Fork-Think with Confidence
Zena Al-Khalili, Rafi Hakim, Dietrich Klakow, Ji-Ung LeeSaarland Informatics Campus, Saarland University, Germany · 2026
Read Fork-Think with Confidence by Zena Al-Khalili, Rafi Hakim, Dietrich Klakow, Ji-Ung LeeSaarland Informatics Campus, Saarland University, Germany (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31484.txt.
Introduction
Al-Khalili and three colleagues propose Fork-Think, a cheaper way for language models to reason in parallel. Parallel thinking samples many reasoning paths and then picks among them, which wastes tokens on paths that were never promising. Fork-Think flips the order: decide first where branching is worthwhile, then think.
A single seeding path is scanned for forking points, spots where model confidence marks a meaningful choice. Sampling then branches only at those points, and the continuations are aggregated into the final answer. Across three models and three reasoning benchmarks, token use falls by up to 30 percent and runtime by up to 57 percent, with quality matching or beating parallel thinking. Later forking points often yield better generations than early ones.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zena Al-Khalili, Rafi Hakim, Dietrich Klakow, Ji-Ung LeeSaarland Informatics Campus, Saarland University, Germany |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31484
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fork-Think with Confidence Zena Al-Khalili, Rafi Hakim, Dietrich Klakow, Ji-Ung LeeSaarland Informatics Campus, Saarland University, Germany Abstract Parallel thinking has enjoyed great success for boosting LLM performance on reasoning tasks without the need for any re-training. However, existing methods follow a think-first-then-decide paradigm, i.e., they first sample multiple reasoning paths, which inevitably leads to overgeneration, then prune or stop unnecessary paths to compensate. In contrast, decide-first-then-think —i.e., first identifying points that are likely to lead to desirable generations—has been underexplored so far. Following this paradigm, we propose Fork-think with confidence, that first identify forking points using model confidence in a single seeding path, then trigger thinking, sampling multiple continuations and aggregating them for the final response. Our experiments across three models and three reasoning benchmarks show that Fork-think reduces the token consumption by up to 30% and run-time by up to 57%, while performing comparable or better to parallel thinking. Our analysis reveals that Fork-think is able to identify forking points that are meaningful with respect to the downstream task and that sampling at later positions can lead to substantially better generations. Finally, we demonstrate how combining Fork-think with existing mechanisms such as early stopping and weighted voting can further boost the performance and perform comparably to existing state-of-the-art methods, without requiring any warm-up or offline training. Our results establish pre-determined forking as a promising research direction for efficient LLM reasoning. 1 Introduction Despite the recent success of large language models (LLMs), they still struggle to reliably solve complex tasks, especially those that require multi-step reasoning and deduction ( 54 ) . To combat this, research has investigated various methods for building advanced reasoning models, for instance, by running supervised fine-tuning on additional reasoning data ( 12 ; 50 ) or using reinforcement learning ( 16 ) . However, such post-training methods are limited by the available data and can require substantial amounts of compute ( 38 ; 25 ) . In contrast, inference-time scaling avoids costly post-training (or can be used in a complementary manner) by allocating additional compute during inference ( 64 ; 56 ) . Over time, works have devised sequential methods that iteratively refine the quality of the generation ( 37 ) as well as search-based methods that sample (and aggregate) multiple continuations at each step in the generation ( 62 ) . However, sequential methods are bound by the maximum context size or deteriorate with overlong contexts ( 33 ) and search-based methods incur an exponential compute cost. To reduce compute cost, works have proposed parallel thinking as a lightweight alternative, where multiple reasoning paths were sampled only once—allowing compute cost to scale linearly with the number of samples—and then aggregated ( 53 ; 11 ) . Since then, researchers have studied increasingly sophisticated aggregation methods ( 52 ; 22 ) or even proposed to break up the reasoning process again into smaller steps ( 20 ) , however, at the expense of an increased compute cost especially for verbose reasoning models ( 9 ) . Most recently, some works proposed to mitigate this using adaptive methods that dynamically identify and prune unpromising reasoning traces using a threshold found in a warm-up phase ( 15 ) or a scoring model trained offline ( 30 ; 48 ) . One common denominator of prior works is that they operate on a think-first-then-decide paradigm (i.e., sampling at the beginning), which is surprising as there exists no theoretical justification to do so. In this work, we propose to address parallel thinking in a decide-first-then-think manner which has not been studied so far. In other words, we propose to first identify fork ing points using a seed path from which we then sample think ing paths (Fork-think). To identify forking points, we utilize pivot tokens which have been found to substantially affect the generation ( 2 ) and which we identify using the model’s confidence. Our contributions are: 1. A new perspective on parallel thinking based on a decide-first-then-think paradigm and a first method (Fork-think) based on the novel paradigm. 2. A systematic evaluation across three models and three datasets showing that Fork-think is a simple, yet effective method reducing the overall token cost by up to 30% and the overall run-time by up-to \sim 57% in comparison to parallel think. 3. Analysis and ablation studies investigating different factors and showing that later forking points can achieve a substantially higher performance compared to generating parallel samples at the beginning. Our results indicate that the decide-first-then-think paradigm provides a promising new perspective on parallel scaling and that investigating more sophisticated methods to identify forking points could be a worthwhile endeavor for future research. (a) Think-first-then-Decide (b) Decide-first-then-Think Figure 1: Left : Existing works commonly pursue a think-first-then-decide strategy which given a specific input (i.e., prompt & question), first generates multiple parallel traces which are pruned dynamically and aggregated afterwards. Right : Instead, we propose a decide-first-then-think strategy, which generates a greedy seed path first, and then identifies promising forking points to sample multiple parallel traces from. Note, that Fork-think can be used complementary to existing pruning or aggregation methods. 2 Related Work 2.1 LLM Reasoning Evaluating and improving the reasoning capabilities of LLMs has been a long-sought subject of research ( 24 ; 49 ; 44 ; 8 ; 34 ) . Whereas early works were primarily concerned with improving the reasoning capabilities via in-context learning (ICL, 60 ) or chain-of-thought prompting (CoT, 55 ), recent works have also investigated the verification of reasoning chains ( 31 ; 19 ; 14 ) as well as how to directly instill reasoning capabilities into models ( 16 ; 41 ) . Others propose to break down a complex task into easier sub-tasks ( 66 ) or to minimize randomness (e.g., by falling back to greedy decoding) at critical reasoning steps to avoid wrong deductions ( 47 ) . The Importance of Diversity. One recurring property to improve LLM reasoning is the diversity of the generated reasoning paths (for a single question). For instance, 28 show that aggregating responses with diverse reasoning paths (using different prompts) for a single question substantially boosts performance. Others propose to increase diversity by ensembling ( 13 ) or by sampling from a different distribution ( 23 ) . Finally, some methods directly mitigate the diversity collapse caused by post-training ( 43 ) , by adaptively changing the temperature ( 59 ; 63 ) or adding regularizers during post-training ( 17 ; 21 ) . However these methods often rely upon repeatedly sampling the model at different temperatures (or require more offline training) which substantially increases compute cost. Instead, we propose to utilize pivot tokens ( 2 ) as our forking points. 2.2 Inference-time Scaling Inference-time scaling (or test-time scaling) allows models to dynamically adjust their generation distribution during inference and has emerged as a powerful alternative to scaling model parameters ( 42 ; 58 ) . While scaling strategies such as sequential refinement ( 35 ) or search against a verifier ( 58 ) are effective, they are limited to single-path exploration or rely on expensive, difficult-to-train scoring functions. In contrast, parallel thinking (or repetitive sampling) bypasses the need for trained verifiers by independently sampling multiple, diverse