Cosmological Concordance in an Especially Opaque Universe: A Tentative Cosmological Detection of Physical Neutrino Mass in Λ \Lambda CDM Preprint: MIT-CTP/6048

James M. Sullivan, Roger de Belsunce, Mikhail M. Ivanov · 2026

Read Cosmological Concordance in an Especially Opaque Universe: A Tentative Cosmological Detection of Physical Neutrino Mass in Λ \Lambda CDM Preprint: MIT-CTP/6048 by James M. Sullivan, Roger de Belsunce, Mikhail M. Ivanov (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30903.txt.

Introduction

James Sullivan, Roger de Belsunce and Mikhail Ivanov propose that several cosmological tensions share one mundane cause: the optical depth to reionization, tau, being higher than usually assumed. Tau measures how much cosmic microwave background light was rescattered after the first stars reionized the universe. Recent work showed that ignoring large-scale polarisation data and adopting a higher tau eases the Hubble tension, the pull toward negative neutrino masses, and hints of evolving dark energy. The authors fix a concordance tau centred on 0.11 by requiring positive neutrino masses and agreement between microwave-background and galaxy-survey values of the Hubble constant.

Inside that high-tau universe they obtain a tentative detection of the summed neutrino mass, about 0.10 electronvolts at the two-sigma level. Dark energy becomes consistent with a cosmological constant, and the Hubble tension with local measurements eases.

Catalog record

CREATORJames M. Sullivan, Roger de Belsunce, Mikhail M. Ivanov
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30903

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cosmological Concordance in an Especially Opaque Universe: A Tentative Cosmological Detection of Physical Neutrino Mass in Λ \Lambda CDM Preprint: MIT-CTP/6048 James M. Sullivan, Roger de Belsunce, Mikhail M. Ivanov Abstract The measurement of the sum of neutrino masses is among the primary promises of precision cosmology, achievable by combining complementary early- and late-Universe probes. However, these datasets currently exhibit mild-to-strong disagreements within Λ \Lambda CDM and its simplest extensions, giving rise to multiple tensions, including the Hubble tension, the preference for “negative” neutrino mass, and indications of evolving dark energy. It has recently been shown that these tensions can be alleviated by adopting a higher value of the optical depth to reionization parameter, τ \tau , when large-scale CMB polarization data are ignored. We extend this proposal and show that a single, especially high prior on τ = 0.11 ± 0.006 \tau=0.11\pm 0.006 simultaneously addresses all three of these tensions, thereby significantly reducing the need for new physics beyond Λ \Lambda CDM. We determine the “concordance” value of τ \tau by requiring (i) the physical masses of neutrinos to be positive, and (ii) consistency of the Λ \Lambda CDM-based Hubble constant, H 0 H_{0} , inferred from the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and that preferred by the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) and full-shape galaxy-clustering measurements. Within this high- τ \tau Universe, we obtain the first 2 ​ σ 2\sigma detection of a positive neutrino mass, Σ ​ m ν = 0.10 − 0.05 + 0.04 \Sigma m_{\nu}=0.10^{+0.04}_{-0.05} eV at 68% C.L., while restoring cosmological concordance between datasets within Λ \Lambda CDM. In particular, the resulting cosmology predicts low-redshift distance measurements consistent with DESI BAO observations and raises the inferred value of H 0 H_{0} into agreement with the CMB-independent determination from DESI. Furthermore, the inferred dark-energy equation-of-state parameters become consistent with a cosmological constant, both with and without supernova data. We find that increasing τ \tau reduces the Hubble tension with the SH0ES measurement to 4.4 ​ σ 4.4\sigma , while remaining fully consistent with the Chicago-Carnegie Hubble Program (CCHP) measurement. The concordance power of our τ \tau prior further motivates new measurements of τ \tau , for example through large angular-scale CMB polarization observations with the LiteBIRD , CLASS, or proposed PICO experiments. 1 Introduction and Summary The last decade in cosmology has seen the emergence of multiple tensions between precision datasets. Key cosmological data in the early and late Universe have produced mild, moderate, and strong disagreements between the parameters of the standard \Lambda CDM model and its simplest extensions. Three of these tensions stand out, with the most prominent being the Hubble tension , the long-standing disagreement between direct and indirect determinations of the Hubble constant; see 33 ; 2 for reviews. Nominally, the cosmic microwave background (CMB)-inferred value, H_{0}=67.4\pm 0.5 km/s/Mpc 77 , is in a \approx 6\sigma tension with the most recent Cepheid-calibrated Type Ia supernovae measurement, H_{0}=73.17\pm 0.86 km/s/Mpc 16 (superseding the previous result H_{0}=73.04\pm 1.04 km/s/Mpc 82 ). Despite being a problem for over a decade, this local-Universe H_{0} tension still does not have a satisfactory solution, neither in terms of compelling new physics models, nor in terms of known sources of measurement systematics ( 34 , see, e.g., ) . The value of the Hubble constant inferred by the combination of DESI full-shape measurements and CMB lensing is also somewhat larger than the CMB-inferred value 54 ; 69 . The second tension is the cosmological preference for “negative” neutrino mass, driven by the CMB lensing anomaly 77 ; 78 . The third is the preference for evolving dark energy suggested by the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI; 4 ; 3 ). In this work we show that a single, especially high prior on the optical depth to reionization, \tau=0.11\pm 0.006 , simultaneously alleviates all three of these tensions within \Lambda CDM when neglecting large-angle polarization data from Planck , thereby largely removing the need for new physics. Most strikingly, it converts the preference for “negative” neutrino mass into a tentative 2\sigma detection of a positive, physical neutrino mass, removes evidence for dynamical dark energy, and substantially alleviates the Hubble tension with respect to H_{0} preferred by DESI data, while somewhat reducing its significance with respect to the local SH0ES measurement. We describe all the three tensions in the following. The most central tension to this work is the cosmological preference for “negative” neutrino mass. Its origin lies in the CMB anisotropy spectrum measured by the Planck satellite, which shows a mild disagreement between the small-scale and large-scale parts of the spectrum, producing a preference for excess gravitational lensing ( A_{\mathrm{L}}>1 ) relative to the \Lambda CDM prediction. This can be recast as a tension between the CMB-predicted matter fluctuation amplitude, \sigma_{8} , and its direct measurement from the smoothing of the acoustic peaks 77 ; 78 . This excess lensing translates into especially strong constraints on the neutrino mass sum, with a significant preference for zero (or “negative”) neutrino masses 28 ; 66 ; 46 ; 35 ; 45 ; 50 . The “negative” neutrino mass is further supported by the CMB-lensing reconstruction data, which additionally favors a small excess of power compared to predictions based on CMB primaries in \Lambda CDM. At face value, the preference for “negative” neutrino masses is in conflict with particle-physics oscillation experiments, suggesting new physics, e.g. neutrino decays 28 ; 24 . The third, especially timely, tension is the preference for time evolution in the equation of state of dark energy, suggested by measurements of the baryonic acoustic oscillation (BAO) feature observed by DESI 32 ; 4 ; 3 in combination with CMB data 4 ; 3 . In \Lambda CDM, DESI BAO favors lower distances to observed galaxies than those predicted by the Planck primary CMB, which leads to a lower value of the matter density, \Omega_{m} . Their combination leads to an additional preference for zero (or “negative”) neutrino mass, as well as non-negligible evidence for evolving dark energy (e.g., w_{0}w_{a} ), especially when combined with uncalibrated Type Ia supernovae magnitudes. Three aspects complicate a joint resolution of this triple trouble of tensions. First, the dark-energy and “negative” neutrino-mass tensions are partly correlated, as the evidence for “negative” neutrino mass reduces in the w_{0}w_{a} CDM background 46 ; yet it does not go away completely, suggesting that dynamical dark energy alone cannot account for the “negative” neutrino-mass inference. Second, while the preference for w_{0}w_{a} CDM cosmology is somewhat reduced by marginalizing over A_{\mathrm{L}} , non-trivial values of (w_{0},w_{a}) are still preferred over the cosmological-constant values by \approx 2\sigma 74 . Third, the Hubble tension resurfaces across these datasets: the inferred value of H_{0} is low from all of them compared to certain local measurements 82 ; 37 ; 16 , and is pushed to even lower values in an evolving dark energy model (by 3\sigma , see Tab. V of Ref. 3 ). Taken at face value, the above tensions require multiple new physics sectors to restore concordance in cosmology. The DESI evidence for evolving dark energy alone requires a complex dark sector with dark-matter–dark-energy interactions. Accounting for “negative” neutrino masses requires, e.g., new interactions in the neutrino

Read the complete text