Boundaries in the Instantaneous Formulation of Field Theories
Silvester G.A. Borsboom · 2026
Read Boundaries in the Instantaneous Formulation of Field Theories by Silvester G.A. Borsboom (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31265.txt.
Introduction
Borsboom studies boundary conditions in the instantaneous formulation of classical field theories, the version that describes a field by its state at one moment. Boundaries complicate symmetry and state spaces, above all when gauge fields meet a spatial edge. The work follows GiMmsy's covariant and instantaneous formulations side by side.
With a constant Dirichlet condition, where the field value is fixed at the edge, the state space becomes a tangent bundle over fields obeying that condition. Requiring only the field velocity to vanish gives sectors, each a tangent bundle labelled by the boundary configuration. A Legendre transform then yields sectored phase spaces. Applied to Yang-Mills theory, the results link to flux superselection sectors and motivate a new quotient definition of the boundary symmetry group.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Silvester G.A. Borsboom |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31265
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Boundaries in the Instantaneous Formulation of Field Theories Silvester G.A. Borsboom Abstract We study boundary conditions in GiMmsy’s covariant and instantaneous formulations of classical field theories and show that the instantaneous state space in the presence of a constant Dirichlet boundary condition is a tangent bundle to the configuration space of fields satisfying said condition. We then study the instantaneous state space when only the velocity of the field is required to vanish at the boundary and show that this results in a sector structure, where each sector is a tangent bundle labeled by the configuration at the boundary. Taking the Legendre transform of this sectored state space yields a sectored phase space with leafwise canonical Poisson structures. We apply this to Yang-Mills theory with spatial boundary conditions and relate our results to flux superselection sectors. The sector-moving gauge transformations are not Hamiltonian because of the lack of a boundary momentum, prompting us to propose a novel definition of the asymptotic or boundary symmetry group as the quotient of the boundary-preserving Hamiltonian transformations by the trivial ones. The physical boundary symmetry group of electromagnetism is then shown to be a copy of the global gauge group even when all sectors are considered simultaneously. Conditions are discussed under which the same holds for non-Abelian Yang-Mills theory. 1 Introduction Boundaries play an increasingly prominent role in the study of classical field theories because of their highly non-trivial interaction with localizable symmetry groups [ 17 ] . By the Vanishing Theorem, also known as Noether’s second theorem, (time-)localizable symmetries lead to constraints in the Hamiltonian formulation of a field theory [ 3 , 14 ] . Under suitable regularity and well-posedness assumptions, the final constraint set is contained in the zero locus of the instantaneous energy-momentum map. If, in addition, the gauge group is full and all secondary constraints are first class, this inclusion becomes an equality [ 14 , Theorem 10B.1] . The infinitesimal gauge directions lie in the null distribution of the symplectic form pulled back to the final constraint set, meaning that these symmetry transformations are unphysical, and coincide with the unphysical transformations when the gauge group is full. But in the presence of boundaries, gauge transformations acting non-trivially at the boundary may instead acquire physical significance: on the bulk constraint surface, their momentum may still reduce to a non-vanishing boundary flux. This phenomenon is well studied in the canonical Hamiltonian formulation [ 18 , 19 ] . However, a well-defined classical field theory needs a full instantaneous formulation, including instantaneous Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formulations, as well as a well-defined instantaneous Legendre transform between them and a 3+1 split from both the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian covariant formulations. The covariant and instantaneous formulations of classical field theories have been developed by GiMmsy [ 12 , 13 , 14 ] . 1 1 1 GiMmsy stands for Gotay, Isenberg, Marsden, Montgomery, Sniatycki en Yasskin, with the names of the “main protagonists” capitalized [ 4 ] . In this paper we extend the GiMmsy framework to develop a rigorous foundation for the study of boundary conditions in classical field theories, in particular in the instantaneous formulation. This allows us to understand how boundaries interact with 3+1 decompositions, the Legendre transform, Hamiltonian constraints, momentum maps and boundary fluxes. We begin in Section 2 with a recap of GiMmsy’s framework. In Section 3 we then consider various boundary conditions in this framework. This leads us to a study of the instantaneous Legendre transform in the presence of boundary conditions in Section 4 . Finally we apply our results to Yang-Mills theory in Section 5 , extending results in [ 5 ] . 2 The instantaneous formulation of field theories In the instantaneous analysis of field theories, developed by GiMmsy [ 3 , 12 , 13 ] , one moves from the covariant to the instantaneous theory by implementing a 3+1 split of spacetime and defining the associated instantaneous Lagrangian and instantaneous Legendre transform . We will now summarize this framework. Let M denote 4-dimensional spacetime and let \pi_{Y}\colon Y\to M be the field bundle , sections of which are the fields of the theory (e.g. the affine connection bundle for Yang-Mills theory on a principal G -bundle P , which becomes Y=T^{*}M\otimes\mathfrak{g} when P is trivalized). The covariant configuration space is denoted Q:=\Gamma(Y) . A 3+1 decomposition is performed by first choosing a slicing of M into Cauchy surfaces \Sigma_{t}\cong\Sigma , i.e. a diffeomorphism \Sigma\times\mathbb{R}\to M with generator \zeta_{M}\in\mathfrak{X}(M) which is transverse to every \Sigma_{t} . A compatible slicing of the field bundle Y is a bundle Y_{\Sigma}\to\Sigma and a diffeomorphism Y_{\Sigma}\times\mathbb{R}\to Y such that the diagram \begin{array}[]{ccc}Y_{\Sigma}\times\mathbb{R}&\longrightarrow&Y\\ \downarrow&&\downarrow\\ \Sigma\times\mathbb{R}&\longrightarrow&M\end{array} commutes, where the vertical arrows are the bundle projections [ 13 ] . The generator of this diffeomorphism is denoted by \zeta_{Y}\in\mathfrak{X}(Y) . We assume that the Lagrangian depends on first derivatives only. Then a covariant Lagrangian density is a smooth bundle map \mathfrak{L}\colon J^{1}Y\to\Lambda^{4}(M) , where J^{1}Y denotes the first jet bundle of Y . This density can be integrated over M to obtain the action: \displaystyle S(\varphi)=\int_{M}\mathfrak{L}(j^{1}(\varphi)), where j^{1}\colon\Gamma(Y)\to\Gamma(J^{1}Y) denotes the first jet prolongation. Note that the slicing \zeta_{Y} induces a slicing of J^{1}Y through the jet prolongation. Throughout we assume a Lagrangian slicing, i.e. such that \mathfrak{L} is equivariant with respect to the one-parameter groups of automorphisms associated to the induced slicings of J^{1}Y and \Lambda^{4}(M) [ 13 ] . But the action can be written not only as a spacetime integral of a covariant Lagrangian density, but also as a time integral over an instantaneous Lagrangian, in the same way as for standard non-covariant classical mechanics. To obtain the instantaneous Lagrangian one first performs a 3+1 split of the field \varphi\in\Gamma(Y) into \displaystyle\varphi_{t}=\varphi|_{\Sigma_{t}},\;\;\;\;\;\dot{\varphi}_{t}:=\text{\pounds}_{\zeta}\varphi|_{\Sigma_{t}}=\left(T\varphi\circ\zeta_{M}-\zeta_{Y}\circ\varphi\right)|_{\Sigma_{t}}. We think of \dot{\varphi}_{t} as the time-derivative of \varphi at time t , and it is vertical: \dot{\varphi}_{t}\in\Gamma(\varphi_{t}^{*}VY_{t}) , where VY_{t}\to Y_{t} is the vertical bundle VY_{t}=\text{ker}(T\pi_{t})\subset TY_{t} , with \pi_{t}=\pi_{Y}|_{Y_{t}}\colon Y_{t}\to\Sigma_{t} the instantaneous field projection. Thus \varphi_{t}^{*}VY_{t} is a bundle over \Sigma_{t} . This field decomposition yields the jet decomposition map \beta_{\zeta}\colon(J^{1}Y)_{t}\to J^{1}(Y_{t})\times_{Y_{t}}VY_{t} [ 13 ] : \displaystyle\beta_{\zeta}(j^{1}\varphi(x))=(j^{1}\varphi_{t}(x),\dot{\varphi}_{t}(x)). Here (J^{1}Y)_{t} denotes the restriction of J^{1}Y over \Sigma_{t} and Y_{t} the restriction of Y over \Sigma_{t} . We obtain vertical tangent vectors because the time-derivative yields only variations within the fibers of the field bundle, not within space. The jet decomposition map is an affine-bundle isomorphism and its inverse is called the jet reconstruction map [ 13 ] . Clearly \beta_{\zeta} can be extended to a map on holonomic sections in \Gamma((J^{1}Y)_{t}) : \displaystyle\beta_{\zeta}(j^{1}\varphi\circ i_{t})=(j^{1}\varphi_{t},\dot{\varphi}_{t}), where i_{t}\colon\Sigma_{t}\to M denotes the inclusion of space. The following result explains how the instantaneous state space arises as a tangent bundle [ 13 , Corollary 6.2] . Proposition 2.1 . Let Q_{t}=\Gamma(Y_{t}) denote the instantaneous configuration space at time t . Then \beta_{\zeta} induces an isomorphism (j^{1}Q)_{t}\cong TQ_{t} , where (j^{1}Q)_{t}=\{j^{1}\varphi\circ i_{t}:\varphi\in\Gamma(Y)\} is the collection of holonomic sections of J^{1}Y\to M restricted to \Sigma_{t} . Proof. This follows from the identification T_{\varphi_{t}}Q_{t}\cong\Gamma(\varphi_{t}^{*}VY_{t}) , given by v_{\varphi_{t}}=\dot{\gamma}(0)\mapsto\left(x\mapsto\left.\frac{d}{ds}\right|_{s=0}\gamma(s)(x)\right), where \gamma is any smooth curve in Q_{t} with \gamma(0)=\varphi_{t} . This is a section of \varphi_{t}^{*}VY_{t} , because for every s we have \pi_{t}(\gamma(s)(x))=x . The spatial jet is given by \varphi_{t}\in Q_{t} , while