Scalarization and descalarization in hyperbolic encounters of black holes
Frederick C.L. Pardoe, Helvi Witek · 2026
Read Scalarization and descalarization in hyperbolic encounters of black holes by Frederick C.L. Pardoe, Helvi Witek (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30865.txt.
Introduction
Frederick Pardoe and Helvi Witek simulate what happens when black holes fly past each other in a gravity theory with an extra scalar field. In quadratic scalar Gauss-Bonnet gravity, some single black holes grow scalar hair, a cloud of scalar field, depending on their mass and spin. Working in the decoupling limit, the pair evolve the scalar field on a fixed background spacetime. They seed pairs of black holes with a starting field and follow close hyperbolic encounters, flybys rather than mergers.
Pairs that could not hold hair on their own temporarily scalarised during the encounter, for both signs of the coupling, given suitable spins. Some encounters also changed a hole's spin enough to switch its hair on or off permanently, an effect they name spin-up scalarisation or descalarisation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Frederick C.L. Pardoe, Helvi Witek |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 124 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30865
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Scalarization and descalarization in hyperbolic encounters of black holes Frederick C.L. Pardoe, Helvi Witek Abstract We use numerical relativity to study the scalar field evolution sourced by hyperbolic encounters of black holes in quadratic scalar Gauss-Bonnet gravity. In this theory, single black holes are known to acquire a scalar hair through scalarization for certain values of their mass and spin. We work in the decoupling limit and evolve the scalar field on top of a background metric. Seeding binary black holes with an initial scalar field, we find that configurations which initially cannot sustain a scalar hair temporarily scalarize during an encounter and thereby exhibit dynamical scalarization . This is possible for both positive and negative couplings between the scalar field and curvature in black hole binaries with zero and non-zero initial spins, respectively. Furthermore, we find that the change in the spin magnitude of black holes during certain hyperbolic encounters can lead to permanent spin-induced scalarization (or descalarization ), which we refer to as spin-up (de)scalarization . I Introduction Ever since the publication of General Relativity (GR) more than a century ago, the theory has been subject to a litany of tests. Historically, most tests were conducted in the weak-field regime, and only a few strong-field tests based on electromagnetic observations of pulsars were possible; see Refs. 138 ; 30 ; 139 ; 144 for a review. However, since the first direct detection of gravitational waves (GWs) in 2015 6 , tests of GR in the strong-field regime have become far more common. In the decade since, hundreds of GW observations have been subject to tests 7 ; 8 ; 9 ; 10 ; 11 ; 2 ; 1 ; 3 ; 4 ; 5 . Further strong-field tests have also been conducted using observations of supermassive black holes (BHs) from the Event Horizon Telescope 86 ; 12 . To date, these tests have found observations to be consistent with GR. However, with pulsar timing arrays 144 ; 93 and next generation GW detectors such as LISA 14 , the Einstein Telescope 108 , and Cosmic Explorer 110 , opportunities to test GR will only continue improve in the coming decades. With these advancements in experimental capabilities has come an increased interest in theoretical alternatives to GR. Numerous alternatives to GR have been proposed, motivated in part by the seeming inevitability that quantum effects must lead to deviations from GR in the strong-field regime 119 ; 30 ; 48 . One such set of theories is scalar Gauss-Bonnet (sGB) gravity, a subset of the broader class of Horndeski theories 75 that are known to lead to second order field equations. The Horndeski theories are derived by adding a dynamical scalar field to Lovelock gravity 95 ; 97 ; 96 , either heuristically or via Kaluza-Klein reduction from higher dimensions; see Refs. 44 ; 62 ; 84 ; 85 for a review. Certain forms of sGB gravity also appear as part of a dimensional reduction of heterotic string theory 40 ; 98 ; 81 in the low energy limit. One of the key properties of sGB gravity is that BHs can be endowed with a scalar hair sourced by the spacetime curvature 80 ; 128 ; 129 . This is due to a nonminimal coupling between the curvature and the scalar field. In some versions of the theory, such as those with a linear or diatonic coupling between the scalar and curvature, this hair is always present. However, for quadratic or gaussian forms of the coupling, hairy solutions can only appear below a certain BH mass, or equivalently, above a certain value of the coupling constant 57 ; 126 . In this case, initially hairless BHs can acquire a scalar hair. This phenomenon, known as scalarization 52 ; 53 , has been studied in great detail both in sGB gravity, as well as in other theories; see Ref. 55 for a review. In practice, scalarization is often classified into a number of phenomenological subcategories. Single compact objects can experience spontaneous scalarization , which occurs on account of the object’s compactness 52 ; 53 ; 57 ; 126 . Under certain conditions, BHs in sGB gravity can also undergo spin-induced scalarization , which occurs above a certain (dimensionless) spin determined by the coupling constant and BH mass 54 ; 72 ; 74 . Binary systems can be subject to induced scalarization , where one scalarized compact object induces a scalar hair in another, and dynamical scalarization , where the gravitational interaction of two compact objects causes the scalarization of both 22 ; 123 ; 105 . Equivalent processes in which the scalar hair is lost are referred to as descalarization 55 . In recent years, numerous works have studied binary BH dynamics in sGB gravity 127 ; 61 ; 56 ; 59 ; 17 ; 101 ; 91 ; 79 . These studies have relied on numerical relativity, both in the decoupling limit 140 ; 127 ; 61 ; 56 ; 92 and with backreaction 141 ; 60 ; 59 ; 17 ; 101 ; 91 ; 90 ; 50 , as well as on semi-analytic methods 79 ; 78 ; 124 . See Ref. 113 for a review on the application of numerical relativity to various Horndeski theories. Simulations have shown that remnants formed from the merger of two scalarized BHs can descalarize if the remnant BH has a larger mass 127 or lower spin 61 than its progenitors. These processes are often referred to as dynamical descalarization and spin-induced dynamical descalarization , respectively. However, it is pertinent to note that the descalarization found in these cases occurs after the formation of a common apparent horizon (CAH) and is thus not dynamical in quite the same sense as defined above; originally, dynamical scalarization was coined to describe the scalarization of inspiraling neutron stars prior to merger in other theories 22 ; 123 ; 105 . The “dynamical” descalarization of remnant BHs has also been studied in varieties of sGB gravity where there is a “jump” between solutions with a minimum allowed scalar hair and no scalar hair at all, as opposed to a gradual transition depending on the BH mass (or coupling constant) 56 . It is conjectured that this jump may create an abrupt qualitative difference between GW emissions from systems with scalarized and unscalarized remnants. In addition to spin-induced “dynamical” descalarization , there are also examples of systems where the inspiral and merger of initially unscalarized BHs leads to the spin-induced dynamical scalarization of the remnant 61 . Here, scalarization begins prior to the formation of a CAH and is thus dynamical in the original sense of the term. Nonetheless, for all but exceptionally large couplings, the scalarization in these systems was found to be small prior to the formation of a CAH. Thus, the scalarization would likely affect merger and ringdown, but have minimal impact on the dynamics and GW emission during the inspiral. This phenomena is known as stealth scalarization . In addition to the inferences drawn from studies in the decoupling limit, GW emissions have also been investigated directly with backreaction. The GW emissions emitted from stealth scalarization were directly computed by Ref. 17 ,