Extraction of the nucleon axial form factor from Lattice QCD using NNLO chiral perturbation theory

Fernando Alvarado, Luis Alvarez-Ruso · 2026

Read Extraction of the nucleon axial form factor from Lattice QCD using NNLO chiral perturbation theory by Fernando Alvarado, Luis Alvarez-Ruso (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30834.txt.

Introduction

Fernando Alvarado and Luis Alvarez-Ruso calculate the nucleon axial form factor, a quantity that shapes how neutrinos scatter off protons and neutrons. They work in relativistic chiral perturbation theory, an effective theory of the strong force. The calculation runs to next-to-next-to-leading order. The Delta(1232) resonance, an excited state of the nucleon, is included explicitly. The theory's free constants are fixed by fitting lattice QCD results at several pion masses. Lattice QCD simulates the strong force on a space-time grid.

Fits described the lattice data well for momentum transfers up to about 0.6 GeV. They also held for pion masses up to 400 MeV. Including the Delta proved necessary to match how the axial charge and radius change with pion mass. At the physical point, the axial charge came out as 1.257 with a small uncertainty of 0.011, and the axial radius squared as 0.312 square femtometres.

Catalog record

CREATORFernando Alvarado, Luis Alvarez-Ruso
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30834

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Extraction of the nucleon axial form factor from Lattice QCD using NNLO chiral perturbation theory Fernando Alvarado, Luis Alvarez-Ruso Abstract We calculate the nucleon axial form factor in relativistic chiral perturbation theory with Δ ⁡ ( 1232 ) \Delta(1232) up to next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO). Relevant low-energy constants are determined by fitting to recent lattice-QCD results at several pion masses, while accounting for the uncertainty associated with the truncation of the chiral expansion. We obtain a good description of the lattice data for momentum transfers up to Q 2 ≃ 0.6 \sqrt{Q^{2}}\simeq 0.6 GeV and pion masses up to M π ≃ 400 M_{\pi}\simeq 400 MeV. We find that the explicit inclusion of the Δ \Delta resonance is required to reproduce the lattice-QCD pion-mass dependence of the axial charge and axial radius, as well as the momentum dependence of the form factor. At the physical point we obtain g A = 1.257 ± 0.011 g_{A}=1.257\pm 0.011 and ⟨ r A 2 ⟩ = 0.312 ± 0.037 ​ fm 2 \langle r_{A}^{2}\rangle=0.312\pm 0.037~\mathrm{fm}^{2} . Our analysis provides a model-independent and systematically improvable parametrization of the pion-mass and momentum dependence of the axial form factor, offering a framework for extrapolating lattice-QCD results to the physical point and for improving predictions of low-energy weak interactions involving nucleons. I Introduction The axial form factor, F_{A}(Q^{2}) , is a fundamental property of the nucleon. Given that the weak interaction is left-handed, i. e. V-A , its effect on the nucleon depends not only on vector form factors (FF), which up to isospin-breaking corrections can be related to electromagnetic FF, but also on F_{A} and on the pion-pole-dominated induced pseudoscalar form factor F_{P} . Therefore, the axial FF of the nucleon is a key ingredient in the description of weak processes. In particular, it shapes the neutrino-nucleon elastic and quasielastic scattering cross section, upon which neutrino oscillation experiments critically rely 5 . The extraction of the nucleon axial form factor from experimental data is challenging and may be affected by experimental biases and model dependence. Pion electroproduction is one of the sources of information about this FF 45 ; 13 , although the connection of this process and F_{A} is model independent only at low Q^{2} where chiral perturbation theory (ChPT) is applicable 15 . F_{A} can also be extracted from neutrino-deuteron scattering bubble chamber experiments performed through the 70es to the 90es of the XXth century 16 ; 43 , which suffered from considerable flux uncertainties and efficiency corrections, particularly at low Q^{2} . The recent measurement of the \bar{\nu}_{\mu}\,p\rightarrow\mu^{+}\,n cross section using the plastic-scintillator target of the MINERvA experiment, by subtracting the background from interactions on carbon 17 , has also allowed the extraction of F_{A} . Finally, at very low and fixed Q^{2} it has also been obtained from weak muon capture in muonic hydrogen ( \mu H ) with ChPT input 36 . Any extraction of the FF requires that a certain functional form is fitted to the data. Historically, the dipole parameterization has been extensively used, employing only one free parameter, the axial mass M_{A} , even though it is not physically justified and leads to underestimated uncertainties. The so-called z -expansion, which relies on the analytic structure of the FF dictated by QCD, has also been widely employed, and is considered to yield more reliable results. The z -expansion has a different number of free parameters depending on the power, k_{\mathrm{max}} , of z at which the series is truncated. The choice of k_{\mathrm{max}} , priors and fit strategy has an impact on the extracted FF and its uncertainty. New z-expansion fits to determine F_{A}(Q^{2}) from hydrogen and deuterium data have been reported in Ref. 42 . A neural-network-based parametrization of the nucleon axial FF has also been proposed 6 . Ultimately, with sufficiently precise experimental data, all parametrizations and fitting strategies are expected to yield consistent results. Lattice QCD (LQCD) simulations provide another valuable source of information on nucleon properties, including FF, which can be extracted directly from the interactions dictated by the QCD Lagrangian. In the last ten years, the progress in this field has been significant 8 thanks to better computational resources, improved algorithms, and techniques to lower systematic errors. Nevertheless, LQCD computations are generally affected by several artifacts that lead to systematic errors: the lattice finite volume, L ; the discretization spacing, a ; the values of the light quark masses, typically higher than the physical ones. Reaching the physical limit from simulations affected by the aforementioned artifacts requires a chiral extrapolation to the continuum, which relies on a nontrivial parametrization of the relevant dependencies. Therefore, theoretical input is essential to describe not only the Q^{2} dependence of the axial FF, but also the effects of lattice artifacts. In this context, Chiral Perturbation Theory (ChPT), the low-energy effective field theory of QCD 25 ; 26 , offers a symmetry-based alternative to ad hoc parametrizations. Once ChPT low energy constants are fixed, it parametrizes the F_{A} dependence on the momentum transfer and the light quark mass, which are expansion parameters of the theory. Chiral Perturbation Theory can also account for lattice-volume and lattice-spacing corrections in a systematic way 11 ; 12 ; 31 ; 34 ; 35 . It is also useful for addressing contamination from excited states, a major issue in the baryon axial sector that has received considerable attention 53 ; 10 ; 9 . There is a clear synergy between ChPT and LQCD, as the latter constrains the low-energy constants (LECs), some of which are difficult to determine from experiment. These constants enter ChPT together with the quark-mass dependence, and lattice calculations at nonphysical quark masses help disentangle their individual valus. This provides valuable input for predicting other observables, such as the neutrino–nucleon elastic cross section at low momentum transfer 19 . These questions have motivated us to perform a global analysis of a combined set of recent LQCD data using NNLO ChPT as parametrization. The main goal is to describe the axial FF at low energies without relying on ad-hoc parametrizations. On top of that, we determine important values of the low-energy constants and keep track of the truncation error of ChPT, aiming for consistent results while testing the convergence of the chiral approach. As discussed below, previous works have employed the non-relativistic approximation or have computed contributions only up to the leading loop correction, \mathcal{O}(p^{3}) in the chiral expansion. Our aim here is to outperform the previous analyzes thanks to the relativistic EOMS renormalization 24 and the explicit inclusion of \Delta up to \mathcal{O}(p^{4}) (NNLO). In fact, the EOMS scheme guaranties that not only power counting but also analytic properties of loop functions are properly preserved. Moreover, the inclusion of \mathcal{O}(p^{4}) leads to a better estimation of the truncation uncertainty, given by differences between orders. After introducing and motivating our study, the axial FF and the terms of the effective Lagrangian that contribute to it are presented in Sec. II , as well as the pertinent Feynman diagrams. The fit to LQCD results is described in Sec. III . We finish with a comparison with previous determinations of the axial radius of the nucleon, Sec. IV , followed by the concluding Sec. V

Read the complete text