Partially ordering software licenses

Hamidah Oderinwale* McGill University [email protected] and David Atkinson Georgetown University [email protected] and Rachel Hong University of Washington [email protected] and Art Abal Open Data Labs [email protected] and Ben Laufer Cornell Tech [email protected] · 2026

Read Partially ordering software licenses by Hamidah Oderinwale* McGill University [email protected] and David Atkinson Georgetown University [email protected] and Rachel Hong University of Washington [email protected] and Art Abal Open Data Labs [email protected] and Ben Laufer Cornell Tech [email protected] (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-31032.txt.

Introduction

Hamidah Oderinwale, David Atkinson, Rachel Hong, Art Abal and Ben Laufer use language models to compare software licences at scale. Licences are legal instruments chosen and written with little structure, so basic questions lack answers: is this licence more permissive than that one, or are their terms simply incomparable? The question matters for platforms like GitHub, Hugging Face and the Python Package Index, where stacked components each carry their own licence. The team build two comparison methods. One asks models pairwise questions to assemble a partial ordering by permissiveness. The other draws on existing licence taxonomies, treating selection as a combination of shared provisions.

Their analysis recovers interpretable attributes that track with stricter licences. Tracing restrictiveness this way, and decomposing licences into provisions, offers a systematic handle on relationships across the growing licence ecosystem, with legal implications for open source.

Catalog record

CREATORHamidah Oderinwale* McGill University [email protected] and David Atkinson Georgetown University [email protected] and Rachel Hong University of Washington [email protected] and Art Abal Open Data Labs [email protected] and Ben Laufer Cornell Tech [email protected]
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY SA
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.31032

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Partially ordering software licenses Hamidah Oderinwale* McGill University [email protected] and David Atkinson Georgetown University [email protected] and Rachel Hong University of Washington [email protected] and Art Abal Open Data Labs [email protected] and Ben Laufer Cornell Tech [email protected] Abstract Licenses are legal instruments that inventors may use to protect the technologies they build and regulate how they are used—however, the nature of their authorship and selection means that how they are interpreted, chosen, and enforced is largely unstructured. In practice, this makes it difficult to compare licenses at scale—when is one license considered more permissive than the other, and when are their terms incomparable to each other? Currently, there is a growing list of licenses that are introduced and used, but there is no systematic way to study their relationships. This matters for platforms such as Hugging Face, GitHub, and the Python Package Index, where developers publish or build upon technologies that each have their own licenses. Using large language models (LLMs), we introduce methods for comparing licenses at scale: first, in a pairwise fashion to construct a partial ordering based on permissiveness, and second, by drawing on existing taxonomies of software licenses. The former allows us to trace restrictiveness, and the latter allows us to understand license selection as a combination of shared provisions. Our analysis recovers certain interpretable attributes that correspond to stricter licenses, with legal implications for the open-source ecosystem. 1 Introduction Innovation hinges on developers’ ability to protect the technologies they build. Yet today’s legal instruments have not been reconsidered in light of an increasingly AI-driven software ecosystem. In this work, we look specifically at today’s software licenses which, due to their decentralized and unregulated nature, are chosen ad-hoc and have proven difficult to enforce. The lack of authorship norms for new licenses or frameworks for reasoning about existing ones means that developers are at higher risk of implicating themselves and others without the ability to reason about the potential stakes. By nature, generative AI has made it easier than ever to produce new technical artifacts and build on top of existing ones; as such, the AI supply chain is notably complex ( 11 ) with diverse technologies. Software repositories can import other packages, model derivatives are fine-tuned from foundation models ( 16 ) , and datasets are composed of other datasets. When the developer of a technology chooses a license, they adopt its terms. When a user uses the software for which the license is chosen, they enter into an agreement to abide by those terms ( 26 ) . If the terms require attribution to the source, the user must provide it; otherwise, they violate the license terms and may be in breach of contract. Likewise, if the terms state that any derivative of the software must be made available under the same license as the source, ignoring that requirement may constitute a breach of contract. Because of the uncoordinated nature of the machine learning ecosystem and the range of artifacts being produced (e.g. models, datasets, source code, benchmarks, etc.), developers are left to interpret and contextualize license terms that were not written with their artifact in mind. They may inadvertently fail to address the implications of their license choices on other developers, thus exposing themselves and others to legal risk ( 5 ) . 1.1 Toward (computable) software license governance The challenge with governing license selection beyond institutional factors—such as the lack of a centralized authority or established protocols to adjudicate violations and mediate license publishing—is that licenses are much more expressive than typical legal artifacts. While you can consider a software license a contract because it specifies terms under which users may use a given software, there are no established restrictions on what terms can be written or how. As a corollary, the mechanisms by which these terms are enforced are similarly ill-defined. New licenses are written for several reasons, but enforcement mechanisms are rarely described within them and typically have to be inferred. For example, while there are terms of use which govern what an end user of a technology may do with it, it is less clear what terms apply to a derivative developer building on that technology who wants to apply their own protections. Furthermore, for all the terms in a license, it is not immediately clear which party they apply to. Take, for instance, OpenClaw, an open-source agent project with a user-controlled, sovereign technology narrative and released with an MIT license that meant companies like OpenAI could adapt the project and release it under more closed terms that were seemingly misaligned ( 8 ) . Given the arbitrariness of the landscape, downstream artifacts also do not always comply with the licenses of the artifacts they are built on, leading to potential legal consequences. In 2022, the class-action lawsuit DOE 1 v. GitHub alleged that the creation of the Codex and Copilot AI systems constituted a breach of contract of open-source software licenses ( 19 ) . This legal challenge implies that downstream artifact licenses may need to be compatible with upstream license restrictions, yet the current free-for-all of license attachments challenges our ability to make such comparisons. Despite challenges in enforcing these protections, software licenses are considered contracts and should thus be treated as such ( 24 ) . This motivates our work to address the following questions about the ML artifact ecosystem more broadly: how can we characterize and compare license restrictions despite their lack of structure, and how do licenses interact across an artifact and its derivatives? By doing so, we aim to analyze the ad-hoc practices of ML artifact licensing and inform effective policies for governing creative expression in this space. 1.2 Contributions This work presents methodology for reasoning about licenses and unstructured legal texts more broadly, and demonstrates its use in practice. To do so, we: • Present a dataset of 747 licenses (and a subset of 93 exclusive to Hugging Face) with text and metadata (author, version, etc.) and use existing software license taxonomies to characterize them. • Present novel methods to use LLMs to compare and characterize legal texts in a pairwise fashion. We validate these methods by examining inter-model agreement, license incomparability, and model rationale. • Employ pairwise comparisons to produce a partial ordering that forms the basis of computationally evaluating licenses—ranking them, filtering through them, and tracing their permissiveness through downstream derivatives. • Survey the open-source software ecosystem using our partial orderings, studying 7.2B dependency relationships across five major software library ecosystems covering a total of 11.9M packages from 2010–2025 (npm, PyPI, Cargo, Maven, and conda-forge), and find that inconsistent license choice—where a downstream artifact uses a more permissive license than an upstream dependency—happens at rates ranging from 12.3%–57.4%. 2 Related Work Licenses are the primary instrument through which innovators govern access to the technologies they develop, though software and new kinds of digital artifact exist in a gray zone of governance ( 25 ) . This raises the question of whether license choice within a technological ecosystem can be optimally designed, and how the externalities of the choices made by its actors can be measured ( 14 ; 9 ) . ( 29 ) put forth a framework for assessing openness and

Read the complete text