The Sc, Ti, and V Abundance Discrepancy: Testing High-Mass IMF Variation and Massive-Star Rotation
Soonchul Choi, Eda Gjergo, Youngman Kim, Toshitaka Kajino · 2026
Read The Sc, Ti, and V Abundance Discrepancy: Testing High-Mass IMF Variation and Massive-Star Rotation by Soonchul Choi, Eda Gjergo, Youngman Kim, Toshitaka Kajino (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31218.txt.
Introduction
Choi and three colleagues test why models of Milky Way chemical growth under-produce scandium, titanium, and vanadium early on. These elements form mostly in massive stars, so their yields depend on star rotation and on the initial mass function, the birth mix of star masses. The team runs one-zone Galactic chemical evolution models across a grid of settings.
Rotating massive-star yields with starting spin near 300 kilometres per second move model tracks much closer to metal-poor halo data. The joint pattern across all three elements improves as well. Changing the high-mass slope of the mass function adds only a secondary shift. Tensions remain near solar and higher metallicity, which the authors tie to missing enrichment physics and model uncertainty.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Soonchul Choi, Eda Gjergo, Youngman Kim, Toshitaka Kajino |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31218
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Sc, Ti, and V Abundance Discrepancy: Testing High-Mass IMF Variation and Massive-Star Rotation Soonchul Choi, Eda Gjergo, Youngman Kim, Toshitaka Kajino Abstract Scandium, titanium, and vanadium can be synthesized primarily in massive stars. Yet many of the current Galactic chemical evolution models under-produce these elements at early epochs. Motivated by evidence that the initial mass function varied in the past on the Galactic disc, we examine how assumptions about massive-star rotation and the initial mass function affect the inferred evolution of Sc, Ti, and V. We compute a grid of one-zone Galactic chemical evolution models that varies the initial rotational velocity of massive stars and the high-mass slope of the initial mass function. We compare the resulting [X/Fe] vs [Fe/H] for X= Sc, Ti, and V tracks and cross-element correlations with Galactic abundance data. We find that adopting rotating massive-star yields with an initial rotational velocity of 300 km/s brings the model trends closer to metal-poor observations, especially for halo stars ([Fe/H] < − 2 <-2 ), and improves the joint behavior of Sc, Ti, and V. Variations of the high-mass slope of the initial mass function produce a secondary modulation. The remaining tensions, most apparent at solar to super-solar metallicities, motivate future work with a more complete treatment of the enrichment physics and model uncertainties. show][email protected] show][email protected] I Introduction Scandium, titanium, and vanadium provide sensitive tests of massive-star nucleosynthesis in Galactic chemical evolution (GCE) models. Large spectroscopic surveys, including Gaia-ESO ( 13 ) , APOGEE ( 56 ) , and GALAH ( 5 ) , together with complementary programs ( 54 ; 57 ; 12 ) , have mapped the chemical structure of the Milky Way across its main stellar components. In parallel, high-resolution studies of nearby stars provide homogeneous abundances for iron-peak and \alpha -elements in the thin disc, thick disc, and halo ( 1 ; 2 ; 4 ; 3 ; 6 ; 16 ; 21 ; 20 ; 23 ; 30 ; 46 ; 47 ; 58 ) . These datasets include [X/Fe]–[Fe/H] relations for X = Sc, Ti, and V, allowing their enrichment histories to be traced from metal-poor halo stars to the Galactic disc, where [\mathrm{X}/\mathrm{Y}]\equiv\log_{10}(\mathrm{X}/\mathrm{Y})-\log_{10}(\mathrm{X}/\mathrm{Y})_{\odot}. Interpreting these abundance trends requires a GCE framework, because the measured ratios reflect the integrated effects of star formation, gas flows, stellar lifetimes, and nucleosynthetic yields. GCE predictions depend on several ingredients: the initial mass function ( 28 , IMF) , the star-formation rate ( 25 ) , the rates and metallicities of gas infall and outflows ( 52 ; 53 ; 43 , e.g.,) , radial migration ( 24 , e.g.,) , and stellar yields (e.g., 32 , and references therein) . A consistent choice of these ingredients is therefore required when using GCE models to interpret the evolution of individual elements ( 36 , see discussions in) . GCE models reproduce many broad features of Milky Way chemical evolution, including the main structure of the [ \alpha /Fe]–[Fe/H] relation and the evolution of several light and iron-peak elements. Both one-zone ( 38 , e.g.,) and multi-zone models ( 41 , e.g.,) can match abundance trends in the solar neighborhood and other Galactic components. However, Sc, Ti, and V remain difficult to reproduce. Commonly used stellar-yield sets underproduce these elements relative to observations, both at low metallicity and near the solar value. For instance, 27 show that standard core-collapse supernova yield grids do not produce sufficient amounts of Sc, Ti, and V. This discrepancy suggests that some of the relevant nucleosynthetic physics, or the population-level weighting of massive-star ejecta, is still incomplete in standard GCE models. Several mechanisms may affect the production of these elements. Neutrino-induced nucleosynthesis in the innermost ejecta of core-collapse supernovae can enhance some odd-Z and iron-peak species through neutrino interactions ( 26 ) . Aspherical or jet-like explosions can also modify Fe-peak yields through high-entropy, low-density ejecta ( 51 ) . These mechanisms may increase the predicted abundances of Sc and V, but their contributions and parameter dependences remain uncertain. A closely related Milky Way GCE study is that of 45 , who explored the Limongi–Chieffi rotating massive-star yields in a one-infall model. Their Figure 13 shows abundance tracks for several elements, including Sc, Ti, and V, and provides an important reference point for our comparison. Building on this work, we examine how two population-level ingredients, the representative initial rotational velocity (IRV) of massive stars and the high-mass IMF slope, affect the Sc, Ti, and V trends and their cross-element correlations within the same one-zone framework. The IMF sets the relative numbers of low- and high-mass stars and therefore controls the weighting of different enrichment channels. The classical IMF of 48 identifies a single power-law slope for massive stars, while 29 refined the low-mass end to match local star counts. Observational and theoretical work suggests that a top-heavy IMF, corresponding to a higher fraction of massive stars, may be relevant in environments with high star-formation rates or low metallicities (e.g., 28 ; 15 , and references therein) . Evidence from Milky Way stellar clusters also indicates that IMF parameters may vary with the physical conditions of the star-forming gas ( 31 , e.g.,) . Motivated by these results, we test whether variations in the high-mass IMF slope can alter the early production of Sc, Ti, and V, adopting the 29 IMF as the fiducial baseline. Stellar rotation changes the internal structure and nucleosynthesis of massive stars. Rotation-induced mixing, driven by meridional circulation and shear instabilities, transports nuclear species between burning regions, modifies convective zones, and changes the temperatures and densities at which burning occurs. These effects can alter both the total yields and the relative production of individual isotopes. Rotation also affects the surface properties of massive stars, especially at subsolar metallicity, where enhanced mixing can enrich the surface and strengthen radiatively driven mass loss. Such effects have long been discussed in the context of primary 14 N and 13 C production at low metallicity ( 40 ; 39 ; 9 ; 8 ; 7 ) . For the present work, the rotating models of 33 are important because they predict enhanced yields of several odd-Z and iron-peak elements, including Sc, Ti, and V. In this study, we use the one-zone GCE code GalCEM ( 14 ) with the rotating massive-star yields of 33 to evaluate how the high-mass IMF slope, \alpha_{3} , and the IRV of massive stars affect the chemical evolution of Sc, Ti, and V. We compare the resulting [X/Fe]–[Fe/H] tracks with observational data for thin-disc, thick-disc, and halo stars. We also examine the combined effects of IMF slope and stellar rotation, and test whether the same models can reproduce the observed cross-element correlations among Sc, Ti, and V. This allows us to assess which combinations of IMF and rotational properties provide the most plausible explanation for the observed behaviour of these elements in the Milky Way. II GCE II.1 Theoretical model GCE quantifies past enrichment by reconstructing the stellar birthrate history of a Galaxy and by applying nucleosynthetic yields to stars at the time of their death. The stellar birthrate is a function of both star formation rate (SFR) and IMF ( 14 ; 37 , see discussions