Deeply slice knot detection via immersed curves
Rob McConkey, Christopher St. Clair, Tristan Wells, Chen Zhang · 2026
Read Deeply slice knot detection via immersed curves by Rob McConkey, Christopher St. Clair, Tristan Wells, Chen Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30823.txt.
Introduction
Rob McConkey, Christopher St. Clair, Tristan Wells and Chen Zhang make progress on a knot-theory question from the Kirby problem list. Akbulut asked whether some homology sphere, other than the ordinary three-sphere, has a strong slicing property. Any knot in it that bounds a disk in some contractible four-manifold should already bound a disk in the thin product region. Knots with the opposite, deeply slice behaviour would illuminate the question.
The team construct a class of deeply slice knots. They specify a pair: a contractible four-manifold with integral homology-sphere boundary, and a knot that is slice in that manifold. Then they prove the knot is not slice in the product region, using concordance invariants from Heegaard Floer homology. Immersed curve techniques, a diagrammatic way to compute those invariants, do the heavy lifting. The construction supplies test cases for Akbulut's question rather than settling it.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rob McConkey, Christopher St. Clair, Tristan Wells, Chen Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30823
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Deeply slice knot detection via immersed curves Rob McConkey, Christopher St. Clair, Tristan Wells, Chen Zhang Abstract . On the Kirby list, Akbulut poses the question of whether there exists a homology 3-sphere Y Y , other than S 3 S^{3} , with the following property: Any knot K K , representing 0 ∈ π 1 ( Y ) , 0\in\pi_{1}(Y), which is slice in some contractible 4-manifold X X which Y Y bounds, is already slice in Y × [ 0 , 1 ] Y\times[0,1] . In this paper, we make progress on this question by producing a class of deeply slice knots. We construct these knots by first specifying a pair ( X , K ) (X,K) , where X X is a contractible 4-manifold with integral homology 3-sphere boundary and K K is slice in X X . Then, we show the knot is deeply slice using concordance invariants from Heegaard Floer homology. We employ immersed curve techniques to compute these invariants. 1. Introduction Deeply slice knots first appeared in [ 13 ] as part of the search for pairs of exotic 4-manifolds for the purposes of attacking the Smooth 4-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture, which claims that every smooth 4-manifold that is homotopy equivalent to the 4-sphere is also diffeomorphic to the standard 4-sphere. In particular the 4D Poincaré conjecture would be false if there was a knot K in S^{3} , where S^{3} is the boundary of some exotic homotopy 4-ball X such that K is slice in X but the requisite smoothly embedded disk \mathbb{D}\hookrightarrow X whose boundary is K cannot be found in a collar neighborhood \partial X\times I . Recall that if X is a smooth 4-manifold with boundary Y , we say a knot K\subset Y is smoothly slice , or simply slice in X , if there exists a smoothly embedded disk \mathbb{D}\hookrightarrow X such that K=\partial\mathbb{D}\subset\partial X=Y. Equivalently, a knot is slice if it is concordant to the unknot. A schematic of a slice disk as well as a trivial example is shown in Figure 1 . Sliceness is an extremely active topic for study when considering knots in S^{3} thought of as the boundary of the standard smooth 4-ball, B^{4} . When not specified, when we say “ K is slice,” we mean that K\subset S^{3} is slice in B^{4} . Klug and Ruppik introduced a more nuanced property called deeply slice in [ 13 ] . Figure 1. Left: A half-dimensional schematic of a slice disk for some knot K . Right: A slice disk schematic for the unknot, pushed into B^{4}. Definition 1.1 (Deeply Slice, [ 13 ] ) . A knot K\subset\partial X is deeply slice in X if it is slice in X but K is not slice in \partial X\times I . In other words, none of the slice disks for K live in \partial X\times I the collar neighborhood of the boundary. In essence, this means that the slice disk is “interesting” because it requires one to dig “deep” into the 4-manifold X . If a knot is slice but not deeply slice, we call it shallow slice . While the Smooth 4-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture motivated this notion, Klug and Ruppik used it to make progress on a question on the Kirby list attributed to Akbulut: Question 1.2 (Kirby list 1.95, [ 11 ] ) . Does there exist a homology 3-sphere Y , other than S^{3} , with the following property: Any knot K , representing 0\in\pi_{1}(Y), which is slice in some contractible 4-manifold X which Y bounds, is already slice in Y\times[0,1] ? The negation of Question 1.2 can be phrased as: Does every homology 3-sphere bound a contractible, smooth 4-manifold which contains a deeply slice knot that is null-homotopic in the boundary? The relevant result to this paper is the following theorem. Theorem 1.3 ( [ 13 ] ) . Every 2-handlebody X contains a null-homotopic deeply slice knot in its boundary. Instead of starting with candidate 4-manifolds and seeking deeply slice knots, our main theorem starts with a slice knot and constructs a 4-manifold: Theorem 1.4 . Associated to a non-trivial slice knot (with some constraints) and any n\in\mathbb{Z}_{>0} , there is a contractible, smooth 4-manifold that contains a deeply slice knot which is null-homotopic in its boundary. See Theorem 5.1 for a technical version, which imposes some further restrictions on the slice knot. The proof of the main theorem has two steps. First, we construct a 4-manifold and a knot with the desired properties, then show that said knot is not slice in a collar neighborhood of the boundary. The novel component to the proof is in the second step, in which we utilize the \tau_{\alpha} -invariants developed in [ 9 ] , generalizing the \tau -invariant coming from knot Floer homology. Similar to the \tau -invariant, these invariants obstruct sliceness. Geometrically, \tau_{\alpha}(Y,K) bounds the genus of surfaces with boundary K in 4-manifolds with boundary Y . In order to compute these, we turn to more recent technology in bordered Floer theory . In particular, the immersed curves perspective on bordered invariants, developed in [ 6 ] serves as the perfect visual tool to compute \tau_{\alpha} . In this paper, we refine a pairing theorem from [ 1 ] to fully leverage their immersed Heegaard Floer homology . The magic of obstructing sliceness using \tau_{\alpha} is that the invariant depends entirely on the knot and the 3-manifold. Therefore, we have agency in constructing a suitable 4-manifold with the needed topological properties like contractibility. We use this freedom along with a result of Gordon to construct a slice knot in a contractible 4-manifold with boundary an integral homology 3-sphere. This differs from the approach of Klug and Ruppik, who had to operate in a setting with prescribed 4-manifolds (such as 2-handlebodies) and then seek knots with the right sliceness properties. Ultimately, the 3-manifold we consider is the 1/n -surgery (described below) on the provided slice knot, and the knot we consider is the Whitehead double of the dual knot to that surgery. Performing 1/n -surgery guarantees that the resulting 3-manifold is an integral homology 3-sphere. We choose the 4-manifold so that the dual knot is slice in it, and Whitehead doubling preserves sliceness. The tricky component to the proof is ensuring that the immersed curves for the class of slice knots we consider behave appropriately, which boils down to a diagrammatic approach. 1.1. Organization Section 2 details the construction of the 4-manifold in the main theorem. Here, we also give Gordon’s result and provide the slice knot in consideration for being deeply slice. In Section 3 , we define \tau_{\alpha}(Y,K) . In Section 4 we introduce immersed curves, immersed Heegaard Floer theory, and our refined pairing theorems for the context of this paper. At the end of Section 4 , we provide example computations of immersed Heegaard diagrams and extract invariants from them. In Section 5 , we prove Theorem 5.1 , the technical version of the main theorem. 1.2. Acknowledgments We thank Matthew Hedden for inspiration on the project as well as guidance in learning required skills. We thank Whenzhao Chen, Jake Rasmussen, Luke Seaton, Ivan So, Dean