redshift radio-luminous active galactic nuclei is well known to be strongly affected by inverse-Compton losses which increase rapidly at higher redshifts due to the higher energy density in the cosmic microwave background radiation. Dynamical models of these sources, however, generally neglect the effects of radiative losses on the dynamics and energetics of the sources themselves. In the framework of an analytical model I developed in a previous paper, I show that the assumption that these losses can be neglected becomes unsafe at high redshifts. The effects on the source dynamics and energetics can result in significantly lower predicted luminosities for high-redshift sources in both radio (synchrotron) and X-ray (inverse-Compton) bands. Modelling of the population of these powerful sources needs to take account of these results in order to infer jet powers at high redshift, and also to make a correct prediction of the number of sources that may be available to provide a background for studies of the 21-cm forest. 1 Introduction Observations with current and next-generation radio telescopes increasingly probe the active galaxy population in the distant universe, and evidence for accreting black holes in the very early universe is becoming more and more compelling ( 17 , e.g.) . At least some of these accreting black holes might be expected to fulfil the conditions required to generate powerful jets (which are likely to be related to the spin of the black hole and the magnetization of the material in the accretion flow: 3 ). In the local Universe, the effects of these jets are predominantly detected as a result of the radio emission due to synchrotron radiation from high-energy particles accelerated within the jet, but the normalization of this synchrotron emission and its spectrum depends on the details of the acceleration and evolution of the particles within the jets and the large-scale lobes that they inflate. It is therefore important to have a model framework within which we can understand the expected evolution of radio-luminous AGN (RLAGN) at high redshift. In principle this needs to take account of (i) the evolution of the conditions required for jet generation in the first place, (ii) the different local environments experienced by the jets at high redshift, and (iii) the rapid increase in the energy density of the cosmic microwave background radiation, which goes as (1+z)^{4} and drives inverse-Compton losses ( 22 , e.g.) . An important application of such a model would be a prediction of the radio properties of the high-redshift radio sources that could be used to give a continuum background against which the so-called ‘21-cm forest’ could be detected ( 18 , e.g.) . In principle, this absorption signal from the redshifted neutral hydrogen in the Universe along the line of sight to the radio source would give a view of the evolution of neutral hydrogen and particularly the timing and evolution of the epoch of reionization which is very complementary to studies of neutral hydrogen in emission. The study of high-redshift neutral hydrogen provides one of the key science cases for the forthcoming Square Kilometre Array ( 15 ) . In an earlier paper ( 11 , hereafter Paper 1) I described a simulation-based analytic model that is primarily designed to model the evolution of powerful RLAGN, where in this context ‘powerful’ means that the sources have enough kinetic power to drive a shock through their external environment throughout their evolution 1 1 1 This corresponds roughly to sources above the classical Fanaroff-Riley break ( 4 ) which implies jet powers above around 10^{38} W, but of course the ability to drive a shock is also dependent on environment. . The key feature of the model was that the energy supplied by the initially light, electron-positron jet is partitioned in a predictable way between the ‘lobes’, containing the synchrotron-emitting particles, and the ‘shocked shell’, consisting of shocked and swept up baryonic matter from the environment. Equally importantly, though, it was assumed that energy was conserved inside the shocked shell: that is, radiative losses from any component of the system were negligible. I showed in Paper 1 that this assumption was reasonable for low-redshift RLAGN, which was the principal use case for the model at the time. However, as I noted in that paper, it seemed likely to break down badly for high-redshift sources where inverse-Compton losses become more and more important. In the present paper I extend the framework of Paper 1 to develop a model in which the losses and the radio source dynamics can be considered consistently, and show that such a model has significant observational consequences at high redshift, affecting the inference of jet powers, the population of high- z luminous radio sources which it is hoped may provide a direct detection of the 21-cm forest, and predictions for future sensitive X-ray surveys. Throughout the paper I use a standard flat \Lambda CDM cosmology with H_{0}=70 km s -1 , \Omega_{\rm m}=0.3 and \Omega_{\Lambda}=0.7 , and define spectral index \alpha in the sense S\propto\nu^{-\alpha} . 2 Losses 2.1 The problem Let us start by revisiting some of the assumptions of Paper 1. We describe a RLAGN as having a two-sided jet power Q , and since the jet is initially light and relativistic this implies a jet momentum flux per lobe of Q/2c . As noted above, in the absence of losses, all of the jet power goes into the lobes and the shocked shell (the work done on the external environment, in this phase, is all done on the shocked material – by construction, the unshocked medium is unaffected by the AGN). Therefore the total energy in the lobes and shocked shell at any given time t is just Qt . The key simplifying assumption, which is supported by simulations, is that a constant fraction \xi of the energy supplied by the jet is stored in the lobes, while the rest is in the shocked shell. In Paper 1 I went on to derive a dynamical model for the expansion of the lobes through the external medium, which is unchanged in the present paper. However, it is easy to see that at some point a model like this will lead to an inconsistency. Consider inverse-Compton losses, which for a single electron 2 2 2 Throughout the paper, except where otherwise stated, I assume that the energy density of the lobes is dominated by a bulk neutral electron/positron plasma; ‘electron’ should be taken to refer to electrons of both charges. of Lorentz factor \gamma ( \gamma\gg 1 ) and a radiation field of energy density U_{\rm rad} can be written ( 16 ) \frac{{\rm d}E}{{\rm d}t}=-\frac{4}{3}\sigma_{T}cU_{\rm rad}\gamma^{2} (1) where \sigma_{T} is the Thomson cross-section and c is the speed of light. For the important case of inverse-Compton scattering from the CMB, we know that U_{\rm rad}=4.2\times 10^{-14}(1+z)^{4} J m -3 . The strong dependence on redshift means that the energy density in the CMB, and therefore the loss rate for an electron of a given energy, is 2,400 times higher at z=6 than at z=0 . Suppose that the electron energy

Read the complete text