A multi-differential constraint map for quarkonium suppression mechanisms in high-multiplicity p ​ p pp and p p Pb collisions

Renato Campanini · 2026

Read A multi-differential constraint map for quarkonium suppression mechanisms in high-multiplicity p ​ p pp and p p Pb collisions by Renato Campanini (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30959.txt.

Introduction

Renato Campanini maps what existing data force any account of quarkonium suppression in small collision systems to look like. In busy proton-proton and proton-lead collisions, excited Upsilon states are suppressed in a hierarchy. In heavy-ion physics that pattern is a classic sign of deconfined matter. Campanini's work is a constraint analysis, not a new measurement or model. He gathers six tests from public CMS and LHCb data. They cover isolation, sectors around the beam, event shape, momentum ordering, long-range links and the forward-backward imbalance.

Together, the tests rule against mechanisms driven only by local track density or by total event activity. They fit an early pattern instead: global, linked across the event, and sensitive to its shape. The activity level where suppression switches on also matches a known change in soft-particle behaviour.

Catalog record

CREATORRenato Campanini
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30959

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A multi-differential constraint map for quarkonium suppression mechanisms in high-multiplicity p ​ p pp and p p Pb collisions Renato Campanini Abstract The multiplicity-dependent suppression of Υ ⁡ ( n ​ S ) \Upsilon(nS) excited states in high-multiplicity p ​ p pp and p p Pb collisions is analysed using publicly available CMS and LHCb data; preliminary CMS Physics Analysis Summary results in p p Pb and light-ion collisions are used only as supporting cross-system evidence. Six complementary differential constraints are considered: cone isolation, azimuthal-sector equivalence, transverse sphericity, transverse-momentum ordering, forward- E T E_{T} long-range correlation, and the pPb/Pbp forward-backward asymmetry. Taken together, these constraints disfavour mechanisms controlled solely by local track density or by total multiplicity, and are consistent with an early, globally correlated, topology-sensitive suppression pattern. The characteristic multiplicity scale at which suppression sets in is independently consistent with the onset of a qualitative change in soft-sector behaviour identified by Campanini and Ferri [ 35 ] from inclusive charged-particle observables. The result is a data-driven constraint map consistent with an early, coloured pre-hadronic environment, possibly involving a deconfined stage. 1 Introduction The suppression of quarkonium states is one of the classic probes of strongly interacting matter. In heavy-ion collisions, the sequential suppression of quarkonium bound states is commonly interpreted as the consequence of colour screening in a deconfined medium: the larger and more weakly bound states are suppressed first, while the ground state is more resistant to screening [ 16 , 17 ] . The observation of a multiplicity-dependent hierarchy among quarkonium states in proton–proton collisions therefore raises a sharply defined question: can such behaviour be generated entirely by hadronic final-state mechanisms in a small system, or does the differential structure of the data require additional early-time, non-local dynamics? The present work addresses this question as a constraint analysis, not as a new experimental measurement or as a new suppression model. The aim is to determine which physical properties any successful mechanism must possess in order to reproduce the complete set of currently available differential measurements. In this sense the analysis is deliberately model-discriminating rather than model-building. The starting point is the CMS measurement of event-activity-dependent \Upsilon(nS) production ratios in pp collisions at \sqrt{s}=7 TeV [ 18 ] . CMS measured not only the multiplicity dependence of the excited-to-ground-state ratios, but also their behaviour under several differential selections: track density inside a cone around the \Upsilon direction, azimuthal sectors relative to the \Upsilon direction, transverse sphericity, and transverse momentum. These observables separate local density, global activity, event topology and kinematic escape effects. The LHCb measurement of prompt \psi(2\mathrm{S}) / J/\psi production in pp collisions at \sqrt{s}=13 TeV [ 19 ] provides an independent cross-check of the multiplicity and p_{T} dependences. The LHCb measurement of \Upsilon(nS)/\Upsilon(1S) ratios at \sqrt{s}=13 TeV [ 20 ] provides an independent confirmation of the sequential suppression pattern at a different centre-of-mass energy, lending support to the robustness of the phenomenology. Two recent pPb results at \sqrt{s_{{}_{\rm NN}}}=8.16 TeV further extend the constraint map: the CMS Physics Analysis Summary HIN-25-005 (preliminary) on event-activity-dependent bottomonium production, including forward- E_{T} and cone-isolation observables [ 2 ] , and the LHCb measurement of the prompt \psi(2\mathrm{S}) / J/\psi ratio in pPb versus Pbp configurations [ 5 ] . As further cross-system context, the recent preliminary CMS measurement of sequential \Upsilon(nS) suppression in symmetric light-ion oxygen–oxygen and neon–neon collisions at \sqrt{s_{{}_{\rm NN}}}=5.36 TeV [ 3 ] extends the sequential hierarchy to an intermediate system size. In the single-ratio representation versus corrected track multiplicity, the OO points follow the same smooth event-activity trend defined by the published pp , p Pb and PbPb measurements, rather than forming a disconnected system-specific pattern. These preliminary pPb and light-ion results are used only as supporting cross-system evidence. The core scissors constraint rests on the published CMS pp data, while the broader six-constraint map also uses published LHCb and CMS pPb measurements where available. The main result is a combined set of constraints. Local-density dissociation scenarios are constrained by the absence of a cone-density effect. Mechanisms depending only on total multiplicity are constrained by the strong sphericity dependence at fixed N_{\mathrm{track}} . The multiplicity dependence also weakens with increasing \Upsilon p_{T} . Within the comover interaction model, both the local-density and partonic implementations of Ferreiro and Lansberg [ 23 ] must be confronted with these constraints: the partonic CIM can better accommodate the cross-system density trend but is presently untested against the complete differential constraint set established here. The pPb data add two further constraints: the correlation of \Upsilon suppression with forward E_{T} across a large rapidity gap, and the contrasting behaviour of the \psi(2S)/J/\psi ratio in pPb versus Pbp configurations. The resulting constraint set requires a mechanism that is not simply “more particles produce more suppression”. All numerical results used here are derived from publicly available experimental data and figures cited below. No new experimental measurement is claimed. 2 Notation and observables The following notation is used throughout the paper. The variable N_{\mathrm{track}} denotes the CMS charged-track multiplicity in the acceptance |\eta|<2.4 with p_{\mathrm{T}}>0.4 GeV/ c . CMS provides the conversion between measured and corrected multiplicities and the corresponding charged-particle density. When a rough comparison with other small-system observables is needed, we use the CMS conversion N_{\mathrm{track}}\simeq 2.83\,dN_{\mathrm{ch}}/d\eta for the relevant selection, remembering that this is experiment- and cut-dependent rather than universal. The quarkonium production ratios are R_{n1}=\frac{Y(\Upsilon(n\mathrm{S}))}{Y(\Upsilon(1\mathrm{S}))},\qquad n=2,3, (1) where Y denotes the yield in the relevant kinematic selection. No double-excited-state ratio is used in the present analysis; the sequential hierarchy is assessed directly from the separate behaviour of R_{21} and R_{31} . The cone-isolation variable N^{\Delta R}_{\rm track} counts tracks inside a cone \Delta R<0.5 around the \Upsilon direction, with \Delta R=\sqrt{(\Delta\eta)^{2}+(\Delta\phi)^{2}} . The azimuthal-sector multiplicities are defined relative to the \Upsilon direction: forward |\Delta\phi|<\pi/3 , transverse \pi/3<|\Delta\phi|<2\pi/3 , and backward |\Delta\phi|>2\pi/3 . The transverse sphericity S_{\mathrm{T}}=2\lambda_{2}/(\lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}) is obtained from the eigenvalues of the transverse-momentum tensor; S_{\mathrm{T}}\to 0 is jet-like and S_{\mathrm{T}}\to 1 is isotropic. 3 Multiplicity dependence and transverse-momentum ordering CMS observes a monotonic decrease of both R_{21} and R_{31} with N_{\mathrm{track}} in pp collisions at \sqrt{s}=7 TeV, in both the inclusive sample ( p_{T}^{\mu\mu}>0 GeV, 0.3 fb -1 ) and the high- p_{\mathrm{T}} sample ( p_{T}^{\mu\mu}>7 GeV/ c , 4.8 fb -1 ). The effect is stronger for \Upsilon(3\mathrm{S}) than for \Upsilon(2\mathrm{S}) , as expected for sequential suppression ordered by binding energy. Figure 1 : CMS pp data at \sqrt{s}=7 TeV: R_{21} and R_{31} as functions of N_{\mathrm{track}} in inclusive and high- p_{\mathrm{T}} selections. The figure is reproduced from the public CMS/HEPData-based plot used for the present analysis. Both ratios decrease with multiplicity, with a stronger relative decrease for the more weakly bound \Upsilon(3\mathrm{S}) state. The transverse-momentum dependence provides an additional constraint. At fixed N_{\mathrm{track}} , higher- p_{\mathrm{T}} quarkonia are less suppressed. In the CMS \Upsilon data the multiplicity slope weakens as the \Upsilon transverse momentum increases, and the highest- p_{\mathrm{T}} slice is compatible with a much weaker multiplicity dependence within uncertainties. This is the qualitative behaviour expected from a finite-size medium: a fast quarkonium crosses the active region on a shorter timescale, \tau_{\rm cross}\sim\frac{R}{\beta\gamma}, (2) so its survival probability increases with momentum [ 33 ] . Figure 2

Read the complete text